All the changes they've slowly been pushing onto jungle have made it extremely polarized, yes. Generally either both have a miserable experience, or one does because they're outplayed or unlucky in even just one scenario beyond reasonable hope of coming back unless the enemy heavily misplays into you specifically.
You're already 1-2 levels behind, low on gold, and usually not with good waveclear. Imagine falling behind on top of that, and not even being able to buy a support starter item so you aren't a cannon minion. It's literally almost not worth farming camps anymore if you can just go and fight or impact the map before anyone else because you'll fall more and more behind without that due to all these changes. It was a good problem to think about with jungler impact prior to these changes (starting from rift herald which isn't so bad, to plants, to exp catchups and removal, to krugs nerf, to scuttle, and to all the new changes now) but most of the solution(s) just feel awful.