Why does Riot give small-scale reworks to those who barely need it while ignoring the ones that do?

Kairoptra··3 votes·1,258 views

First, let me say that I neither work for Riot nor know what their thought processes are. This is a theory to address the question in the title.

Recently, there has been some controversy over why Ahri has gotten some special attention while others suffer. In the past, as well, there have been complaints of certain champions being constantly glanced over (Mordekaiser, Skarner, etc.). People have often chalked this up to Riot being incompetent, and maybe they're right. However, allow me to offer up a different possibility.


#DISCLAIMER: I DO NOT HAVE THE INTENTION OF DEFENDING RIOT IN THIS POST. I AM ONLY TELLING YOU ALL AN ALTERNATIVE VIEWPOINT THAT OCCURED TO ME RECENTLY. ALL I ASK IS THAT YOU CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING.


tl;dr - They are giving champions who don't reworks as badly theirs first so that they're out of the way when the big problems roll around.

Allow me to explain: Certain champions need reworks very badly (again, Mordekaiser, Skarner, etc.), and this means that they have a lot of problems. If they have a lot of problems, that means they will need a lot of time and dedication to rework.

Then you have champions who don't need a rework as badly, but still need some work (Volibear, pre-rework Irelia, etc.). If they don't need it as badly, that should mean that it won't take as long, nor take as much effort to rework them.

Now let me ask you this: Why would we put in so much time to solve this huge problem when we could get the smaller problems out of the way and thus have fewer problems quicker? Since it's so clearly difficult to solve these problems, why wouldn't the rework team continue to be productive by cranking out champions that are easier to fix? By putting off the bigger ones, they've managed to get through quite a few smaller ones (Irelia, Swain, Evelynn, etc.).

It's not so much that they're ignoring the champions that need it more, but rather that, in order to be productive, they are dealing with the smaller ones first. Obviously, there's some flawed logic here; what about champs like Yorick, Galio, and Urgot? Well, for them they were able to find a solid direction when they were going over the list of champs that need reworking (Reav3 actually posted the current list: https://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/story-art/Q30wxkKg-new-roadmap-reav3-can-you-give-us-an-update-on-the-tier-1-vgu-list-you-mentioned-one-year-ago?show=flat&comment=0001 ). This of course made things immeasurably easier (at least I imagine it would), bumping them down to the difficulty of the lower-priority champs. However, this direction is of course far more difficult to find with these high-priority champs, which is what makes them high-priotity (I would think).

Is this the answer to your question? I don't know.

Is my logic flawless? Probably not (feel free to point out discrepencies).

Is this the answer that I believe? Not necessarily.

Are you getting sick of me asking questions and then answering myself? Yeah, I'll stop ^_^"

Anyway, this is just a theory of mine that I thought I'd share. Feel free to believe what you want. Please comment what you think below!

11 Comments

Grift982 votes

I mean how long did we wait for the taric rework. i'm fine with waiting for any rework as long as it turns out as well as the change from old taric to new taric is

JustaNewb1 votes

This is actually well thought out, and honestly with a lot of champions (ex Morde) they have needed work for years. The Back Shelfing due to the workload is permissible for quite some time, but after awhile it honestly reaches a point where some changes have been promised for so long that it is no longer 'okay.'

Especially when the time table is pushed back season after season.

Kairoptra1 votes

True enough, I won't say that they're 100% excused from not reworking certain champs; there's a statute of limitations for sure.

VvVVvV1 votes

Its just like getting rid of debt. if you have 3 credit cards ......$1500 , $1000, $500 and you want to pay them off you get the small one out the way 1st then work your way up.

Rewt1 votes

Some champions arent worth reworking on a mini rework level. Morde for example retained most of his kit through his rework. For morde to be in a balanced state. He would need a Galio level rework which will take 6-12 months of development.

Dark Nephthys1 votes

There is a lot of people who work in the company, and they put different champions with different people. Some people might be tasked with the smaller reworks, while some are task with the bigger reworks, so I don't think any large reworks are really slowing down smaller reworks. Though I could be wrong with that, but I think Riot is doing fine with how they balance smaller reworks and larger reworks.

I just hope that the smaller reworks don't really take away some key features of the champion or make parts of their kit feel boring. Like the small rework on Shyvana has some changes that I don't really like, mainly how boring her passive has become.

Wînter Fox1 votes

Certain champions need reworks very badly

Who are these champions? The only two examples you gave, Mordekaiser and Skarner, have gotten reworks already. Whether they were good reworks or not doesn't change the fact that they were reworked.

Gear Jammer1 votes

Teemo needs rework he is always forgotten

Zoli Ben1 votes

They are afraid of messing up Mordekaiser til they find a suitable idea for him, so champion like Irelia Akali Kayle Morgana are chosen over him. They also refuse to rework many champ in row with same role/position. Hence why they have Swain Akali Morg Corki Kog as candidates in tier one.

cZair1 votes

I'm kind of fearing the volibear rework to be honest, I really like how he is now. The Q (extra speed is really nice) and E (the knock back fixed so much in his kit.) changes were what he really needed. So for me It's really nice seeing almost every ability work amazingly. I only think His Passive and R need to be changed a bit. If they do something like warwick's rework and how well that went. I think I be find with it.

BerylCrab1 votes

upvote. wondered this myself many times.

More from Gameplay

More by Kairoptra