its actually impossible to play any melee ad top anymore because of this meta.
u picked riven or darius? tank malphite that outdamages u by going full tank "balance-riot games". you want to play irelia or nasus? gnar is here to make sure you cut the pain away.
would agree with this.....being as he has had a steady 50%+ win rate seems top lane melee can win...at least half the time :P