Why are stealth lore updates completely changing (and arguably ruining) characters?

Quepha··4 votes·507 views

I just learned that at some point Orianna's lore has completely changed who her character is. She used to be a clockwork automaton built in the image of her creator's dead daughter, but now she was a sick girl who had her organs removed one by one until no organic material was left.

Before even discussing whether or not the new story is "better" than the old one, there is a fundamental and undeniable truth that it is a different one for a character that has been a staple of this game for over five years, and it was changed with little to no notification to the players. Most older players probably don't realize that she is a fundamentally different person now and I don't know why the writing team thinks that could be a good idea.

I know Riot has also done this with Dr. Mundo (By the way, Mundo's new lore is unquestionably terrible, please revert it back to the Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde inspired story) and Trundle. Trundle actually had a lot of pomp and circumstance with it being part of his champion relaunch with the Freljord event, and I thought Riot learned from that event that it is a phenomenally stupid idea to change the story of an established character with its own fanbase (and Trundle was a way less popular character than Orianna).

Players don't check the lore sections very often, so these changes fly under the radar for a while, but that doesn't mean players don't know the old lores and don't have a certain image of the character based on that lore.

Also, I do think Orianna's old lore was better. Her visual design and animations look like she was designed and constructed all at once as opposed to a number of piecemeal surgeries to fill her with imitation organs. The large turnkey on her back, the rotating dress, neither of those make any sense under the new lore.

15 Comments

Requiemsfire8 votes

I disagree, the new lore, breaks down taking segments of the old lore and rebuild it from the ground up, building the character and thus giving a more plausible reason behind their ideals rather than they just want to. Signs of a character's progression and transformation from the beginning of the story to the very end are often very rewarding.

Before Orianna could be defined by simply soulless machine with the memories of a dead girl but now you can actually talk about her as a developing persona trying to find her own place in a world she no longer fits.

Quepha1 votes

They have thrown out essential parts of the old characters and replaced them with some completely different story that has no business being here. A recently released story about Orianna actually seems to have agreed with me and completely abandoned the new lore: http://universe.leagueoflegends.com/en_US/story/orianna-color-story/

Orianna giggled and shrugged her shoulders, a gesture she had recently acquired, though she wasn’t quite sure if she had used it correctly.

“Fabricated?” she said. “Yes. I am still mastering certain expressions.”

A girl who replaced her body parts would know the purpose of certain expressions even if she physically forgot how to perform them. Throughout this story she makes no reference to any memories she had of being human and she fails to immediately recognize a cheap sideshow trick.

This is not the Orianna with the listed bio where she was once flesh and blood, it is clearly the Orianna of the old lore and Riot has forgotten to revert her bio.

Wrathof3004 votes

Its the reverse, she physically knows how to performs these expressions but doesn't remember why thy are important expressions. The more she was augmented the less human she became. The last part of her to be augmented/replaced was her heart, your heart doesn't store memories and emotions, your brain does.

Previous ori lore, imo at least, was astro boy in a league setting.

Quepha1 votes

Then she is not acquiring or mastering the expressions, she is barely holding onto them while forgetting others. Nothing about that short story evokes any of the elements of the new lore and fits the old lore much better. I get the impression that the person writing the story either did not read the new lore or is deliberately ignoring it (which I consider to be a good choice)

Wrathof3004 votes

This is because the ori from the old lore and new lore are basically the same, all riot does with these lore updates is change the way the champions became who they are. Old lore: she was the robot with the memories of a dead girl, new lore: she is a girl that became a robot. Goal of both lores: to represent a character who has lost her touch with her humanity and is soul searching as she leaves home to discover her true self. The whole reason she left home in her new lore was because she realized she was no longer her father's daughter, she was someone else, and she embraced this and left with an ambition to live her life how she wants and to its fullest.

Fasmodey6 votes

Stealth?

Sharjo8 votes

Yeah this stuff gets overtly spoken about in the client and the website. There's nothing stealth about these changes.

Quepha1 votes

please link me to the announcement.

Sharjo7 votes

Well if you take a look here they made a public news announcement about the new Piltover lore, listed towards the bottom:

http://euw.leagueoflegends.com/en/news?page=55

Here's another, this time for Zaun closer to the top of the page:

http://euw.leagueoflegends.com/en/news?page=46

In here's another Zaun one:

http://euw.leagueoflegends.com/en/news?page=42

And though I can't physically get a client version of these, I can speak from experience in saying they were linked in the client as well when they were more recent.

They ALWAYS make public announcements about lore related stuff. ALWAYS.

Quepha2 votes

Those are all advertisements for short story releases, not lore updates. Nor would a single new announcement, even if it were linked in the client, be a sufficient notification for a complete and total origin change for these characters.

I believe the lore updates I'm talking about happened before riot started doing the short stories.

Fasmodey6 votes

They release their official bios on their official website. What is stealth about it?

Quepha2 votes

They didn't really say anything about it. For a total character relaunch I'd expect more pomp and circumstance, not just rewriting a block of characters in a batch and acting like all they did was add some short stories related to a region.

Cetri1 votes

"short story releases" ... so, lore updates? I'm not seeing a meaningful difference between the terms. Every new story is an expansion to the lore, an update. And no, those are the exact lore updates (Mundo, Ori) that you're complaining about. The bios and stories for the champs updated were released at the same time.

Quepha1 votes

If there was any notification about this it was pretty small and temporary. I remember hearing something about lore updates but I assumed they were just more cleanup work to remove references to the "League," not these completely new backstories.

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by Quepha