So I tried to give Jax a try again, only to get reminded why I stopped playing him.
Dodge dodges mord's Q! Which is good! Except it doesn't dodge the magic damage part.
Dodge dodges Sivir's Ricochet! Actually that's a lie all 3 attacks go directly through dodge.
Dodge dodges Xin's three talon strike! This one is true. All 3 attacks get dodged, but the knockup goes off at the end.
Dodge dodges Kog'maw's W! Hah, fooled you again.
Dodge dodges Darius's W! But the slow still goes through. No bleed stacks, no damage, but it slows.
Dodge dodges pick a card! Actually it dodges the auto attack damage, but not the magic damage, still applies lichbane, and does the stun.
CONSISTENCY RIOT. PLEASE GIVE CONSISTENCY.
Jax is at a 49% win rate. It wouldn't break the game for dodge to actually start dodging all the attack damage of special abilities and merely letting all the special effects go through. Jax is in a VERY VERY weak position right now with almost no lane recovery since he has no sustain, no ranged last hitting, and is incredibly squishy. Not to mention that a TON of other melee champions now out scale him due to new itemization, most notably Riven (who has the same base stats as him. Yes, the difference between Riven and Jax at level 18 is jax has 18 more HP, and 2 less armor.)
Think about what letting Jax dodge special attack damage would do:
It might finally make him good.
And before you say "BUT JAX DOMINATES EVERY LOW ELO GAME!" Shut up. No he doesn't. He has a 48% win rate at bronze, and a 49.05% win rate at silver. Jax actually peaks at Diamond with a 50% win rate, then plummets down again at mastes+ to 46% (for obvious reasons.) Low ELO actually holds DOWN Jax's win rate. He doesn't dominate low ELO.