Remake Vote should start at minute 1, not minute 3

FantasySniper·May 19, 2016·1 votes·305 views

If everyone goes to their positions, anyone can die to an invade - which happen even before minions spawn and is even worse with a teammate missing - you're not going to be allowed to remake it. Yet if you were to do the opposite action, and wait on the remake only for them to connect after the waves have spawned, then everyone that should've been in lane will suffer just as much as the DC.

I appreciate the effort put into making this happen, but there's no right answer to the situation because you can't rely on one or the other, the Remake vote or AFK. Solution? Make it occur at minute 1 instead of minute 3. Don't make us suffer because they came in late, but not late enough.

5 Comments

Fondling GemsMay 19, 20161 votes

coming in at 3 minutes isn't gg, sure it makes it a bit more difficult but it isn't the end of the world. And a lot of people take longer than 1 minute to connect. I know if my computer crashes it takes about 1 and 1/2 minutes just to have the lol launcher back open.

Snowball4uMay 19, 20161 votes

if they were afk for 90 seconds you can remake it.

ie, if you are 4v5, sit in fountain. If they have joined then go to lane (minions just spawned not going to miss a wave) if they have not joined, sit in fountain and wait for 3 minutes. EVEN IF THEY JOIN from what it says, you can still remake as long as they have been afk for 90 seconds

FantasySniperMay 19, 20161 votes

I think you missed my point.

If you go and wait for them to come back, you may not be allowed to remake because someone died, at which point Remake is worthless. If you stay and wait for the Remake, they may come back, at which point you'll be even worse off then not having tried to Remake it.

If they reconnect in the 1:00 to 1:30 minute window where you're supposed to be in your positions, but weren't, your team will only be behind because they wanted to wait on the Remake. They need to either extend how long the fountain grants its starting Homegaurd bonus to counteract that, or just make it less of a wait in the first place and make the vote happen at minute 1.

Snowball4uMay 19, 20161 votes

1st of all, The two things you said in your first paragraph I already answered.

Secondly, remake isn't even going to be an issue for you, me, or 99% of the community. The ONLY time I could see this being a problem is in a high elo game.

Ex: team 1; 3 masters, 2 diamond 5's team 2: 1 challenger 800 lp, 4 masters

This would be completely unfair and one of the masters will probably believe the game is over. So they will then leave the game so they waste 3 minutes instead of 20, and lose the same amount of lp.

FantasySniperMay 20, 20161 votes

1st, I said that you missed my point, so I rephrased it.

2nd, you're not even properly answering me about why it shouldn't be improved like this.