Aatrox is actually in a pretty balanced spot rn, he could use a few QoL buffs, but i feel hes not too bad, urgot was doing pretty decently too last i checked, if you want an example of a champion thats been gutted, look at 39% win rate azir, but anyways, his ult is in a toxic position, which makes it so annoying, you HAVE to fight him to force him to use it, and when you fight him, he has an 80% slow, and a massive gap closer to prevent you from back off, on top of this he has a crit steroid, and a manaless heal, the problem with his kit, is he just does SO much that they cant do anything to him without gutting him, and its kinda bullshit, as hes not fun to play against as you will lose lane 75% of the time unless you get severely ahead