Wouldnt it be cool if tanks were an optional class?

Rexxiee··2 votes·483 views

But they havent been one for the last 3 years...

If you want to win you HAVE to have 1 or multiple tanks on your team, it just makes your team straight up better than a team without a tank, theres nothing you can exploit about teams picking multiple tanks (unlike full adc/ap/support/assassin comps etc), they just become stronger and thats it and the only thing you can do is just make sure your team also has tanks otherwise your team is going to have no EHP, you cant even splitpush them down because riot thought it was a good idea to make tanks lane bullies and duelists aswell (ornn/maokai lmao).

Why do you think there are 5~6 tanks per game in competitive in last 2 years worth of metas?

Remember when ori/syndra were the meta mid? Ppl spammed tanks Remember when adcs were weak? Ppl spammed tanks Remember when assassins got very strong for a few patches? Ppl spammed tanks Remember ardent meta when adcs got stronger? Ppl spammed tanks

Picking tanks is just the awnser for everything in this game and its not cool.

Imagine if bruisers were actually strong vs tanks early game, maybe you could viably play one to make picking tanks more risky and give a team that stacks tanks a weakness (which is exactly how it used to be in season 2, aka the golden era of the game).

10 Comments

Dead flag blues5 votes

Remember a game without a botlane with marksmen on both sides ? [sg-poppy]

Rexxiee2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Dead flag blues,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=zKt70nAH,comment-id=0003,timestamp=2018-01-28T18:18:54.085+0000)

Remember a game without a botlane with marksmen on both sides ? [sg-poppy]

That feel when theres more tanks than adcs in pretty much last 3 years of competitive play outside of the short moment right after the adc class update.

Need Gold 4 Tent3 votes

I could say that about ADC

Sujiren3 votes

Tank team comps only work, because of insane hyper carries like Tristana KogMaw Twitch. You could legit play 3 tanks like Braum Sejuani Maokai and some supportive midlaner like Orianna and that Tristana is just never gonna die in those fights, while killing everybody. Now imagine you had Jhin as your adc, that team would not work if game is even somewhat close.

Rexxiee1 votes

{quoted}

Tank team comps only work, because of insane hyper carries like Tristana KogMaw Twitch. You could legit play 3 tanks like Braum Sejuani Maokai and some supportive midlaner like Orianna and that Tristana is just never gonna die in those fights, while killing everybody. Now imagine you had Jhin as your adc, that team would not work if game is even somewhat close.

That is just completely false.

Back when the meta was lethality adcs with mf/jhin/varus in every game tanks were still spammed.

Nice try though.

Sujiren2 votes

If both teams had lethality adcs, then both teams are in.exact same spot though. Now if one side had Jhin and 3 tanks, the otherTristana and 3 tanks, pretty clear which team would win if game went past 30min.

redniwediS2 votes

The last time they were optional it was because tanks had low damage, and couldn't be used to their full potential without a coordinated team.

Tanks are not really designed to be beaten in a rock-paper-scissors style like other classes are, otherwise they can just be completely shut down. I think the only real way to make them optional is to weaken their damage threat, and, while I don't see that as necessary, if the goal is to make them an optional class I think this has to be the way you do it. Some damage could be shifted into new mechanics closer to Leona's passive, where it requires allies to activate said damage, though that won't work well on Tanks that are solo laners.

All this said top lane tanks could be weakened slightly when it comes to their matchup against non-juggernauts. A good juggernaut player can handle the strong top lane tanks with relative ease, but unless we want every top laner to learn a juggernaut alongside whatever they specialize in something might need to be changed.

Diamond2Kappa1 votes

Remember when assassins got very strong for a few patches?

no lul

Rexxiee1 votes

{quoted}

no lul

Forgot the patch where they introducted lethality before they nerfed it all?

Diamond2Kappa2 votes

Actually that rings a bell. 2 years ago assassins were good for a few patches, but only AD ones hehe

More from Gameplay

More by Rexxiee