It was a good effort

Kairoptra·3/8/2019, 4:12:30 PM·137 votes·20,274 views

For those of you who don’t know, Riot has officially made the decision to discontinue position ranks.

To SapMagic and everyone on the team, I know you guys worked tirelessly trying to make this a success, and I appreciate that, even if it didn’t work out. Thank you for taking a chance in an attempt to make the game better. I look forward to seeing what else you’ve got in store for us.

Best of luck!

35 Comments

Iota Theta3/8/2019, 5:10:57 PM27 votes

Noble intentions, but not the greatest implementation from what I hear. What few I played, I didn’t experience any major issues of the trolls, but I might’ve just not played enough. At least positional matchmaking worked out better, even if the ranks didn’t.

May future endeavors fare better than this one.

Düff McWhalen3/8/2019, 9:01:25 PM15 votes

Agree 100%, and I appreciate that they can admit it was a mistake overall if I can see the intent and appreciate the effort. It was a good try, but just too freaking wonky. I also have two mains per role. I worked really hard being good at all positions, my rank should reflect the effort I put in, not just favor one tricks.

I wish they'd just admit failure more often than not when it comes to champion/item/rune balance, but that's probably a whole other team that handles that. Fuck those guys btw.

AetherArising3/8/2019, 11:28:03 PM9 votes

I mean, props to sapmagic. He saw that it wasn't working out, he pulled it down, even though he put countless hours into it

It takes some balls to make a change It takes even more to admit when you've made a mistake And it takes the most to actually do something about the mistake made.

So in all honesty, thanks for not making this another Dynamic Queue for an entire season.

Saevum3/8/2019, 6:26:51 PM9 votes

Yeah is true, good try. At least they didn't fear to go for something new or better. Every good invention starts with a dream, courage, and balls. They sure got the latter cause we flamed them to death.

6KEMBE4ORBA3/8/2019, 8:52:39 PM8 votes

Spending time and resources on r%%%%%ness similar to DynamicQ... "good effort" indeed.

They're learning slowly (or just observing more players leaving).

Maybe in 5 years stupid stuff like these will get shutdown in the brainstorming meeting. If League survives till then, that is.

mack91123/8/2019, 10:37:46 PM7 votes

Personally I enjoyed the new system

Douglas Funnie3/9/2019, 4:20:09 AM5 votes

It was not a good effort. It was designed to mask the population problem League has been facing since the infamous Season 8 was launched. Less people are playing this game, so Auto-fill is rampant. They also wanted to hold new/casual player's hands by putting the auto-filled players against lower skilled players. So it was a strategic and deceptive strategy from Riot.

Neptunia xoxo3/8/2019, 11:05:42 PM4 votes

Good. You have no idea how annoying it was to have someone literally troll because they got auto filled and didn't have to play serious because they know they lose literally nothing.

iamthegoatofwar3/8/2019, 10:43:59 PM4 votes

I ain't got plans to come back to league but it's good to see they ain't gonna stick yall with this bullshit for the next year

Janakin3/8/2019, 11:27:49 PM3 votes

Pathetic attempt.

FSRER3/9/2019, 5:55:35 AM3 votes

At least they admited that they could not do it and it was a mistake unlike many others.

Wert the Wacky3/9/2019, 3:15:34 PM3 votes

I was actually really enjoying positional ranking.

hotarse3/9/2019, 1:39:25 AM2 votes

The real problem is and always has been the hidden MMR system. Why have two systems, one which is invisible and unintuitive on top of one which leads you to think you are the ranking your in, but in actuality, you may be getting paired against completely different tiers of players. If it hadn't been for this, and for the facts that DUO Q ruins matchmaking as well, then this system would actually work in some manner. However, to do so, you would have to do away with auto-fill entirely.

oortoomeebreesuu3/8/2019, 8:08:12 PM2 votes

It was a good swing to make autofill less impactful, but it didn't land. It builds some confidence that they'll take a step back and admit it.

Jennifer4203/8/2019, 8:33:41 PM2 votes

aww man i wanted to have fun on euw :(

oh well. got a link to it?

Hayaishi23/8/2019, 11:30:27 PM2 votes

We did not need that.

Quepha3/8/2019, 11:54:33 PM2 votes

I don't understand why people think this is a good thing.

Sõna3/9/2019, 12:46:38 AM2 votes

The system itself is fine if everyone has the sportmanship and respect towards players. (but as you know our community, I don't have to say it loud)

This system is being abused by trolls, suicidals, random smurfs.

General Esdeath 3/9/2019, 3:50:30 AM2 votes

The idea could work if autofill wasn't a thing.

rtbf2256182413/9/2019, 6:53:37 AM2 votes

Good to know they won't repeat the mistake they made in 2016 with Flex Queue.

Morbys3/9/2019, 11:27:57 AM2 votes

I don't understand why people think this was bad, its was AMAZING news when it was announced. If someone trolls then report, really no difference from before the system. What they need to do is fix ranked. Its a bad system if you have to hard carry everything up to plat before you can get a decent team you don't have to babysit.

Morgentau3/9/2019, 11:38:59 AM2 votes

Upvoted for positivity.

FaZe Elite Iron3/9/2019, 7:05:17 PM2 votes

Honestly, it and it's implementation were spot on and we should bring it back (:

The Skáld3/9/2019, 6:42:58 AM1 votes

That's what happens when you do something in right way. Instead of screaming around sending feedback with proper proof and you success.

Anyways, gj fellas!

DeleteSuppRole3/9/2019, 4:34:56 PM1 votes

Like genuine question, why couldn't we all test it ? why was it only exclusive for NA and korea ? what was the point ?

DARCKD00M3/9/2019, 9:33:31 AM1 votes

THE COMMUNITY TO RIOT: we will suffer and endure the bs but we will never give up on having a FUN BALANCED GAME!

DeepFriedPengu3/10/2019, 7:53:08 PM1 votes

Over all was a better outcome than I ever thought it would have. Even though I had probably the worst experience I have ever had playing league these past few months over the years I have played it, I am someone happy with how they are going forward with what changes they did try and keep.

QancerClown3/10/2019, 12:41:02 PM1 votes

Now when you look at changes since S8 ... nothing changed.