[{quoted}](name=Lost R,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=p8BWIQQj,comment-id=0003,timestamp=2015-04-20T14:39:57.502+0000)
No. Cho'gath's an outdated champion with some scaling issues, and we shouldn't change other champions to be more like him. Besides, we already have someone with an ult that fills almost all those criteria. His name is Darius.
The point behind Garen and Darius' ults is that they're meant to be used as finishers. Garen's ult does more potential damage to tanks, since his scales on the number of health they have missing, and tanks have a lot to lose, and Darius's ult does more damage based on how many bleed stacks the target has, deals true damage, and is pretty much meant to finish off weaker champions.
so why garen that he have a finisher ulti dosent need the red cycle that you get as cho when the enemy will die if you use ulti? i mean it make more sense to garen to have that!! because he have a finisher ulti!
Plus why garen need so much cast animation? why not buff his cast animation something that people ask for years now...