tbh the rework is fine, just a bit overtuned. i heard riot was nerfing her soon, but im not sure how or by how much.
either way, i just want to put my two cents in on it
make her q 50 mana at all ranks with 50% reduced cooldown on a hit instead of 60%. also make the targeting bubble a wee bit smaller and maybe make the dash a wee bit longer to compensate.
also don't make her % max hp true damage passive scale with bonus AD. that's obnoxious. just give it flat values per champion level.
Weiner the Pooh2 votesThe passive scaling with ad opposed to flat makes it so Fiora can't build tank while doing crazy damage, I'm sure that when riot nerfs her it will be a nerf to tankier builds as opposed to full ad as riot wanted her built
Toastey1 votesdont make it scale at all then. a flat, %max hp value for the whole game is fine. it's true damage, after all.
Weiner the Pooh1 votesThen if it doesn't scale Fiora has no incentive to build ad meaning her build will be primarily tank, which is what riot was trying to avoid, they want her to be high damage but squishy, but people ruin it by going tank, and If it didn't she'd become the exact opposite of what riot was trying to make
Toastey1 votesQ has a hefty bonus AD scaling E is almost entirely reliant on having a lot of AD to be effective The heal on her R is bonus AD-scaling.
she has more than enough incentive to build AD. If she wants to build tank, it's not because her kit doesn't cater enough to being AD, it's because defensive items are currently far too gold efficient. The underlying problem is the items in the game.
Weiner the Pooh1 votes[{quoted}](name=Toasted Pigeon,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=bcLNEt8v,comment-id=00010000,timestamp=2015-08-29T05:05:27.809+0000)
Q has a hefty bonus AD scaling E is almost entirely reliant on having a lot of AD to be effective The heal on her R is bonus AD-scaling.
she has more than enough incentive to build AD. If she wants to build tank, it's not because her kit doesn't cater enough to being AD, it's because defensive items are currently far too gold efficient. The underlying problem is the items in the game.
Her ults heal and her one crit is not incentive enough, but clearly me saying exactly what riot said isn't gonna convince you so I'm not going to argue this anymore.
Toastey1 votesThings are unbalanced because of Riot's decisions. Of course they're going to defend themselves. If you want to actually discuss the balance of the game, you can't use the arguments of the entity that unbalanced it in the first place.