I think Dynamic Q and MMR are not doing their job well enough.

TheSlogs··83 votes·3,002 views

In terms of matching similar skill levels.

Thoughts?

57 Comments

Too Ton17 votes

I write a thread about this but no one listens... Whether it is due to boosters, smurfs, boostees playing/trying to play at a higher rank, premades causing solo players to rage, or all of the above affect the game :/ Plat this season is a crapshoot of different levels of play. Just saying~

LegacyDAP2 votes

Plat has always been like that.

Junkο5 votes

Trust me it's way worse this season.

Weasel Kensei3 votes

I wrote about this as well, though my thread revolved around the idea of the match making system placing absolute garbage players in matches to torpedo a team to increase the odds of them losing, and therefore increase the odds of the enemy team winning to force the 50% win rate average.

Im saying their MMR uses baddies to throw matches on purpose.

Origninal thread: http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/gameplay-balance/MBFFmttV-stomping-roll-or-stomping-roll

I detail a ranked match that has our team with a toplane feeder making a Riven into a god, then speculate that that Riven player will have a feeder on their team next match to FORCE a 50% winrate via feeder planting from the match making.

To the OPs point, the match making is shit and there are so many assclowns where they dont belong.

Naag One2 votes

I played two ranked games last night. first game, I got 7 ranked wins nida top(first game ever as nida too) and a 20 ranked wins riven jg. second game I got an unranked top laner playing his first ranked game, who begged us to ban teemo in champ select. when we didn't he locked teemo top himself. I'm like Gold 4 getting 17 LP per win. My MMR is a bit low but c'mon wtf?
so inexperienced team mates in 2 games back to back? plis riot

I've always doubted this matchmaking. Wheneven I'm on a 7-8 winning streak, I can tell for sure that next few games I'm gonna get shit team mates. It's not even a speculation, it WILL happen.

Bronze Fiend4 votes

Mhm.. dynamic queue came with this season as well. Coincidence ? i doubt. I used to like more solo/duo matching.

Tufio15 votes

There is no solution, mmr will always be broken under dynamic.

big premades aready ruin balance by default, last season duo queue was already a problem but now you get 3-4-5 with a huge range as standard. Then you have to also account for role pick, the poor mmr need to go to the end of the spacetime continuum for getting that missing support.

ranked mmr is not better than the normal one.

LatetotheRace3 votes

DQ and mmr could work. Provided the restrictions get much tighter. Say 1 tier or 5 ranks max. (Bronze 5, with silver 5 max.) I'd personally like a 4 rank max but I doubt riot would oblige.

Tufio4 votes

{quoted}

DQ and mmr could work. Provided the restrictions get much tighter. Say 1 tier or 5 ranks max. (Bronze 5, with silver 5 max.) I'd personally like a 4 rank max but I doubt riot would oblige.

dynamic exist only for promoting group/friend play, restrictions ruin that, is a no no for riot. And rolepick still stay as a huge problem for the mmr. (the only fix is to make all roles equal)

The only solution is to remove rolepick, but dynamic can't work like that. (premades gonna bully solos and lesser premades for preferred roles, the ranked will implode in toxicity)

Avarosa Guide Me2 votes

{quoted}

There is no solution, mmr will always be broken under dynamic.

big premades aready ruin balance by default, last season duo queue was already a problem but now you get 3-4-5 with a huge range as standard. Then you have to also account for role pick, the poor mmr need to go to the end of the spacetime continuum for getting that missing support.

ranked mmr is not better than the normal one.

hell, even small premades can screw up mmr. if im silver 5 and duoed with a friend last season who was gold 1, Its gonna be a fucked up game.

EndlessSorcerer6 votes

MMR works rather well at matching players of similar skill in most scenarios. Last season, most of my games would be fairly even skillwise and everyone in the game would be within about three divisions of one another.

However, the existence of premades tends to make this more difficult. If there is a difference of ten divisions between two members of a premade (i.e. Gold V and Platinum 1), then matchmaking will have to adjust but there isn't really a good way to do so that won't make certain lanes into outright stomps (i.e. Gold V has to lane against a Platinum 3, etc).

tl;dr Dynamic Queue sucks.

ThePartyLeader5 votes

Just wish I could see people's mmr like the old elo system. Would add a ton of clarity on why certain people are in certain games.

Meurtrierr1 votes

But then, everyone would be toxic to each others.

PB4UAME1 votes

Never saw this under the Elo system; but then again, I'm sure RIOT has all sorts of surveys (that no one remembers seeing) and totally reliable data that's so bulletproof they'll never show it, to explain that I'm wrong.

Dehitay4 votes

MMR is based off of elo which was made for single players, not groups. Consequently, it's just not going to work that effectively for dynamic queue. The system considers the MMR of a Gold 5 and Plat 1 to be pretty much the same as a Gold 1 and a Plat 5. Then there's the obvious premade advantage which Riot tries to compensate for by matching them with higher MMR solo players. But annoyingly enough, they always err on the side of caution for premades. Not once have solo players ever had the advantage since dynamic queue came out (they still don't) even though they've been screwed the hardest. Riot could have easily made it to where solo players had the advantage to make up for pissing all over their solo queue and then balanced it from the other direction, but they clearly care more about premades.

Weiner the Pooh4 votes

Matchmaking is shit. Always has been. Dynamic Queue bringing in people with like 4 ranks between them then matching you against people two levels above you to balance out the fact your team has pre makes. So frustrating.

UniVibe4 votes

DQ totally fks up the true MMR, especially when the difference in premades is huge, like a silver 1 duos with a plat 3.

So the system will have trouble finding another premade with exact same ranked silver 1 and plat 3 players, so the opposing team are usually higher than silver 1, but lower that plat 3. And I've seen this a lot where you often find that oddball in your game where most of you are plat/ gold and that one silver, which of course goes 0-9. I for one would want to be on the opposite team of the silver one because that plat premade will often not pick up his premade silver slack.

Hence why DQ is a clown fiesta and doesn't belong in ranked.

TruckFump20162 votes

{quoted}

DQ totally fks up the true MMR, especially when the difference in premades is huge, like a silver 1 duos with a plat 3.

LOL

Thats physically impossible.

UniVibe4 votes

http://matchhistory.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/#match-details/NA1/2255330012/35146339?tab=overview

Just saying it's impossible doesn't make it so, kid.

Get your facts straight next time before spamming a post, thanks.

Nocturniquet2 votes

He's saying you can't queue with them if they're that far apart. But they can still get in a game with plats if their win streak is impressive enough, or the platinum players are tilted and de-ranking. There are diamond players who fail promos on purpose to stay in Bronze, but always get matched in Diamond for kicks.

Woo Dragon3 votes

the thing is tho.... no one play league now... they all play overwatch...... not enough player you know..... sad sad story.... [zombie-nunu-tears]

Volcanuz3 votes

People who chose OW over LoL weren't realy LoL players anyway. It only takes from the low end of the ranked player group. Also overwatch ranked is garbage and still needs heavy work for it to be any good. It also has DQ so you can't expect to have a pure soloq experience in overwatch either. The amount of 4-5-6 man teams i see in overwatch is insane, certainly 50+.

LatetotheRace2 votes

The dq system works well in insanely chaotic fast paced games where personal performance can be quite minimal in comparison to the team's overall performance. In league, everything under diamond can easily revolve around one or two players due to the smaller team size and champion design. But yea, you're right about the OW players being half-hearted league players.

Volcanuz2 votes

Well i have to disagree DQ doesn't work in OW. It is horrible, and the amount of games i have had where 3-4 people are in a group and won't use comms or chat is insanely high. And only use it to yell at people who prior to that yelling asked for them to work together only to be yelled at to work together.

Then you got people who are 70+ rating who are doing ranked games with 20-40 rank players and spazzing out also when their team of really messed up player rating (to put it into lol terms is it like a master with a bronze, two silvers and a plat all in the same match against 6 mid range plats), but the difference is the bronze level players in OW are WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYY worse than you think, they are like kiddies first FPS players who have jack all know how to build a team or change character constantly.

Also the whole OTP thing was carried over from this and other MOBA's into OW and people ONLY play ONE character and they never change when you NEED to change a lot in overwatch, the game is BEGGING for you to change it up on the fly. It is very very painful..

Battlecast Sona1 votes

and then OW released their competitive environment and it was DQ.

What game are they going to go play next? Maple Story? =P

Vistha Kai3 votes

Nah, it's completely fine for a Plat to play with Silvers.

Dextix LT3 votes

Thoughts? Bring backsolo/duo and kill off dynamic. It is an inherently failed system.

Sire Hippington3 votes

The issue is, in order to have proper matchmakeing with dynamic que, there has to be a missmatch on skill to balance out premade vs non-premade.

Leon Etoile3 votes

Which Riot is unable to figure out.

Firefox5093 votes

Any queue is going to be miss matching as long as boosting happens. Dynamic or not its been this way before, just worse since you can queue with more people to boost at once.

SlashStriker2 votes

what do you expect since the MMR thing does not respect your performance. You can be the only one in the entire game with S Rank but when you are about to lose 20 LP you lose 20 LP because you know performance grade == skill

Leonerdo1 votes

I don't think so. If I'm in a game that feels unbalanced it's usually because someone is massively on tilt. It's hardly ever the case that we're getting stomped just because the other team is more skilled.

Bronze Fiend1 votes

This wouldn't be my main concern.. a bunch of 4 or 5 silver premade can easily win against some gold-plat players unless they are premade as well. This is just a scenario, very unlikely but not as unlikely as same-mmr premade vs non-premade matches.

ZeeWolfZ1 votes

I know personally a Silver 4 (for 3 seasons) who is now Diamond 2 thanks to this season.

Been carried out of his mind.

OokamiNoSora1 votes

Id like to see a strait up solo que only option just to see some stats on that. Just for curiosity sake.

Yawnli1 votes

everyone knows dynamic q was a mistake. every time i get a 3-4 man premade i want to go afk

BestSupportNK1 votes

Yeah, I may be low ranked but I just had someone who plays aram exclusively join my ranked game with me in Silver II and feed his ass off...someone playing first time ranked should be matched with ~Silver 5s, not high Silver/Gold 5.

Fieryfury31 votes

I had a game earlier and my team was 3 silver 5s, a bronze 2, and a silver 2. The other team had a diamond 3, plat 5, gold 3, gold 5, and silver 3. THAT LITERALLY MAKES NO SENSE!!!

Obungo 2 votes

That's literally impossible in a ranked game.

Be an attention whore elsewhere lmao.

Fieryfury31 votes

The fuck? It shouldn't be possible in normals either. Im not being an attention whore I'm stating facts here. Go be a dick elsewhere lmao

Obungo 1 votes

Facts? What you stated is an impossible occurrence, lmao.

Fieryfury31 votes

It was in normals. So apparently not.

Vekkna2 votes

Normals and ranked have separate MMR. Those players probably leveled to 30 and only occasionally played normals to test new champs or builds. So they climb in ranked and the next time then hop into normals their MMR is still back in silver. That seems unfair.

On the other hand, the opposite is also pretty unfair. If you go to normals to learn a very difficult champ or a new role, you're probably going to suck at it and lose a lot. If the MMRs weren't separate, there would be no way for you to try something new and become a better player without tanking your ranked MMR. If I'm a gold mid and a wood 5 jungler, I would have no incentive to ever practice my jungle if it means tanking my ranked MMR back to bronze.

lokipaws1 votes

the new DQ and MMR simply suck i am in silver unraked Aram and trey throw me into matches with gold and plat players that have nothing less than 100-500 wins under their belt. and i get stuck with bronze or unraked with more than 50 loses and now wins. WTF did i do to get this horse shit ? . im so toxic after 2 weeks of this bs im suprized i havent been reported for feeding or being a bot. and after the one normal i did PiSSSH i might as well just play bot matchs all day and feed till 50 min mark with a bunch of lvl 1's if i wanted to get anywhere. cant push towers cant defend towers get so out payed you want to call HAX. no way a plat and gold player can burst down a full health garen under his tower at lvl 15 and most his build. while the towers are cooking dps.... wrong how is that even posable they didnt even have that much health.

in short the past 2 weeks have me so pissed and toxic at the bs going on with MMR and DQ i broke my laptop in a fit of rage and our sliding glass door oh i was pissed. how is riot going to match people like that. send a kid into a gun fight with a knife against marines with sniper rifles and land mines. i'd rather listen to Teemo laugh non stop for 2 weeks than deall with this new system

LordGeovanni1 votes

considering how much people are vocal and seem to spend alot of time on this game and how much of them are playing normals or the weekend game mode compared to ranked you you should expect people up to 7 divisions away from you and i think its pretty fair considering thats where you want to be you should have to prove yourself agains them especially if you have been on a winning streak (which most people claim to because they dont want to seem like a scrub who loses . i dont really think team play vs slow is fair but thats another thing

QweraRandolphz1 votes

We need a complete ladder rehaul to be honest, the tiers are way too generous and the current system rewards 50% winrate far more than it should


http://www.pvpdatabase.com/?p=1253

Ragnorok6161 votes

Honestly ide be fine with DQ if they made it so its 5 man Q outside o3f ranked but in ranked its solo/duo like the old days

inplane1 votes

Plat is the new Gold of previous Seasons. A shitstorm of good and bad players that constantly want to climb and the occasional Smurfs that runs through almost every game they play (You'd think this wouldn't be a problem by the 6th Season of the game).

Summonerrr 11 votes

The standard deviation of MMR is completely fucked now, yeah.

Your assumption is correct.

Blåbæret1 votes

I meet smurfs constantly that I have no chance against. I look up their profile and see some insane win streak. Why am I being put against these people? It's not fair.

More from Gameplay

More by TheSlogs