I need help!

So, I'm goinna describe a few games that I can't pick between. You tell me which one to pick, since I can't decide anything on my own. xD

Game 1: I played it for 12 years and loved it, but then the "casuals" (AKA lazy fucks who can't be bothered to put in any effort) invaded, and the game was made so simplistic and easy that a monkey could probably be trained to do it. People tell me that it gets better at higher difficulties, but I donno. So easy that I just don't really enjoy myself.

Game 2: I LOVE the art, the atmosphere, the music, the crafting, the story, the community, everything... but the combat and raids are incredibly boring and painful to do. I burn out super fast, but people tell me it's fun at high level (when it's just the same with a couple more buttons). Just being in the game is fun, but playing it is not.

Game 3: I ABSOLUTELY love this game. The combat is hands down my favorite ever in an MMO, and the raids / dungeons are really fun... but no one pugs anything because of a r%%%%%ed design choice. There's no pugs, and there's not a lot to do outside of a couple dungeons and farming open world objectives.

So, help me decide. T_T I can't decide.