%hp dmg+high base dmg on full tank "fighters" seems ridiculous

Last game I was Amumu jungle and enemy had a poppy support. At one point I was caught in the river in a 1v1 against their full ad jungle wukong. we were both 1 item I had runic echo and he had warrior. The fight was fairly equal and that was when the support poppy kicked in and completely rekted my face as wukong finished me off. I checked death recap, wukong q 180dmg e 60dmg, but poppy q 289 dmg with only an eye of quinox...

We still won the game because we are better macro wise but that fulltank suppirt poppy diving our backline 1v1ing our carries just seems wrong.