And then they took it away because they said it was too much damage for someone with mobility and mixed damage to have and that he was effective against tanks and squishes
so they gave him reduced max % health and giant mana costs
then 
EndlessSorcerer3 votesIf they end up nerfing Kalista, the first targets will probably be the percent health magic damage and implementing a limit to her Rend stacks. I have no problem with the mechanics themselves, but the numbers seem a tad high.
TheFallenShaw3 votesI currently don't consider her Op but I'm of silver rank and prob haven't played someone who can play her right.
LupusNox1 votessee, thats usually the case with adcs at a lower level, as compared to adcs at a higher level who use a technique called "orb walking" to deal damage while moving so that they can kite/chase better than just right clicking on the target.
Kalista does this without you even really knowing it since the hard part of orb walking is knowing just when to issue a move command without popping your projectile. since kalista can't cancel and hops instead of walking, she just orb walks without even trying, making her the gayest, most anti fun vs melee champ ever. You literally cant even touch her with 80+% of the melee champ roster. Literally playing her is just spam the attack move key and mouse over what direction you want to troll in
redniwediS1 votesTake a tip from top lane: If you can't kill your opponent push hard, ward, and make their under tower CSing a living hell.
Talamare3 votesTake a tip from top lane: If you can't kill your opponent push hard, ward, and make their under tower CSing a living hell.
Ironic, My tip for top lane is if you can't kill your opponent, let them push and learn to CS under tower while waiting for a gank
7ha7guy7771 votesthat's what i do as mundo. it forces them to be open to ganks if they want to farm
redniwediS1 votesTo each their own I suppose.
TheFallenShaw3 votesTake a tip from top lane: If you can't kill your opponent push hard, ward, and make their under tower CSing a living hell.
unless its a Nasus he wants to be there
redlightman3 votesThat's not the reason they nerfed WW's Q.
Nhifu2 votesKalista needs to be stronger. Too many lucian players.
Corki Kog Jinx Ashe have weak ults compared to Lucian Twitch Vayne only beats melee sups, which is why we dont see her in any big tournies :P
Here is the culling
PHYSICAL DAMAGE PER SHOT: 45 / 55 / 65 (+25% bonus AD) (+10% AP) SHOTS FIRED: 7.5 + (7.5 / 9 / 10.5 × attack speed at the time of cast) MAXIMUM SHOTS: 26 / 30 / 33 MAXIMUM TOTAL DAMAGE: 1170 / 1650 / 2145 (+650 / 750 / 825% bonus AD) (+260 / 300 / 330% AP)
In terms of ULT's, lucians is the best out of every ADC
In terms of passives, lucians is the best out of every ADC (No cooldown on pretty much a sheen proc)
So the strongest passive, with no cooldown, and the strongest ult, with the lowest cooldown, and the best early mid late game champ all around.
Warwick is a huge game changer champ. Still does alot with pure tank items. Btw, it's so hard to press R Q at level 6 and end mid lane laning phase to win the game.
LupusNox2 votesfirst of all, how is lucian going to land anything on a kalista if they are any bit confident in her. Shes just going to dodge his skills and then he just has his passive, which is good, but the whole time she should be attacking him and the damage from her E and her W procs is just so much
Narasimha1 votesShe can't kill him if he bursts her down first. And Lucian can get his burst off a LOT faster.
Junkο1 votesthen Warwick became able to oneshot you with ult alone because of preseason changes