[{quoted}](name=The Loveless,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=qXpJEH3E,comment-id=0004000000000000,timestamp=2015-11-18T17:55:10.871+0000)
The old YGB+LW would give you 70 ad. The new YGB+Maw will give you 120 ad (and 30 flat pen). The older combo had a bit of crit chance, but the new combo lets you deal a constant +120 in autoattacks and also adds 120 ad to your SCALING abilities, so imagine that versus the measly 70 you used to have.
If you can't kill a squishy with +120 ad and 30 pen, something must be wrong with your rotations or execution. It's worked for me and I am speaking from experience, of course, on champs like Talon, Rengar & Panth. Urgot is not an assassin, so he will not be 100-to-0'ing anyone in a short amount of time anyway, so no need bringing him up. Jayce and Varus poke before going all-in, if they go all-in at all. Riven is much more disgusting with 120 bonus ad than 70 bonus ad, so...(???)
What you propose in the second paragraph (new pen item) sounds unfair to the squishy. How would a support defend themselves against you if you decide to 1v1 tower dive and instagib them, taking maybe 1-2 tower shots?
30 flat armor pene vs 20 flat armor pene and 35% where the enemy has to have 28 total armor minimum to be more effective, oh wait the squishies have a base armor of 75-85 max level. maw does nothing compared to old lw did midgame and onward and if you get maw+youmuu early enough to even make maw useful the enemy sure fed easily. Btw no real need to compare youmuu to itself youmuu was a buff for everyone except rengar who used the crit for ie so all you actually lost is 15 ad to get the old lw over maw.
I didn't mean urgot was an assassin but full ad reng, talon, pathe are and even if they didn't go full ad if they use to build lw they are hurt from the nerf. and urgot falls under varus/jayce even if he's underwhelming due to riot not reworking him yet. And squishies can be killed pre-mid game afterward an assassin is useless since lw gave more of a squishy killing potential before than the crap assassins have now
Also it's not unfair ad assassins have a low in win rate for a reason atm and just because that item would be catered to them doesn't mean that supports can't still peel them like before it's just giving them better squishy killing potential mid-game and onward nothing hard to counter(The one that lowers usability over time is easy to stop with cc, the one that a certain amount of hits until it loses effectiveness is easy to take hits for the carry and make the item useless as well.) It's for short engages such as poke (urgot/varus/jayce's poke) and ad assassins in general who want to get in kill and get out but unlike old LW it will lose effectiveness while in combat this way riven won't just buy it and be back to a assassins are cute but I can do this all through a fight)