Runic echo is just far worse than runeglaive right now, don't make changes please

KirbyCake··2 votes·1,997 views

Don't know why people are excited when its a huge nerf to the item, I guess the only thing they are looking at are the passive.

Runeglaive 1675 40 ap 250 mana 10% cdr

stats give 1520

modified version of lich bane passive

Runic Echo 1400 60 ap 10% movement speed

stats give 1700

modified version of luden's echo passive

Looks like runic echo is just better right? Not really.

Runeglaive gives well-rounded out stats, mana and cdr, without taking up an item slot. Combined with passive you do not need to buy any mana items.

With runic echo, you have to invest in tear because luden's passive offers less than half the mana regen as the current lich bane passive. In fact the overall regen is less even if you buy a tear.

Example, at level 6 karthus will have 738 + 250 = 988 mana. He can recover 8% missing mana every 2 seconds or so. The mana regen is so great that I almost never run out of mana.

With runic echo, it takes 10 q's to regen 18% of missing mana when your mana bar is already at 738. Basically 10 seconds to regen 18% missing mana which is 25% smaller without the 250 mana.

Note that it doesn't need to be karthus. Take fid for example. He can probably proc the missing mana passive in runeglaive every 4 seconds right now. However with runic echo it would take him like 20 seconds to proc runic echo.

The mana is extremely important on dragon and baron. You didn't need to worry about your mana when taking these objectives but now you do.

Also runeglaive passive is better for skirmishes involving 1/2 people, while runic echo is designed for wave clearing and more damage in team fights. Team fights simply don't happen early game, so runeglaive is actually much stronger early. Combine that with the fact that you must now invest an item slot for a mana item delays AP junglers powerspike way too much. This is why you can see people rush lichbane but not luden's echo. However, junglers must rush thier jungle item first.

Honestly I see no problem with runeglaive for ap junglers right now. It gives them unlimited mana and a bit of cdr, something that is now hard to get on AP. It helps them be stronger earlier.

20 Comments

The Bearded Bard3 votes

You definitely don't have to invest in tear on most AP junglers.

Ekko Still gonna build a sheen item, so he's good to go on mana. Amumu Will benefit from Frozen Heart far more than he would tear. Diana Again, most likely gonna grab either a FH or a sheen item or both. Never tear. Elise FH, IbG, isn't even that mana hungry in the first place. Evelynn Could actually benefit from tear, but most likely is just gonna grab a sheen item. Fiddlesticks Not insanely mana hungry, if anything I'd grab a roa on him if I was going to get any mana item. Fizz Still gonna grab a sheen item. Karma Isn't insanely mana hungry, if anything a morellos is all she needs. Gragas Still gonna go cinderhulk. Nidalee Still gonna grab a sheen item.

Luden's passive is completely viable and actually really good on every single one of them, lichbane passive was not.

KirbyCake2 votes

why are you ignoring the far more important part of the passive?

regening 8% missing mana every 2 seconds with a larger mana pool is worth at least 1k gold more than regening 18% missing mana every 20 seconds. currently runeglaive gives infinite mana for clearing.

as of right now, you aren't even listing REAL ap junglers like karthus or brand or heimerdinger or lulu

DeathBurst2 votes

Lol. I sincerely and litterally "laughed out loud" reading that. Thank you for brightening my night.

That being said, Ekko, Diana, Elise, Fiddle, Nidalee, Fizz are all more "real" Junglers than Karthus or Brand or Heimer. Amumu and Gragas are also real junglers that scale with AP, but I grant you that they build more tank than mage.

You may make the case that the new item is not as versatile and doesn't allow for as many off-meta picks. But you have to phrase it better, and not in an antagonistic way, because if you say it like that, people will just dismiss your post as a useless rant. And don't call Karthus or Heimer "real junglers" ;)

I think there are 2 points:

  • can a champ use a Spellblade proc or an Echo proc? Some champs prefer Spellblade, but some can't use it effectively at all. Whereas almost all champs can use a Luden proc effectively. So I'd say Echo is preferable if you want a versatile item.
  • is the mana regen sufficient? Apparently you're saying the new passive doesn't give enough mana to clear the jungle. I can believe you, but I think this is a problem easily solved with number tuning.

All in all, I think the concept of Runic Echo is good, and probably better than Runeglaive.

BeatzBoyFTW2 votes

{quoted}

as of right now, you aren't even listing REAL ap junglers like karthus or brand or heimerdinger or lulu

[slayer-jinx-unamused] [zombie-brand-facepalm]

Nekusen1 votes

{quoted} as of right now, you aren't even listing REAL ap junglers like karthus or brand or heimerdinger or lulu

are you high ? specially with heimer, he is probably one if not THE worst champ you could use to jungle.

Im done loading1 votes

Well, the Runeglaive item is way better than the new item on Amumu, as Amumu relies a lot on autos. The damage output and mana regen will be way lower for Amumu, and it will get way harder to lock down and take down a specific target.

Dominick Destine3 votes

Diamond Evelynn main here.

Runic Echoes is infinitely superior to Runeglaive on Evelynn because it gives her one of the most valuable stats (% MS boost) and is cheaper.... in addition to opening up her build-path by allowing a selection between Trinity Force/Lich Bane/Iceborn Gauntlet. Basically, it is the second coming of Solid Snake. It is glorious.

The Bearded Bard1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Dominick Destine,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=zlAgedhZ,comment-id=0003,timestamp=2015-12-12T02:53:19.443+0000)

Diamond Evelynn main here.

Runic Echoes is infinitely superior to Runeglaive on Evelynn because it gives her one of the most valuable stats (% MS boost) and is cheaper.... in addition to opening up her build-path by allowing a selection between Trinity Force/Lich Bane/Iceborn Gauntlet. Basically, it is the second coming of Solid Snake. It is glorious.

Enjoy it while it lasts, evelyn buffs don't come without heavy nerfs in the near future haha

Dominick Destine1 votes

Of course. I realize that it is a dangerous game to allow Evelynn to play with the Double-edged sword this way, she is an Assassin that is always... other mastery names.

Point being , I know, she's going to get railed as soon as Riot realizes her viability with the new item.

Nekusen2 votes

its about the champion you use, not all potential AP jungles get something from runeglaive, but more of them can use runic echo.

runic just gives more flexibility, if you want sheen's passive, you can get lichbane next, but if sheen is useless to you, as an AP jungler, you are left without having a jungle item to complete.

KirbyCake2 votes

You're saying there is some ap jungler that can't auto attack?

A lot of ap junglers will be unplayable after these changes just because they don't have enough mana to clear anymore. Just because they wouldn't buy lich bane in lane doesn't mean the passive is useless. The second part of the passive is far more important, it gives ap junglers unlimited mana to always clear their jungle.

I have played ap junglers every season and what really makes or breaks them is whether or not they have enough mana to clear and gank. If they need tear or some other mana regen item, then its just bad because they need to waste an item slot and delay their power spike.

WookieJesuz2 votes

Why not keep both idk

DeathBurst1 votes

Every item you keep add to the complexity of the system and the difficulty of balancing it. Riot tries to use as few item as possible. (Not my opinion, just repeating stuff Riot already said.)

KirbyCake2 votes

So far is pretty obvious that I'm the highest elo player who has posted so far that has jungled with REAL ap junglers and everybody else has 0 idea what they're talking about.

Don't post unless you jungle with karthus, fid, brand, heimerdinger, or lulu, because really you have 0 idea what you're talking about.

Im done loading2 votes

This is going to affect Amumu's potential A LOT! Amumu really shines with Runeglaive, or the now removed Ranger's Trailblazer. Amumu item 3070 (actually, remove the item 3070, we don't have mana for that stuff anymore).

Amumu First they nerf my E, my passive, my damage, my R range and now they take all my items. I have gotten used to having no friends and getting flamed a lot no matter how well I do. Don't take my only real friend: Runeglaive, it's my only friend when I jump in to the enemy team and my own team just looks at that sad Amumu...

Irelia Bot1 votes

Shouldn't you be playing soraka mid or something?

DeathBurst1 votes

Karthus may be an extreme case, because his CD is really short and his cast time relatively long, so you don't really have time to walk. But remember that Echo procs are stacked also by moving, not only by casting spells. And most AP Junglers would want to kite the monsters anyway, to avoid some damages.

Khell DarkWolf1 votes

Both should remain in the game. AD/Autoattackers have two choices, it only makes sense.

And the route of using mana crystal as a stand alone for sheen combine was wrong. It should have been an amplifying tome and then have sheen just give the flat mana from being combined.

All runeglaive needs is a numbers tweak.

Remove and replacing items isn't the way to go. R.I.P. Magus Enchantment item 1402

insaiyanbacca1 votes

at least fiddle can actually use it tbh

BluePolarizer1 votes

I actually now realize that this pushes a build for AP tanks who want to go damage out of the game.

Right now an AP tank can choose between going runeglaive -> full tank to take advantage of their high base damage and try to snowball the game early (or maybe they're the only source of magic damage on the team), or they can just go cinderhulk -> full tank to act as engage and/or a meat shield.

Now there will be less choice.

Alot of the AP junglers are really gimmicky except Fiddle.

More from Gameplay

More by KirbyCake