Let's pretend that Riot was willing to do this, what would you be willing to give Yasuo in exchange? And don't pretend like he wouldn't need anything because he definitely would.
Some suggestions: -Yasuo's crits now do max damage. -Yasuo's 3rd q (knockup) no longer expires. He can hold onto it as long as he wants. -Yasuo no longer has sh*t base hp. -Wind wall cooldown significantly reduced.
GULAG 4 U6 votesCrits do max damage: It's logical.
Yasuo's 3rd Q lasting forever: Hell no. This would make his laning phase ridiculously strong being able to zone you for even longer with nado now.
Yasuo no longer has shit base HP: Okay.
Windwall CD reduced: becomes much safer (He isn't safe, stfu, he's the toplaner that dies the most kthxs)
TLDR: He becomes a bruiser, bad idea.
Cloud2731 votesCrits do max damage: It's logical.
Yasuo's 3rd Q lasting forever: Hell no. This would make his laning phase ridiculously strong being able to zone you for even longer with nado now.
Yasuo no longer has shit base HP: Okay.
Windwall CD reduced: becomes much safer (He isn't safe, stfu, he's the toplaner that dies the most kthxs)
TLDR: He becomes a bruiser, bad idea.
Well people clearly don't like the double crit passive. Do you have a better idea?
GULAG 4 U2 votesSome idiots in bronze/silver not liking it doesn't mean they should change it.
Best Kog NA5 votesOr, we just remove the double crit passive and that's it.
JustMonika132 votes[{quoted}](name=Best Kog NA,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=aY7OYTfX,comment-id=0001,timestamp=2016-11-27T22:13:35.562+0000)
Or, we just remove the double crit passive and that's it.
Or not because his double crit is his main damage steroid (his ult's armor pen only lasts 15 seconds). Unless you want the return of tank Yasuo?
Astôlfo2 votesTank Yasuo does just about nothing anyways anymore now. It means he'll actually have to build more damage, so if anything, it'll kill tank Yasuo even further.
Best Kog NA1 votesThat's not the point. I have no objections to gutting Yasuo.
Irelia Bot4 votesthird Q needs to have a shorter hold time if anything.
Astôlfo4 votesNothing.
GULAG 4 U1 votesHaven't you've learned your lesson with tanksuo?
Astôlfo1 votes? What about Tank/Bruiser Yasuo? Removal of Double Crit means he'll have to actually build more crit if he wants an effective ultimate. And with all his nerfs, Tank/Bruiser Yasuo is already fairly limited in its potential. So if anything, this would kill off Tank/Bruiser Yasuo even further.
GULAG 4 U1 votesGiving nothing in return is turning him into a bruiser. melee carries need steroids, otherwise they'd be shitty vaynes/jinxes. WIthout double crit, Yasuo will be going tankier/bruiser like it or not. Removing Yasuo's double crit will make him a complete dogshit champ.
Oh but then the boards would still QQ about him : ^)
JustMonika131 votes? What about Tank/Bruiser Yasuo? Removal of Double Crit means he'll have to actually build more crit if he wants an effective ultimate. And with all his nerfs, Tank/Bruiser Yasuo is already fairly limited in its potential. So if anything, this would kill off Tank/Bruiser Yasuo even further.
That's the issue. A standard Yasuo build is Either PD or Statikk, IE, lifesteal or damage-tank hybrid, and then two defensive and/or damage-tank hybrid. This is in the mid lane, mind you, where Yasuo is more concerned about damage than his top lane gameplay. And he's still often topping the death count charts for champions in both lanes.
If Yasuo needs to start building more than his standard two crit items (assuming Riot implements a crit mechanic for him shall they remove his first passive in order to encourage building crit), that's one or two item slots gone. One or two item slots where he will be a lot less durable, a lot more prone to dying (more than he does now). Yasuo needs to be durable enough to last in the middle of a fight.
"But what about guerrilla tactics for a more damage centered Yasuo!?!!1/" Good luck pulling that off if the enemy team is competent.
And guess what people will do. They will investigate ways of saying "fuck what you (the community mostly) want, I'm going to make your life hell" and improvise builds. Don't underestimate the creativity of the whole community, especially the upper echelons and the people in KR. There are plenty of items that can be used in order to bring about a bruiser or tank Yasuo.
Spicy Rice4 votesIf you remove the crit passive, then make his q scale down to it's min cd when leveling it up.
With no crit passive, buying zeal items would become nearly useless
Astôlfo1 votesUh. No, it would not be useless. Buying no crit (which is entirely Zeal-evo items outside of IE/ER) means his passive's armorshred/pen/whatever it is that I can't remember off the top of my head, is now completely useless.
Spicy Rice4 votesThen revert that change as well.
If you wanted 100% crit, you would need either 2 zeal items + I.E + Esscence reaver
OR
3 zeal items + I.E.
OR
3 zeal items + 10% crit runes
Astôlfo1 votesSo what's the problem, again?
GULAG 4 U4 votesIt's impossible to effectively gain 100% crit chance on Yasuo without the 2x.
Spicy Rice3 votesOr in other words, you can reach 100% crit, but to do so, you would sacrifice so many combat stats that you would become borderline useless
GULAG 4 U3 votesIf you actually bothered getting 100% crit on any champion other than yasuo atm, you're stupid, nuff said
Spicy Rice2 votesTo be fair, 100% crit Jhin is hella fun.
GULAG 4 U1 votesjhin's an exception.
Neko Caitlyn3 votesNothing. F*ck 
Ruin Lance2 votes-caitlyn player
GULAG 4 U2 votesNeko cait is a known troll for spewing illogical shit fyi
Poske2 votesIf you remove Crit passive add anything SAY HI TO TANK YASUO
NO Just a bad idea
Pierce The Veal1 votesLet's pretend that Riot was willing to do this, what would you be willing to give Yasuo in exchange? And don't pretend like he wouldn't need anything because he definitely would.
Some suggestions: -Yasuo's crits now do max damage. -Yasuo's 3rd q (knockup) no longer expires. He can hold onto it as long as he wants. -Yasuo no longer has sh*t base hp. -Wind wall cooldown significantly reduced.
All of that is bullshit.
We can allow the cooldown of his q to not cap so low.
Spicy Rice1 votesyou mean that ability that is literally supposed to be an auto attack?
You want that ability to have a higher cd?
Pierce The Veal1 votes[{quoted}](name=Spicy Rice,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=aY7OYTfX,comment-id=00070000,timestamp=2016-11-28T01:06:37.240+0000)
you mean that ability that is literally supposed to be an auto attack?
You want that ability to have a higher cd?
No I meant it the other way around. He should be able to get more cooldown reduction on it for building attack speed.
Man this is why people hate yasuo players. They're literally too braindead to understand a buff to their champion.
Spicy Rice1 votesYou realize your wording of your buff was literally stupid?
"Allow the cooldown of his q to ** not** cap so low
Why couldn't you have just said to let the ability get a higher cd : attspd ratio?
Pierce The Veal1 votes[{quoted}](name=Spicy Rice,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=aY7OYTfX,comment-id=0007000000000000,timestamp=2016-11-28T02:43:25.935+0000)
You realize your wording of your buff was literally stupid?
"Allow the cooldown of his q to ** not** cap so low
Why couldn't you have just said to let the ability get a higher cd : attspd ratio?
I said that he should be able to cap at a higher CDR.
CDR= cooldown reduction.
Thus he can have a lower cooldown.
the weeaboo1 votesSees thread about taking away Yasuos double crit
Thinks 
? 
?
Honestly only broken thing about Yasuo is his Windwall. I think they should change it to something like the projectile(s) get slowed down by the wall and the wall goes alot further, to make it so you have to use E and shit to dodge the projectiles rather than bloacking them completely.