SHE'S IRRESISTIBLE
And btw, if she misses her skill shot, it'll extrend the duration of hate spikes. Not only that, she also deals less dmg, a lot less. And tbh her hate spikes is her core kit ability . . . once she's done with it, she gets shit on ( Depending on many factors like your skills, her skills, etc . .)
And BTW, you can still outplay her BEFORE she even throws her skill shot. For example, I always charm her first with ahri's E before she even thinks of throwing her Q with the heart thingy above me. There are many ways to counter her. Ahri's e is just an example, one of the many.
I myself, played eve a lot at some point and I can assure you that even if I have my W on their heads . . . You actually hesitate in going in for the q depending on the situation. There's always a risk in engaging with eve, specially when her R's not available.
You have time to think about your actions before she thinks about engaging.