Reworked Evelynn does not lack damage she just lacks utility
and i've played a quite a few games of evelynn so im sure on that
especially now that a whole lot of champions in league are highly mobile or mobile enough that they can escape a sticky situation
it is hard to catch up with your target because she has no real gap closer (and don't say her E please you should already know why)
if she uses her ult as a gap closer well now she has lost a lot of her damage but more importantly, she has no escape now assuming the enemy team is near
every time i play eve i find myself having problems with her charm
her charm takes a bit a too long to charge up
her charm is the hardest thing to hit, there's almost no point of her having a charm
it takes 2.5 seconds and thats a whole lot of time for the enemy to react
by the time the charm is ready the enemy is already all the way at their tower or behind a whole bunch of minions or already made it to there teammates
and when that happens the only way to hit the charm is if you walk right up to the enemy and E or waste your first active on Q and lose the bonus damage and use the automatic targeting Q thing to hit the charm
(sometimes i just place the w on an enemy just to scare them away for a bit so they dont get too close to me even when i know i cant do anything to them; but yet they run away)
another issue with her W is that every point you put into it also increases your W range...
though i dont mind it as much, cant lie its kind of useless
your already invisble playing eve you can stand right next to them outside of stealth range waiting for the charm; it doesnt matter if you use her w from a far they're never gonna know
putting points into W is only good for jungle clears but still thats not even that great
what i do think that could really really help eve is if the charm took less time to charge up (like maybe 1 second or 1.5 seconds) or give eve high ms boost in stealth form (she's really missing that movespeed buff; you can barely feel it when you use your e too) or increase the range on the first active on her Q
even her empowered e could maybe use a little bit of range when empowered so ya know the dash is more noticeable; plus more reliable gap closer.
evelynn charm takes more skill, thinking, and risk to land compared to other charms; so i think to reward someone when it does land is to make it so the charm lasts longer like ahri charm last longer or have it do a small amount of damage when landed or make it so the enemy is slowed even when out of charm for like a second
one of those things could really help eve imo; would you agree?
im not trying to say evelynn is a bad champion entirely because she isn't
if she just gets a minor buff to her charm or utility (ms, range, gap closer, etc), then it could really drastically change her from being, the champion that most other champions do her job better, to being Evelynn the widow maker
but riot wont care because its their game they do what they want