I just realized: Narrative's Great Retcon left Doran, the brain-damaged child inventor, homeless.

CupcakeTrap··38 votes·4,309 views

http://img1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20100917003131/leagueoflegends/images/9/98/Institute_of_War.jpg

First, for those unversed in the story of Doran, let me introduce you to one of the most, uh, striking bits of lore in the entire Riot catalogue. (That set of lore, which I call the "Wow, really, Riot?" collection, also includes Lux being a broken wreck with an ever-cheerful facade and Teemo being a sociopathic murderer who sheds no tears for the enemies of his glorious yordle home.)

I present to you: the story of Doran, from the Journal of Justice.


“What is the story of Doran and his trinkets that the League so frequently uses? Who was Doran? When did he live? Why did he create these items? I've always been curious as to the origins of these items I use so frequently in my matches.” – Summoner Afrasabi of Noxus

The story of Doran tugs at the heartstrings. They say Effrem E. Doran was born with a hammer in his hands and a forge in his heart. Every object he touched, he found ways to improve, and he knew that he was destined to be a brilliant artificer. At the age of 15, he was invited to the League with an offer to assume the role of Master Artificer, a dream come true and an unprecedented honor for one so young. However, fate had other plans. En route, his carriage broke an axle. When he leaned down to inspect it, he was kicked in the head by his donkey, a stern blow. He stumbled back onto the wagon, but when he arrived at the Institute of War he was a different boy. The kick had rendered his mind soft, but it hadn’t robbed him of his passion. He still wanted nothing other than to craft, but where once he may have created singular masterpieces, he now crafted…somewhat simpler items, and many of them. He is a kind, goofy, good-hearted soul, and he takes pride in the work he does. His items are daily selected by champions on the Fields of Justice, and he has a permanent home at the Institute.


("Hey, you know what our fantasy newspaper needs more of? Traumatic brain injury. Like, with kids.")

item 1055 item 1056 item 1054

That's right. Your gold-efficient, non-upgradable starting items are made by a mentally handicapped child inventor. He lives at the Institute, where he probably gets a lot of thumbs-up encouragement and a steady, slightly uncomfortable stream of "Good work, buddy" reassurances from Summoners and Champions.

Or at least, so it used to be.

I've long opposed the Great Retcon, but only today did its most tragic consequence occur to me: by retconning the League of Legends from League of Legends, Narrative has simultaneously rendered poor little Doran homeless. Wow, Narrative. Show some heart.

(Don't worry, he's not really homeless. He still has a safe, warm place to stay at the Institute in Factions lore. We'll take care of him. Happy Snowdown, little guy.)

36 Comments

Lumus Avatar14 votes

I just read the journal on Lux for the first time the other day. Whoa. Now that's depth you would never guess from just in-game interactions. It made me want to draw. I want to draw Lux during this interview, at the moment she breaks down and tells the illusion that she has "nothing else."

CupcakeTrap13 votes

[{quoted}](name=Lumus Avatar,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=u98OLuML,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2014-12-12T02:54:02.182+0000) I just read the journal on Lux for the first time the other day. Whoa. Now that's depth you would never guess from just in-game interactions. It made me want to draw. I want to draw Lux during this interview, at the moment she breaks down and tells the illusion that she has "nothing else."

I joke about it being comically horrible, but I think it actually does add some depth to her character, as well as to Demacia: a mostly "Good" place where, nonetheless, you simply must do as you're told, even if it means sacrificing your dreams and taking up a life you never wanted. (I oppose the "prison" view of the League, but stepping forward as a Champion of Demacia still would mean going from a private citizen to a representative of the kingdom, on and off the Fields.)

You might like this, too. It's a recent lore update I wrote for Factions, set during the Harrowing, that (with the catalyst of a recent near-fatal injury) shows Lux struggling to hold her fractured self together.

Legacy of Xion3 votes

...Damn.

That was awesome. Really liked how Lux was keeping herself calm and now lasering Flaadym.

And Yorick walking in all "I await your future business" like a boss.

...I just wish Ezreal thought "moonlite sonata on the Piltover coast" instead of "LIBRARY WITH EXTRA DIMENSIONAL WE'RE PROLLY GONNA BLOW SOMETHING UP" but hey, least he's honest with his danger fix.

He should get on that highway to that danger. Get in the - I'm leaving now.

Centuros2 votes

Wow, that was a great reference to cancelled champions in the story.

CupcakeTrap1 votes

{quoted} Wow, that was a great reference to cancelled champions in the story.

They were "cancelled".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23ARFCQlb3M

OLD SION: Bad news. Your concept is about to get AXED.

OLD SION: Ze Rioters spent two hours deciding vether or not to keep you. Zey told me it vas a SPLIT DECISION.

Dreamspitter3 votes

[{quoted}](name=Lumus Avatar,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=u98OLuML,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2014-12-12T02:54:02.182+0000) I just read the journal on Lux for the first time the other day. Whoa. Now that's depth you would never guess from just in-game interactions. It made me want to draw. I want to draw Lux during this interview, at the moment she breaks down and tells the illusion that she has "nothing else."

http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/story-art/lYdM7d05-riot-the-psychology-of-lux-lore-retcons-to-come?comment=0005

Motajo2 votes

[{quoted}](name=Lumus Avatar,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=u98OLuML,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2014-12-12T02:54:02.182+0000) I want to draw Lux during this interview

It's her League Judgment, not an interview (though I believe there is an interview with her somewhere in the JoJ), but yeah. Her Judgment definitely cemented her position as my favorite character.

Lumus Avatar1 votes

in the League Judgement, she referred to it as an interview, which has a broad spectrum of meanings.

Nveriyoth9 votes

What?

Lux is a wreck with a façade?

All I remember from her lore is that she can copy magic and do magic with light and is military and stuff…

Edit: Just read her judgement.

Well, that was … traumatic.

CupcakeTrap8 votes

{quoted} What?

Lux is a wreck with a façade?

All I remember from her lore is that she can copy magic and do magic with light and is military and stuff…

Her family forced her to join the League military against her will, because Demacia needed her and it would bring honor to her house. I think her lore actually has her being dragged (quite literally) kicking and screaming out of her family home.

Well, that was … traumatic.

I know, right? I was like, "Oh, Lux, she's a bubbly blonde cheerleader type," and then I read that and was like…wow. Uh. That got dark.

Motajo5 votes

{quoted} Her family forced her to join the League against her will, because Demacia needed her and it would bring honor to her house. I think her lore actually has her being dragged (quite literally) kicking and screaming out of her family home.

Well, her family had her join the military. That kicking and screaming was quite a few years ago; she joined the League after many years of spy/military stuff. To my knowledge, her family didn't force her there, just into the military. After her Judgment, I believe the League became like a home--a place she sort of belongs to, where she can slowly recover, and maybe--just maybe--find real happiness later.

CupcakeTrap3 votes

{quoted} Well, her family had her join the military. That kicking and screaming was quite a few years ago; she joined the League after many years of spy/military stuff. To my knowledge, her family didn't force her there, just into the military. After her Judgment, I believe the League became like a home--a place she sort of belongs to, where she can slowly recover, and maybe--just maybe--find real happiness later.

I don't know how I missed that. You're right—it said "military officers". Thank you! It's especially weird that I missed that, because I remember thinking, "it seems odd that she'd be more upset about joining the League than the military." I'd tried to reconcile it with something like, "Well, everyone has to join the military; joining the League means becoming a Champion, which locks you into a certain kind of destiny on and off the Fields."

Motajo4 votes

{quoted} I don't know how I missed that. You're right—it said "military officers". Thank you! It's especially weird that I missed that, because I remember thinking, "it seems odd that she'd be more upset about joining the League than the military." I'd tried to reconcile it with something like, "Well, everyone has to join the military; joining the League means becoming a Champion, which locks you into a certain kind of destiny on and off the Fields."

Yeah, as far as I can tell, joining League was hella better for Lux than enlisting.

Dreamspitter3 votes

{quoted} What?

Lux is a wreck with a façade?

All I remember from her lore is that she can copy magic and do magic with light and is military and stuff…

Edit: Just read her judgement.

Well, that was … traumatic.

http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/story-art/lYdM7d05-riot-the-psychology-of-lux-lore-retcons-to-come?comment=0005

CupcakeTrap4 votes

{quoted} http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/story-art/lYdM7d05-riot-the-psychology-of-lux-lore-retcons-to-come?comment=0005

Nice thread.

Yeah, I think Lux's lore comes very close to just tumbling into a mass of tropes and awkwardness, but it doesn't: it ends up with some genuine (dare I say it) complexity.

If Narrative rewrites her lore the way I unfortunately expect they will, I might have to make Lux the second outright rejection of Narrative canon in Factions lore.

Dreamspitter4 votes

{quoted} Nice thread.

Yeah, I think Lux's lore comes very close to just tumbling into a mass of tropes and awkwardness, but it doesn't: it ends up with some genuine (dare I say it) complexity.

If Narrative rewrites her lore the way I unfortunately expect they will, I might have to make Lux the second outright rejection of Narrative canon in Factions lore.

What was the first?

Ulric Greatsword2 votes

The Great Retcon of '14

CupcakeTrap2 votes

{quoted} What was the first?

The Great Retcon.

Motajo3 votes

{quoted} Edit: Just read her judgement.

Well, that was … traumatic.

It actually surprises me how few people know of this. I guess it shouldn't, as Judgments were discontinued a while back, but still.

LordHippoman9 votes

At least his items are still around. R.I.P. Wriggle and Atma. I don't know who you were. But I liked your stuff.

Xulsigae5 votes

Wriggle's was found by Ezreal in one of his travels.

Diahane8 votes

We should start a philanthropic foundation, Summoners Cross, which brings help to all the victims of the retcon, providing them a hot meal and psychological assistance to let them understand what it means the IoW never existed.

The Soulforged7 votes

What if the great retcon means that dorans was never on his way to the institute, and never got brain dmg?

LANWhale6 votes

Doran will not be forgotten, RIP Doran, raise your Dorans

Pryotra5 votes

Relevent quote.

{quoted} As far as Doran being cannon, it's pretty weak to say that just because he is tied to wukong's staff still, that means doran still exists. Wukong's staff may very well be something he found, and considering they have all but retconned the plague jungles entirely, he very well may be retconned out of that champions lore entirely.

Keep in mind, the plague jungles only exist right now because Wukong hasn't received his lore update. The only other reason they existed was to found the League, as the plague jungles were the scar on the world from the rune wars. Every other champion has been retconned away from that place, so saying that Wukong proves dorans existance is effectively saying Warwick is still chemist due to Singed's lore because they haven't changed it yet.

While it may be possible Doran still exists, everything about him was for the league. He made wukong's staff so he could fight as a champion. He had his accident on his way to become articifer of the league. He made those basic tools to try and prove his worth. He became an articifer to make weapons for champions. There is no part of Doran that isn't for the league. Wukong's staff is literally the last thing that ties him to cannon, and that is going to get "updated" at some point. I don't feel Doran needs to exist, and highly doubt he will continue to after the new lore is fully established.

Honestly, I feel he got offed in the great retcon. He isn't a champion, and it has been repeated that the game no longer accurately reflects the lore. Wukongs Bio has yet to be updated, and as it mentions the league it will have to happen eventually. If doran no longer makes his staff, he loses the last reason that remains for him to even exist.

It's sad, as I liked the little guy, but apparantly Rito has "better" plans for lore that just don't need him anymore.

junglerboy164 votes

DORAN INVENTED CHILDREN?!? —reaction to reading the title. Anyway, I have to agree with a lot of other people on this thread, he either doesn't exist, or is being retconned into some ancient inventor who has zero relevance and is super bland.

Mogarl4 votes

So I'm sure someone else has mentioned this but

"At the age of 15, he was invited to the League with an offer to assume the role of Master Artificer, a dream come true and an unprecedented honor for one so young. However, fate had other plans. En route, his carriage broke an axle. When he leaned down to inspect it, he was kicked in the head by his donkey"

He was never invited to the institute and so he was never kicked. Taking this into consideration the great retcon is probably the best thing that has happened to Doran, in fact he may profit more from it's absence more than anyone else in the Valoran universe.

Earl Eulrich3 votes

That just adds to the list of crimes against human rights n the western hemisphere that got revealed this week!

Tal99223 votes

Well, actually, the retcon just means he was never invited to the League, meaning he never would have gotten injured in the first place (assuming he still even exists post-retcon)

Chromatic Eagle2 votes

He probably doesn't exist anymore.

OuttaControl562 votes

This is such a worthless, jerking dig at Riot narrative.

God.

The entire lore hasn't been crafted yet and your crying waterfalls already. It's a bloody guilt trip. Doran's story might be retconned, or remade as a Rakkor/Bandle/Freljordian smith of sorts, mental handicap still remained, of course, for your convenience. But of course you throw a fit prematurely. You could have made this post asking Riot to consider keeping Doran's story relatively I hanged, but no, it's just some sob post of how sad and horrendous it is to see Doran thrown out along with the rest of the institute.

And at the end, plug your website/fandom. Not that I hate factions, but god every bloody post of yours plugs it.

Worst off, you make me log in when I have someone's post I have to respond to 2 weeks back. I'm freaking working on it, jeez.

Come on man, seriously.

CupcakeTrap2 votes

Whoa, settle down there.

I've long opposed the Great Retcon, but only today did its most tragic consequence occur to me: by retconning the League of Legends from League of Legends, Narrative has simultaneously rendered poor little Doran homeless. Wow, Narrative. Show some heart.

I'm sorry, but was it not clear that this was written sarcastically? "Oh, no, you changed the shopkeeper. What will the old shopkeeper do? That poor guy's too old to find a new trade. Will he have to go sell items in DotA?"

Since you seem to have been confused, let me ruin the joke by explaining it: this post was meant in a primarily humorous way. (Note the dig at the original lore, for deciding to include a story about a kid with a traumatic brain injury in their silly fantasy newspaper.) I am not actually concerned that a fictional character is now "homeless". That said, toward the end, I do take a more serious turn and draw an analogy between poor little Doran left out in the cold and the other concepts and characters abandoned by Narrative's Great Retcon. And indeed, that's part of what Factions has become: an effort to prevent all this creativity from scattering to the winds as Narrative continues stamping out its industrial-grade ultra-polished new universe. I think the Doran story was cringey and awkward, but in a way, he's a good poster child for those quirky, sometimes-awkward and sometimes-clever bits of old lore that Narrative is chucking out by the bucketful. (Doran himself, I don't know. I'd feel super awkward putting him into Factions lore, because he's such a O_O concept…an unsettling mixture of derp and awfulness that very uncomfortably brings up RL issues.)

Speaking of Factions. Every once in a blue moon, someone like you gets pouty and tells me to stop linking Factions. And about as often—or actually, come to think of it, roughly twice or three times as often—someone tells me they're upset that I didn't do more to promote Factions, because it took them a year to even hear about it. I care about their opinion more than yours, to be perfectly honest.

OuttaControl562 votes

All I'm saying, it's pretty desensitizing to read a rant to Riot over a secondary character that, once again, hasn't been confirmed to be tossed to the wayside.

You're giving 0 chance for Riot. You're obviously not even trying to appreciate the new lore if you're jumping the gun like this.

You could make a post about how the narrative isn't being quick enough with establishing the setting canon of the new Runeterra. You could have made this post as saying "Riot please don't forget about Doran".

Instead you made this pointless gripe as if the lore has already been confirmed that Doran is a homeless mentally-handicapped genius inventor. Hold the phone, man....

And then of course you make this morally threatening validation of Factions: " It's mentally-handicapped and unable-to-fend-for-himself Doran approved! If you don't like it, you're a sicko!"

I don't hate factions, but the context in what you put it in in his post was just wayyyyy aggressive and unfair.

All I'm saying is that this post didn't need to be so negative and forceful. The plug of factions could have been nicer, etc. My original post was spicy in its own right, though. I understand why you're not tickled.

CupcakeTrap3 votes

It's fine, I just really think you're missing the jokey tone of the OP. And again, to clarify, Doran's story has long been my go-to example of "wtf riot" lore. I'm not making a demand that Riot include "child inventor kicked in the head by a mule" Doran in their new lore. Doran's certainly never been used in Factions lore, and I'd be very reluctant to do so: I find it hard to explain exactly what I mean, but in short, the story mixes serious RL issues and derpiness in a very unsettling way. It'd be like having a story about a Piltovian child dying of magical bone cancer and making a request to the Institute's Have A Dream Foundation to spend a day with Councilor Kolminye and Garen. NO. THAT WOULD NOT BE OKAY. Dying of magical polio in a hextech iron lung? Somehow that'd be more okay.

I don't know. "Institute of War Special Education" just triggers DANGER, DANGER, DO NOT DO THAT alarms in my head.

The farcical melodrama of the OP is employed with that context in mind. The intended effect was principally comedic, with a touch of seriousness. It got a little more serious toward the end as I started to realize that Narrative has, in some sense, left the lore community homeless.

KwangoTango1 votes

[deleted]

junglerboy162 votes

no, Doran was the original shopkeeper, before the yordle with an infinity edge in his backpack. He looked like a purple pink troll creature in dark purple robes.

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by CupcakeTrap