[{quoted}](name=The Best EV3R NA,realm=NA,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=7X1iIm3X,comment-id=00010000000000000000,timestamp=2015-10-15T05:11:56.942+0000)
Nuna has been played a long time, people know how to play him. For someone to pick up Kindred, and go into challenger and destroy the competition, that's impressive. Point was is without the heal, Kindred is still good just from proccing their E alone, but you seem to have misread that part.
(Now you're gonna say "Well, he probably PBE'd Kindred before"). Still for a group of challengers to get stomped like nothing um yeah.
Anyhow, Kindred don't need such a large sustain like that, tho the idea is for Kindred to be jungle, Kindred is gonna be played in every lane.
Velkoz was goin 20+ kills in diamond 1+ on release. Is he op?
Please, humor me.
I personally myself played a lot of Kindred and against A LOT of Kindred in all lanes. Top, jungle, mid, support, adc. Seen it all. I honestly was not impressed with much of anything from her sustain/damage wise.
Ekko was blatantly overpowered, everyone on the pbe was pretty much saying he was fucking stupid.
The average response regarding Kindred was: Kill her at level 2. And 90% of the time she just fed. Her jungle is countered by early game aggression. Mid is countered by wave clear + cc. Top is countered by someone who can counter zone her. Yorick, Renekton, Urgot, Cho'gath, Swain, Sion, Nautilus, Lissandra, Hecarim, Gangplank, Jayce, Rengar, Trundle, Vlad, Darius, Garen, Riven all did well against Kindred in the top lane on PBE.
I mean, you keep specifically bringing up this top lane as hard as humanly possible for some shitty excuse for a nerf because some guy went Kindred top and got 20+ kills.
I mean, we can begin to pick this story apart: What was the match up? What was Kindred's team? What was the enemy team? Did they use strats to shut down a champion/player? Or did they just let top island be an island? Was the top a top main? Was he on his off champion? Did Kindred run ignite, or tele? Did Kindred get jungle help? Was the top laner enemy Hashinshin? Who had what runes? What masteries? I mean, when you bring up "challenger" You're talking about a group of 200 people. Out of that 200, only a small hand full are top laners. So then you have to dig down to their own personal strengths.
For example: Mid lane: Faker is notoriously sought after. So, his challenger buddies always stick by his lane for the inevitable 4 man gang bangs heading his way. If his jungler didn't constantly sit in his lane, Fakers score would be fucking garbage from the sheer amount of ganks that head his away.
Dyrus Top lane: While having exceedingly high scores in solo queue as most of his line up. Once he reached LCS and Worlds he was constantly camped and utterly destroyed. 1: Because all of the players KNOW he's actually a pretty good top laner that is really good at getting ahead if left alone, and 2. Because most of his team just ignores him. So, naturally, Dyrus, despite having pretty good kda in solo queue, always has terrible k.d in ranked team play simply because everyone knows to camp him. whereas in soloqueue most people don't even bother with that and are off doing other shit.
Doublelift: Usually level 3 ganked pretty damn regularly to get an early game lead. Is pretty well known for being cocky and going yolo for kills, and thus is susceptible to early cheese.
This here is why Challenger is a terrible bracket to use regarding if a champ is strong or not. Especially on the first day.
Ryze does the same thing to top laners, so does Swain, and Vayne, and Quinn, and Cass, and Lulu, and Nidalee, and Vlad they all do dumb shit and get pretty high kds in the top lane if left unchecked.
Kindred, by design, is going to shit on a melee champion if he doesn't get assistance. Your direct response is "Wah, sustain, nerf her so I can go Renekton and E auto w tiamat auto q E and drop Kindred to 1/16th life while nothing happens to me, and if she pokes me I can just spam q and be back to full. Wah. I deserve it cause I'm a melee champ. Wah.
Why do you think the pro top scene for so long was Gnar Vs Maokai.
Gnar is ranged and bullies people out of lane + also gets health every time he goes into mega gnar, chunks most tanks for their health, and also has sustain. Then you have Maokai who gets sustain because Gnar spams Q, which balances out against all of Gnars strengths. That, in a nut shell, is why that top lane match up is seen so frequently.
But, I mean, if you want to nerf her further to the point she'll never be played again by all means. After you get her sustain nerfed, please, queue into a match so that when I'm Shaco I can have you go 0/10 in 13 minutes like I did the majority of Kindreds on PBE.