As someone who mains both Gangplank and Miss Fortune...
...Riot, you have no idea how hard I fangirled right now. Let's get the good stuff out of the way first, they look freaking amazing. I was worried when I saw VU next to GP because I loved "YARR I'M A PIRATE!", but he still looks insanely cool. Miss Fortune looked like a raggedy Ann doll forever, so I'd take what I can get.
Gangplank's new passive is awesome. It feels so much like his old one, only without making your opponents feel like crap, and not being useless!
Gangplank's new E is freaking AWESOME. I hated how boring his E felt despite it's massive hidden power in AD heavy comps and as a support. BUT YOU CHANGED IT PERFECTLY! I CAN STILL PLAY HIM AS A SUPPORT!
Alright, now onto my gripes.
- I know that GP's W had some serious hidden power with the 100% AP ratio, but I'd actually like to see AP Gangplank a viable build option. Is there an AP Ratio on the powder kegs and his W? I'd be willing to settle with a 40% ratio on his W, as long as he's allowed to have it. Makes Tankplank more viable as well.
- The grievous wounds were part of Miss Fortune's identity. I hope you're willing to give her magic damage a power spike as a tradeoff for that, because my utility build for her just took a major hit, indirectly with the Black Clever changes, and now directly with the removal of the GW. If you did not give her magic damage a power spike, at the very least have the ratio scale with Bullet Time (not the stack amount as you do now), and have GW proc on max stacks. That's more than acceptable if you ask me.
- WHERE THE HELL ARE THIER LAUGHS WHEN THEY CAST THEIR ULTIMATE??!!! THAT'S SOME SERIOUS STEALTH NERFS THERE RIOT AND I ABSOLUTELY WILL NOT ACCEPT THAT!
...ok, now that that's over, I'd like to know who the brains behind the operation was. Because with some balance tweaks for identity, I think that this could be the best reworks that Riot has ever done.
Edit: #4 has been confrimed by Riot to still happen. Can confirm that I heard the laugh to be played on Gangplank's ultimate from FrostyNinja's video. Miss Fortune appears to have updated VOs on her launch, but I havent' personally heard them yet.
From the numbers changes alone, at least from what I can see from the PBE on lolwiki, I'm not convinced that MF is going to be in a better spot, and may be in a worse one. Of course, I'm going to have to play her myself to confirm, but that huge nerf to her W doesn't give me a gameplay boner (her W active only lasts for 3 shots, not simply duration nerf). I feel like they're trying to rework her into an AD caster, but having a passive that applies magic damage scaling with AD and applying on hit effects seriously defeats the purpose. I hope they prove me wrong with the new Q AI, but she could also be completely bug ridden like Azir was (and still is).
As for Gangplank, that's a completely different story. The 100% AP ratio on Remove Scurvy is staying to compensate for the huge base numbers nerf, on top of the just all around buff to Cannon Barrage. He finally has some utility outside of his ultimate in terms of crowd control, and supplements the burst in his kit. However, I'm going to say right off the bat that Death's Daughter is already heads and shoulders above the other two upgrades, and I'm already not particularly fond of Fire at Will. DPS is nice, but from all of the games I've played as Gangplank recently (quite a bit mind you, I'm mastery V) people don't sit in his ultimate. It's a much more effective zoning tool, so being able to drop a 300 damage magic nuke, or speed your allies up is much much better than DPS. Riot may want to consider doing something different with Fire At Will (damage to minions increased?) because right now it's extremely inferior to Raise Morale, and especially inferior to Death's Daughter.
Teal Deer, from a gameplay perspecitve its a mixed bag. Gangplank is extremely superior to the way he is right now (although to play Devil's Advocate literally anything could be better since Gangplank was literally one of the most doomed champions to exist), but unless my hunch is incorrect, Miss Fortune's new kit isn't going to help her all that much, and may actually hurt her late game even worse. Only 5.14? 15? will tell.
has unique taunts for around 30 champions and Tahm Kench gets to have unique jokes for whether certain champions on his team or the enemy's, hearing Gangplank yell to "Swab the poop deck!" 30 times gets a little tiring. But hey, if they can get Scott McNeil to do Sion, I know they'll do Gangplank and Miss Fortune justice.
(I wish he was able to get a traditional skin with his old VO)
SHURIMA!
and
, and then nerf regen on those regen heavy champs.