But...
Carrot vs. Stick
In case you don't understand that, its a question of how to get a horse to move in the direction you want it to. You can either beat them with a stick that is to say punish them (aka refuse to go places that are 100% safe to the detriment of your team) Which results in short term benefits but long term anger or resentment (or an increase in toxic mentality, feeding etc.) or you can hang a carrot in front of the horse causing them to walk toward the carrot of their own free will.
They will do what you are trying to achieve either way, but using the carrot fosters good will and a belief that listening to your directions in the future may result in future carrots. The stick simply fosters resentment, frustration, and a need to take that frustration out somewhere. (in their next game perhaps.)
If everyone uses sticks, everyone suffers down the road.