Hey Riot I fixed galio for you
Q: ap ratio halved now has magic resistance ratio
E: ap ratio halved now has magic resistance ratio
W: reverted to pre-rework (maybe with less armor)
R: reverted to pre-rework
Passive: unchanged
Q: ap ratio halved now has magic resistance ratio
E: ap ratio halved now has magic resistance ratio
W: reverted to pre-rework (maybe with less armor)
R: reverted to pre-rework
Passive: unchanged
old ult
the heal from old W
and some damage nerfs on Q and E
gj you made moakai 2.0 on steroids
the damage nerfs by themselves would be grand
[{quoted}](name=Death by Glamour,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=k9JlhRg1,comment-id=0004,timestamp=2019-01-04T17:25:17.745+0000)
gj you made moakai 2.0 on steroids
that's because maokai himself is a garbage design
But no, it isn't maokai 2.0 Because maokai cannot go midlane and clear waves while laning against mages
Maokai also cannot protect his adc like Galio can
And Galio, (hopefully) would not be able to duel/stonewall bruisers toplane
no you just made a super generalist tank
super generalist tank that has to build magic resistance in order to deal damage
and who's ult can be countered by autoattacks that cc like garen/xin/TF/leona ect..
and who wouldn't be able to lane into melee match ups like yasuo/aatrox/irelia midlane
sounds good
I mean, if he's gonna be a anti-mage, he's gonna lose in some department.
if you have 200 mr that's +80 damage
why bother building mr then? his base with minimal AP would be enough to get by
and who wouldn't be able to lane into melee match ups like yasuo/aatrox/irelia midlane
Sustain from old W and base damage would be enough for him to get by in most matchups as a tank
[{quoted}](name=Death by Glamour,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=k9JlhRg1,comment-id=00040000000000000001,timestamp=2019-01-04T18:40:29.117+0000)
why bother building mr then? his base with minimal AP would be enough to get by
the fuck? his passive is 12 − 80 (based on level) bonus damage
Sustain from old W and base damage would be enough for him to get by in most matchups as a tank
No, his base damage are terrible what base damage are we talking about?
his Q has 70 / 110 / 150 / 190 / 230 base damage, that's complete garbage the %max hp damage is 2% per trick (max 6%) BUT you can just get away from it
his W had 13 sec cd and healed 100 hp if you got damaged for the entire duration, and if you think it's enough to lane against Yasuo/Irelia WITHOUT current W bullshit triggering aftershock then we do not play the same game.
and even if the base damage are high, they can be nerfed
you're taking about making a generalist just because of base damage?
give me a break
you seem to have the difficulty of understanding that gutting his damage will force him into building full tank, which would be fine for midlane as it would force him to go top as a tank.
as you will or should likely know the roles are completely different, as a tank he will/should no longer be able to burst someone down but survive long enough to disrupt the back line. The self healing he will receive from old W/SV/that rune which I forget the name of will be obscene.
again you seem to think galio will remain in midlane after your changes rather than seeing that he will move to toplane as a tank
[{quoted}](name=Death by Glamour,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=k9JlhRg1,comment-id=0004000000000000000100000000,timestamp=2019-01-04T18:59:17.460+0000)
, which would be fine for midlane as it would force him to go top as a tank.
galio base armor is shit
putting him top is asking to lose, especially when he won't be able to do insane trades like he can do right now with 40 or 50 ap
again you seem to think galio will remain in midlane after your changes rather than seeing that he will move to toplane as a tank
Yes he is, just like old galio was a midlaner new galio would still build AP because he has ap ratios, but he won't oneshot you with 1 item like current galio can
and thinking that galio would go top with his 24 base armor is asking to be ridiculous
and thinking that galio would go top with his 24 base armor is asking to be ridiculous
forgetting runes
inbuilt sustain
and waveclear regardless of it being crap
Also he has greater armour per level than shen and sion
putting him top is asking to lose, especially when he won't be able to do insane trades like he can do right now with 40 or 50 ap
…
you don't play a tank top nowadays to win the lane
[{quoted}](name=Death by Glamour,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=k9JlhRg1,comment-id=000400000000000000010000000000000000,timestamp=2019-01-04T19:20:29.757+0000)
inbuilt sustain
and most fighters don't have inbuilt sustain?
like you think that 24 base armor is good with runes, that's insane game knowledge right there
Also he has greater armour per level than shen and sion
nobody cares about armor per level during lane
…
you don't play a tank top nowadays to win the lane
you don't decide why you play a tank and why you don't
winning lane is not necessary, but not inting the lane is necessary
put galio top with old W+less damage against Darius with conqueror and he's going to fucking get demolished, and if you replace Darius by most meta toplaners it will be the same
13 sec cd spell won't do shit for you
You dont remember his old W it seems. Galio into darius would be perfect matchup. His old W healed about 80 base damage for beeing hit reduced 25% for every other hit. minimum of 40 or so i think, Old galio would just walk shielded W into a minnion wave. take 2 autos from all minnions and heal maybe 300-400 hp. That was level 2 W. Darius bleed would heal galio instead of damaging him really. And all galio would have to do is survive 1st murderous 3-4 levels until his armor hits about 50 with runes at level 5.
while i agree with some of what you say galio wont be able to go mid anymore iwht 50% ap ratios. He'd go top despite his bad armor just like nasus if he has a lane anymore.
i dont agree with this sorry. At least not the ult and w change. I'd rather not have him go back to being annie status again (useless unless flash is up).
except that current galio also oneshot you with W+flash and his combo
reverting his old R while keeping his old E would not do what you said
Except new Galio doesn't oneshot your whole team with his flash combo, he only does it to one person while CC'ing everyone else for 0.5 to 1.5 seconds.. Old Galio was a flash Nunu ult that sucked everyone in for 2 seconds.
Also for new Galio to even reach 1.5s AoE CC he needs to channel his W for 2 seconds before flashing (and it slows him during those 2 seconds too).
old galio flash ultying-5 man without anyone stopping his ult/buying QSS meant you deserved to fucking lose
new galio flash-oneshoting you doesn't mean you lose, but it's fucking awful especially when you're a melee champion and you get hardcountered because of that bullshit mechanic that cannot be stopped by ccs
New Galio flash comboing someone without anyone stopping him or the person being combo'd buying QSS means you deserve to fucking lose.
What an argument.
i think the ult could have some changes like a channeling in which he can move about before it releases to help it. But over all his old ult would be harder to pull off with his new kit.
Pre-rework R with new E sounds busted as hell
It’s almost like “Old Nunu ult with two hard CC abilities” also didn’t sound busted as hell.
It’s almost like “Old Nunu ult with two hard CC abilities” also didn’t sound busted as hell.
Isn't that newnu? And isn't he objectively not "busted"
That seemed to be the point but maybe he means the other way.
has a similar ult but has a gap closer
is he busted?
No
Oh you great high elo god. Only you could think of such a fitting comparison which we low elo plebs would have never even thought about.
How could he forget of Amumu who has a similar ult. How could he forget that Amumu gains 50% damage reduction from his ult, so Amumu can actually build ap and survive after his engage. And how could he forget that Galio has a conditional gap closer just like Amumu.
Edit: Also how could he forget that Amumu also got a VGU?
How could he forget that Amumu gains 50% damage reduction from his ult
He only gained damage reduction on enemies's autoattacks
And how could he forget that Galio has a conditional gap closer just like Amumu.
Galio's gap closer is less conditional but way more telegraphed AND shorter
http://leagueoflegends.wikia.com/wiki/Galio#1st
ACTIVE: Galio turns into a statue and channels for 2 seconds, gaining 50% damage reduction and Taunt icon taunting nearby enemies (duration cannot be reduced) until interrupted or until the channel ends.
Galio bursts out of his statue form when the channel ends or is interrupted, dealing magic damage to nearby enemies (increased by 10% for each basic attack received from Taunt icon taunted enemies, maximum 80%)
He only gained a damage boost from enemies autoattacks.
Galio's gap closer is less conditional but way more telegraphed AND shorter
Wrong Galio´s gap closer has no condition (outside of mana cost and cd which are negligible) at all. He can use it anytime and anywhere. Reliability is the keyword. If Amumu hits nothing then also nothing will happen, making his gap closer less reliable than Galio´s. And it´s kinda fair in Galio´s case his gap closer is more reliable but therefore also more telegraphed (terrain blocking it and shorter in distance).
wiki is a shit source of information, he only got damage reduction against autoattacks
just like shen before his rework
riot did that so galio didn't get kill during his ult by enemy tryndamere+vayne
Wrong Galio´s gap closer has no condition
it has no condition if you want, it's still more telegraphed+delayed+shorter
wiki is a shit source of information, he only got damage reduction against autoattacks
My bad that I used wiki. Sure it´s the wiki which is wrong, I should just rather trust your memory.
And the old champion spotlight from the official league of legends channel is surely wrong as well, since it doesn´t fit your narrative:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOQGg1-RzWw&t=1m17s
Also a galio guide from 2012 in which you can see the ingame ability description saying: blocking 50% of incoming damage
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2a2_vjjbBBM&t=6m15s
PS: This is rather unrelated since you´re wrong either way but I first thought you meant that he gains damage reduction for every autoattack and not that he has damage reduction just against autoattacks.
it has no condition if you want, it's still more telegraphed+delayed+shorter
So what´s your point?
Amumu doesn´t have any gap closer if he misses Q. Meanwhile Galio has a gap closer independent if he hits his E or not.
Amumus Q needs to hit something to work. Galios E can just be pointed in their general direction.
So basically for his Q and E get Abyssal Mask and they are gonna be as strong as now, except that Galio get tankier :P
They will be as strong as it is currently only early game, then it will fall off
get Abyssal Mask and they are gonna be as strong as now
do you even know galio's numbers?
his Q right now can deal 700+27% max hp with 500 or 550 ap I don't think you would get that if his ap ratios are halved, magic resistance ratios are terrible, look at his passive it's 40%
if you have 200 mr that's +80 damage
It's actually +64 damage with 200 MR, cause passive only scales off of Bonus MR ;)
I stand corrected
To be honest galio would be scarier lategame this way. For damage he would only build liandrys and rylais. then Abyssal sceptre, Zhonyas, Randuins if armor is neccesary or Spirit vissage is MR helps more with cdr. Now his W can outheal an ADC dpsing him. his Q has less base damage, but with slow and rylais more % hp damage, and he can tank the whole team. Why you ask :? old galio during his W, could actualy outheal 2-3 ppl dpsing him if ahead. If this galio gets ahead, he is night unstoppable, and on 40% cdr with a shield that heals when you take any damage for i think 4 seconds, he would have shield uptime of like 50%.
Old galio was not healthy, This one isnt either. I also prefer this ulti from galio, At least its not a play thats insanely good with flash and useless withouth it.
his old ult was stupid broken and 90% of the reason he got the rework anyway.
[{quoted}](name=Snake of Avarice,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=k9JlhRg1,comment-id=000c,timestamp=2019-01-04T19:48:59.891+0000)
his old ult was stupid broken and 90% of the reason he got the rework anyway.
He got reworked because of his stupid low pickrate and because his kit (especially q and e)was just outdated. And if his ult was "stupid broken" tell me why his pickrate was so low.
He got reworked because of his stupid low pickrate and because his kit (especially q and e)was just outdated. And if his ult was "stupid broken" tell me why his pickrate was so low.
His old ultimate basically had a 300 second CD because you more or less needed Flash to reliably land it.
You also needed to not hit the enemy Garen/Xin/Leona with their Q up, Udyr with his E up, or not hit Braum period or else you just wasted your ult. They can all usually see Galio coming, too, since you don't exactly have the element of surprise when having to move into Flash range for your engage to work.
This is true but also counter play to his old ult that was supposedly broken. you could also throw out a long range hard cc or hard cc him when you suspected he was going to ult something like a sej Q when you saw him E flash right before he ulted and you could knock him out of it. but that was more of an issue for full ap galios trying to get pentas than a bruiser build one.
His E is out dated but yet its Kled's ult. His E was undervalued because people played galio like a ranged mage with no auto attacks until they flash ulted when they could have played him like a bruiser that could ult at any time and force the enemy to not fight him just by the threat of holding his ult until he did get a good 5 man ult walking up to people with his E. Which is how i played him pre rework to great success. Also his Old Q is literally neeko's Q with a diffrent visual. Yes he was reworked because his pick rate was low too but thats largely because riot didnt give him any base defenses or a mana pool Galio throws Q 's and is out of mana up until level 5
I say just the changes in revert 7.21.
galio's old ult is an instant aoe taunt and nuke. i dont think someone should have that at level 6.
I have a simpler solution...
What about folk at Riot finally make up their minds?
Is Galio a mage, a tank, or an assassin?
Is Galio supposed to be a generalist or a anti-magic counterpick?
It's easy. He is a mage, that has a slight advantage vs other mages/magic damage, but can function into full AD just as well. They only took that part because it was his identity before, without forcing him to only be picked into AP.
Offtanks also exist. Or the long lost archetype of a "battle mage", who is sturdy yet fights consistently. An AP bruiser.
Anti-AP tank. yes ^^
{quoted} R: reverted to pre-rework
I see, you want the old "I press flash + R to autowin that teamfight every 5 minutes" Galio back.
first thing that came into my mind
hold up you mighta done somethin here
Only criticism I have is make his W self cast only. Was wonky having it heal you off of your buddies being hurt... and giving the or yourself +90 Armor and MR.
I'd take this though in a heartbeat.