You butcher Shaco because he is unfun to play against.
Yet

Just wow. Thank you riot, love your balance policies.
Yet

Just wow. Thank you riot, love your balance policies.
oh you forgot fizz.
i love shaco, he just kinda pop's up and laughs in my face.
<3
(as a mid laner, i support shaco junglers, make me buy pinks and hug that turret)
When was he butchered?
Gangplank has gotten pretty much nothing but nerfs since he was reworked and he has more on the PBE. Garen's also been nerfed and I believe Morde has nerfs on PBE.
Except Garen, GP, Mord and Devourer are getting nerfed.
I didn't mind playing against shaco or any of the champs you listed. Playing against Annie, Kayle, or Morgana is far worse. Basically really old champs that are incredibly easy to play, yet have huge impact.
yea but, morg binding slow af.....
kayle is meh, she needs items and doesn't really bring utility, just ensured damage (helloooooo bard/knockbacks)
annie has no counterplay, she does as she pleases, the only breathing room is hey, she could miss.
He has +51% atm, I think he's at a fine spot. Yes, he has a high playerbase avg games, but Shaco's also a pretty hard champ to learn (people will do terrible on their first tries if they didn't thoroughly looked up how to play him correctly) so I think that kinda compensates.
What should be done with shaco is this
His boxes need to have some scaling hp set up for them.
His Q crit needs a longer duration than the stealth
And his R needs to mimic the buffs on shaco as well, meaning it gets red buff as well, full effect, but killing it doesn't transfer the buff
Point well made.