"ADC's are going to get doran's shield nerfed for the melees that need it to survive"
Jesus you people are disgusting. Doran's Shield in it's current state is equally idiotic on Yasuo, Fiora or Riven, all of which are 100% melee.
In your ideal, dreamed-of exclusively fighter vs fighter toplane, Doran's Shield fighter is also almost guaranteed to win lane vs fighter with any other starter.
Basically any champion that doesn't use a lot of mana benefits too much of it.
Not everything bad in this game happens because your kite-able champion got kited.
Downvote, and than consider growing up.