ELO Hell - Finally Realized Root Cause
So. I was explaining to someone else why they are having an issue, and in my rambling I figured it out. The basic reason for the ELO hell.
Jay Sea, and a few others, have released videos of what trying to climb in Bronze is like. (Jay gave up after one match.) Even despite what your rank IS, match making has always attempted to somehow give a deviation based on performance.
Issue 1:
You are bronze, and so is your team, but two of you did really well in your last couple games so the enemy team is solid silver or low gold... the 3 poorly playing bronze members of your team lose it for you.
Or
Issue 2:
YOU are the one on your team that might be doing poorly. You're being thrown into teams above your rank. They are tossing you against players that arent exactly top tier, but have far more experience. Therefore the entire team is upset with you, and now THEY are doing poorly, or just want to FF, and their odds of victory just shrank into nonexistent realms.
Both have never worked, but there you have it. They also create a cycle of people never able to climb because either
A: They have teammates far below their skill, and the skill of their enemies, all due to a hidden algorithm. Or B: They are being put against people they stand no chance with, pulling 4 others down with them.
Is this the same for everyone? Quite obviously not. Many people DO manage to climb. Mostly due to either luck of the draw, or they are not Solo. It's fairly easy to climb at the beginning of a season, drafted upwards on the wings of everyone re-placing themselves, but most people that complain of Hell came in mid or late season.