I'm not arguing that. At all. 100% agree.
Riot's system thinks I belong in silver. Always. Even if I surpass it and climb rapidly once I get out of it.
But it takes all goddamn season long to climb out of silver because of how goddamn horrible it is.
You have people in this very thread that are platinum and diamond that are AGREEING silver is absolutely horrible, and probably the hardest to climb through, scroll up.
I am not a platinum or diamond player. Never claim to be. I got close to plat ONCE in 10 years, but have never been. I am PROBABLY not platinum.
But I don't think its unfair to say that there's a possibility I should PROBABLY be gold. Low gold at a minimum.
If I didn't have to hack my way through the briar patch of toxicity, connectivity issues, hard-feeding, griefing, and trolling that is silver -- I might even be able to climb past gold.
But I don't even get the fucking opportunity, because I've gotta go through silver every season -- which takes all season long.
When I do make it past silver, the few times I have -- I climb. Easily. Its quite enjoyable and relaxing, actually. My team mates cooperate, people follow calls, people avoid roaming ganks, people ping their MIAs, people assist with jungle pressure. Its wonderful.
If the system didn't reset me back to silver every season, I have no doubt I'd hang around in gold. I feel comfortable there. Feel like I'm with people of my own skill level. I'm not carrying any games, and I'm not hindering any games. I'm just... part of the team. (That's a weird word for silver players..... team.)
I don't play hard carry champs. I play team oriented champs. I have a team oriented style of play. You don't get teams in Silver. You get 1 of 2 things:
1.) Absolute dog shit players who don't know an objective from their asshole
2.) Hard-carry 1v9 style players who solo carry your game and get you free LP that won't be in silver long.
Because that's how you get out of silver. You 1v9 with a champ like Yasuo, master yi, tryndamere, vayne, kaisa, etc. Pub stompers. Noob wreckers.
I don't play those champs, and I don't play that style. I can't. I'm not a mechanically gifted player. I couldn't 1v1 my way out of a paper bag.
But I can land 5-man amumu ults, 4-man zac knockups, high-priority Sejuani ultimates all day long. I can peel the fuck out of a carry. I can get every drake, every game. I can get every baron, every game. I can out-smite just about anyone in any situation. I put more vision down in one game than most silver supports do in a week. I get 2-3 turrets out of 40-50% of my rift heralds. I can play the fucking map. I can rotate so well a silver player's head would spin.
But none of that shit matters when you've got people on your team going 0-10 in lane, disconnecting, refusing to help, blah blah blah blah blah.
That all stabilizes (kinda) when you hit gold. People actually know what they're doing, and my playstyle shines. I become helpful. My strategy and my decisions begin to matter. People can actually do things with the pressure/information I provide, and I climb. Rapidly.
BUT OH WAIT!!!
The season's over.
Back to silver I go.
And it'd be one thing if it was like..... Silver 1 or whatever.
But nope. Silver 4. Maybe even Bronze 1, if I'm real lucky.