[{quoted}](name=Mirage Night,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=v3uWEEdq,comment-id=0005,timestamp=2015-10-01T10:41:10.205+0000)
She lost
- Stacking ability
- Straight up execute
She gained
- Higher Damage potential in a straight up duel
- Potential of higher damage dealt when using wind slash due to not being an execute
If Riven can gap close using 1 or less casts of abilities, she will have significantly higher damage out put if she can stick to the target.
She will lose her assassination style. There is no doubt to this.
Changes to help her if she gets fucked by this change
- Increase % gained by each stack of edge
- Increase shield duration
- Increase dash distance
- Increase Q distance
- Increase base Windslash damage
- Increase Windslash edge conversion.
Some things I would like to add. This "experimental" change is a nerf to her versus the tank meta. Her wind slash will be mitigated significantly by armor and HP. I would assume the damage with the consumption of 100 edge will not compensate for the original "missing health" damage versus tanks.
Riven is also gutted when fighting ranged champions. She now must use at least 2 - 3 of her mobile abilities to gap close and when successful, she has one attack with increased damage, which will put her in the lower hand of the duel. Overall, it's not even worth using E Q Q Q to catch up to your opponent as you will be on a major disadvantage at that point.
You can no longer play the passive Riven in a team fight. You must constantly look for targets to attack with Runic Blade in order to maximize damage output. If you're playing behind already from multiple enemy jungler ganks, Riven will be near useless in team fights given that she can't accumulate edge to keep her damage up, and wind slash will barely bring her teammate ahead in terms of damage since she has no edge.
Some changes I think would help this "experimental" change.
- The original damage OR the edge increased damage portion of her wind slash should be true damage. This will help balance her out versus the tank meta.
- Bring back the stacking of her passive. Except that edge will only generate once after a Q cast. This will help fighting champions with mobility and/or knockback.
- Riven generates 20 edge every time her Valor absorbs damage. Can only generate once every cast. This will help a little bit on generating edge in a stand off where enemy teams are poking and Riven have no target to generate edge.