Should I just give up on Lucian?

He probably just doesn't complement your style. If you really like him, don't give up; but consider that he simply might not be for you. I suck at Lee Sin, but it's a problem with me not him.

I know how you feel. Sometimes you buy a champion and it just doesn't work out. There's a certain type of player to play each champion, it won't always work. I'm sure we've all had that one expensive champion buy that just didn't feel right through a few games. Either know you're committing to it and really try to get there (research it), or cut your time losses and move on to someone new :)

Try him mid, thats where I found out I liked him, I didn't like him adc but mid was GREAT. If that doesn't work out either it may be time to move on my man.

He just feels worse even fed. My last game I doubled the other ADC's cs. Doubled it in lane. But he feels far worse without a good team then just corki or graves, who can obliterate ppl. I still feel like im having to outplay the shit out of any and eveyrone with dashes abilties compared to just dropping a phos bomb and a sheen proc on them for 70% of their HP, or Buckshot ulting someone into oblivion. Hell, I do better on Varus. I cannot extend my lane dominance, even as him, which feels awful; he feels awful in lane. I have to land nearly every Q to even stand a chance at killing someone, into wins. Compared to doing that on basically any other adc. His damage just feels awful. His presence feels awful. I feel like I have to spend every game completely outplaying people no matter how fed I am to stand a chance at winning or contributing.

I guess there is a reason I faced one lucian this entire season, and Ive played like 200 games.