Aatrox and Irelia don't deserve all the hate they get
Yes, theoretically they can do tons of damage IF they land their ENTIRE COMBO on you, but how often does that actually happen? Most of Aatrox's abilities are skillshots and the same is true with Irelia. Their abilities are extremely easy to dodge and if you get hit by them you deserve to get destroyed. Meanwhile we have champions like Jax and Tryndamere who just jump/dash on top of you and auto you to death (all while being VERY hard or even impossible to kill). TLDR yes they're really strong but at least they have counterplay, unlike certain other melee champs.