Are the undead evil?
IDK - I know they are all about suffering and shit, but mostly they make others into undead and they seem to enjoy being undead... so yeah. Karthus also seems to think based on his quotes that being undead is good.
19 Comments
A core tenet of the undead fantasy is that becoming undead entails a critical loss of 'humanity'. This is commonly expressed as good, ordered, and well mannered people becoming raving monsters, homicidal lunatics, or daemonic malefactors. You have edge cases in things like eternal guardians, timeless watchers, or other positions where morals are ignored in favor of a greater good.
belongs to the malevolent camp. Wicked in life, wicked in death, the totality of his purpose is torture, and the pleasure of said torture.
belongs to the neutral camp. Betrayed in life, her thirst for vengeance compelled her soul into a bargain making specter of retribution. For the price of your eternal soul, you too can have your oathbreaker hunted until the end of time.
'Good' undead are creatures who don't exact a price from the living. The best example of this is a dead spouse, one trying to protect their family or loved ones before 'their time is up'. Self-sacrifice to the extreme, one enduring even into death. These are the rarest of undead invoked, and are quite a-typical to encounter in fantasy.
The Shadow Isles is a place of undeath, where life is considered a burden, and the freedom of the dead is above everything else. This is their perspective: not all of them are honest, fair, or kind in the execution.
Evil - 
Not evil - (if seeking vengeance for major wrong doings is evil, guess I am evil) 
(simply wants to find his body, and have his family's name remembered since he failed to have children in life.)
Kind of neutral - 
(tries to talk people into undeath as opposed to killing and enslaving them)
The shadow isles seem to be the most evil state of all. They attack the living and take their souls back to the island,probably turning them into their soliders(if the souls are getting controlled or not is unclear)
I mean is one of the most evil champions in the league(he'll kill you and then torture your soul for fun) and it is implied that he does work for the shadow isles,if the undeads became obedient on their own,then he'd be kinda obsolete,meaning it is possible that they simply torture the souls of their enemies until they become obedient.
and are more or less the nicest shadow isles champions,with kalista being pretty much neutral(she offers a fair trade to those who have been betrayed) and Yorick simply seems to do his job(though who knows how he'll be after his eventual rework)
The non-Shadow-isles undeads seem to be a bit more varied
isn't evil at all,but he is dangerous
is "evil" currently,but his resurrection was also flawed
is difficult to judge
They're neutral in the best scenario. Kalista doesn't look evil nor good, and Kalista is the only undead we know act like this. All of them expect Kalista want to torment livings or tend others for becoming undead.
Karthus is the kindest for undead. He cares about them. Thresh and Mordekaiser are on a different level, they love tormenting to souls and killing. They're the most evil undead as we know if you ask me. Even Hecarim looks less evil.
Technically, there's nothing that makes an undead automatically evil (unless they've been animated by some malevolent force). However, a D&D Sourcebook provided some insight I'm still amazed by.
. . . undeath gradually alters these beings' perspective. Since they are no longer among the living, undead feel considerably less concern for the things and people they once cared for most. Their morals shift. They might still value friends or family members, but snuffing out the life of a random stranger ceases to be abhorrent, because they place no value on life. . .
The act of becoming undead, whether voluntary or not, separates them from the world of the living. Some hate the living and regard them as prey. Even undead that have souls and feel no need to consume the living regard breathing beings as lesser creatures whose wishes and desires are laughably shortsighted, even childlike. This separation derives from the fact that the various pleasures and discomforts that living beings experience on a constant basis do not affect the undead. They do not feel chilled on a cold winter day or comfortable before a warm fire, and they have no ability to appreciate a fine meal . . . They are outsiders to the world of living sensations. . .
Part of becoming undead involves letting go of the concerns of the living. Mortality is by its nature a hectic state in which individuals are constantly at the mercy of various physical and psychological drives . . . The remainder of the troubles and distractions that plague the living vanish, leaving intelligent undead with a calm and terrible patience.
Basically, there's a reason why a good many intelligent undead come across as "evil". To put it bluntly, there's only one thing left in their existence, and that's the pursuit of their choosing. Since they lose everything else, they need to find something to keep themselves going. A hobby or goal, if you will. If you've ever seen the first Pirates of the Caribbean, recall Barbossa's cursed crew. They felt nothing, and it left with a terrible need. All an intelligent undead exists for is now that goal. And if you somehow stand in the way of them pursuing it, you're taking the one thing they have. And most people as far as I'm aware of wouldn't take kindly to that...
I thought Irelia was brought back via reincarnation/resurrection by the "will of Ionia" aka brought back to normal life, like being rez'd by a holy priest or healing class in an MMO/RPG. Which as we see in other fantasy based things is far different than being undead, and often not as associated with evil things.
**Chaotic Evil : **
They all exist to cause pain, suffering and destruction for their own pleasure.
**Neutral Evil : **
I would argue he's still evil, although tragic. Yorick still perpetuates evil by aiding the Shadow Isles and he does so for selfish reasons so he can ascend and his family name be remembered.
Lawful Evil :
They are evil but loyal to their cause. For Urgot this is Noxus. For Hecarim and Karthus, this is bring more dead to the Shadow Isles.
Lawful Neutral :
She is almost more like a force of nature. She has a very strict code she adheres to and is indiscriminate of who's side they're on.
**Chaotic Neutral : **
Assuming she's undead. She doesn't appear to serve the Shadow Isles. She simply kills to pursue her own interests.
I don't think so, especially given 
.
Because being undead means you can't get rid of it, at all.
So some of them simply come in terms with their own misery one way or the other, and starting to enjoy it, but that doesn't mean they're completely evil.
does not enjoy being undead. Neither does Yorick.
I'm sure alot others don't either. A lot of the weak willed ones lose their minds quick turning into mindless undead. Which that;s wut the Black mist wants