the problem with this theory is when you send a squishy top the jungler and enemy top lane just obliterate you....
if u played
a champ with no escapes and
and
jump on top of you.... you don't even get to flash before u die and even if u don't die.. you don't have sums anymore sooo prepare for round 2 the moment u overextend
"Not only that they also scale regardless of how badly you shut them down"
tanks full build is on average 2000-4000 gold less then that of bruisers, assassins and mages and most tanks have abilities that scale with how much armour/health/magic resist they have... well if you get more efficient stats, faster item power spikes, cheaper full builds and have an advantage in 2v1's vs squishies...
"Champs like this shouldnt go toplane imo"
why would you not play a tank top lane?? you don't have burst at level 6 like assassins, you don't have range if your a melee tank... you cant go mid because everyone outranges you instantly and the tanks that do end up going lethality and pretend they are assassins (lee, riven, jarvan, garen)... your not ranged so going bot lane vs 2 ranged (one ad and one ap) usually would suck... and almost all tanks don't have instant gap closers or ranged cc, and with how insanely fast jungle clears are they don't get a chance to out gank jungers like khazix, lee sin, shaco, jax
"how broken adc and support is atm"
what? you really think this? ive had and lived through games where you cant blink and you get one shot
the only thing broken is whatever riot decides is "the flavour of the month" pick... like how gp has been god tier since klepto came out and hes getting nerfed 2 months after when ezreal got nerfed twice in a row in 8.1 and 8.2.... sure if by "adc broken" you mean the 4 most meta adc's are strong.. you dont see "ashe, sivir, kindred, graves, quinn" (marksman) adc very much do you? misfortune, xayah, caitlyn, ezreal, vayne.. they were all op for a while... ez got 2 nerfs in a row, vayne got nerfed a little, arie got nerfed, percision got nerfed....
edited.