198 Comments

Ebonmaw Dragon66 votes

Uhhhh... im not a Swain main or anything, but... i feel kinda disapointed that the new ultimate doesnt turn him into a complete demon bird like the old ult... now he just.... grow wings? i mean... sure is cool i guess... but i preffer the old raven monster

https://78.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m4jl9l7dAC1qdcj3zo1_1280.jpg

After all, its not like we dont have a humanlike creature with bird wings in the game already Kayle .

Edit: https://i.imgur.com/CK2TYTD.png

redniwediS4 votes

I'll give you that when it comes to just the visual, but the sound design on his new ult is a huge upgrade. I think it's well worth the trade off.

Electro5227 votes

Those whispers........shiver ugggh

Ebonmaw Dragon10 votes

{quoted}

I'll give you that when it comes to just the visual, but the sound design on his new ult is a huge upgrade. I think it's well worth the trade off.

Yeah, the sound is amazing... but when i think about Swain, i think about giant demon bird man... and the new Swain is not that. Whatever, as i said, im not a Swain Main.

trashbagz10 votes

[deleted]

Darlantan128 votes

poor Swain Swain item 3070

Fasmodey36 votes

Yes, that's totally my opinion. I'm not Swain main or anything either but I'm also kinda disappointed with his look and ultimate. I expected more Darius and less Vladimir...

He looks like old Vladimir.

Ebonmaw Dragon18 votes

{quoted}

Yes, that's totally my opinion. I'm not Swain main or anything but I'm also kinda disappointed with his look and ultimate. I expected more Darius and less Vladimir...

He looks like old Vladimir.

I always felt that the part about him turning into a giant monster bird was the most iconic thing about him and im surprised that the new swain left that aside.

Now he looks like Vladimir... with wings. Sure he looks good, but it doesnt feel like Swain to me.

GreenLore10 votes

I kinda hope that at least Tyrant Swain will still morph him into a complete raven,though I kinda doubt this.

Inphernal34 votes

BOOOO WHERE IS HIS BIRD

GreyValkrie23 votes

I love the kit riot, but why remove one of the biggest aspects of his character, that makes swain a memorable character, and replace beatrice, the crows, and his entire style for a stupid edgelord demon look? It completely kills the uniqueness of his character and makes him look like the darkin and Vlad. Im completely dissappointed with this update as it just makes him look as bland and boring as the rest of the edgy demon champions in the roster.

Kyattsu22 votes

Honestly speaking; while this new character doesn't look bad, it also doesn't feel at all like Swain.

All the key elements that made him have his unique flavour (his walking animation and cane, his bird, his transformation) have been removed in favour of dark magic that is generic and disappointing. I didn't even consider removing these things would be an option when they're literally the most iconic thing about the character.

I thought we were past the point where reworks completely changed the core essence of characters. Why have we gone backwards on Swain and given so little care to respecting the established unique identity he held??

Xin Wan20 votes

No opinions on the kit, but I really don't like the new look. He just doesn't read as Swain anymore to me. Where's Beatrice? Where's his limp? Both of those were majorly significant to the character.

Not really fond of the white hair, either. If you're going to give him a luscious flowing mane of hair, go for a dark color. Especially with his raven connections.

If you guys are really married to this new look, please, please, please do a Traditional skin.

Muranodo17 votes

So, I feel torn. I understand one of the cohesive goals here was to make him look more properly Noxian. I wasn't supremely attached to his old look (I mainly used Tyrant with bits of classic/Northern Front/2% or so of Bilgewater), so I'm not going to mislead there.

Beatrice not being on his shoulder in some form irritates me to no end, however. I know there's passive crow usage and the nod with the ultimate. But it was an important character relationship to me. I assume it was not included because she could be visually misleading in some way or make him too busy. But I also don't see why she couldn't have some kind of perch on his old jacket.

I've been trying to eyeball his jacket/Swain himself in-game to see if it's really create a clash to re-imagine his old perch. I don't think it would sans with his ultimate and that's still an IF. It really hurts his character to have the raven-theme diminished for a more generic overlord/warlock look.

Which ties into the ultimate---and is more of a secondary complaint. It felt like this was no reason not to keep the full transformation look as well. I don't know if it's because there was deadlines with modeling or what. But it was one of the fun parts of transforming and felt like you really embraced the transformation. I'm not really fond of the "just the wings" aspect with the graphical pop-in. Graphical pop-in looks great---I don't want to pay it disrespect, but it's brief. The movement animation looks a bit awkward (kind of reminds me of Kayle/Aatrox ult). It's still readable though for an in-game perspective, so it works.

Though I really liked his present kit (I was very happy with the Q rework; I like him as a dot mage), I'm going to try to be optimistic here:

The kit on the other hand barring numbers looks promising without him being as oppressive (though now it's a lot of skillshots of varying length and delay). With the increased vision/CC, I understand wanting to gate him. I'll have to see it in actual practice. I imagine rylai/glacial augment might play well with him. Especially since I presume he'll still be wanting hourglass.

Syrdon11 votes

Agreed. The kit seems ok but they gave his look the Yorick/Galio treatment, which is a complete failure to me.

YuGiHo7 votes

o shhit, i didnt even realize hes not a dot mage any more hes looks like all burst basic skills. his only dot is his ult and it ends in burst lol

OnWingsOfValor17 votes

No cane, no limp, no eyepatch (outside of Northern Front), no Beatrice, no full bird demon form - this honestly doesn't feel anything like Swain anymore from a visual standpoint. It looks more like an upgrade for Blood Lord Vlad. Really disappointed. :(

LadyParallel16 votes

How could u take Beatrice from us riot ;_;

KirotheImmortal15 votes

He looks.. Worse off then before

Otterssoul15 votes

I'm torn on being excited or not... His kit looks interesting, but... That's not swain, don't kid yourself. This should have been a kit on a whole new champion. Not only does the gameplay not feel like "swain", he doesn't even visually feel like Swain. They just removed Swain from the game and gave a new champion his name. So, I mean... I'm excited to try this new champion, but I want swain back...

Late For Tea11 votes

{quoted}

I'm torn on being excited or not... His kit looks interesting, but... That's not swain, don't kid yourself. This should have been a kit on a whole new champion. Not only does the gameplay not feel like "swain", he doesn't even visually feel like Swain. They just removed Swain from the game and gave a new champion his name. So, I mean... I'm excited to try this new champion, but I want swain back...

This is exactly how I feel. While I'm fine with his kit being changed, there is no visual representation of the old Swain. His old design made him look like a mysterious, rugged and perhaps somewhat hard to look at person. Non of that comes back in his new design, and has been replaced for long edge-lord hair. His abilities had a green color palette and mist-like aesthetics, which have now been replaced by red lightning.

And of course, where are the birds?

Venomrequiem15 votes

There's nothing in this that feels like swain. They completely removed the majority of his character elements; The limp, Cane, Beatrice, Morphing into a Demonbird, the hiding of the face, etc. The new kit in no way reflects Swain. There's no DoT, no zone control effects, no transformation on demand and mana management. They created an entirely new champion with the thinnest veneer of Swain and tacked on the shitty edgelord anime look.

Riot used to be so good with subtle changes to a kit or design that really improves on the character while keeping identity intact; Sejuani, Ashe, or Malphite being perfect examples. But lately if you like a character and kit older than 3-4 years better kiss it the fuck goodbye. Rito doesn't like how your champ plays and is going to strip it down to a name, turn every ability into a skill shot, and tack on the edgelord...

TerraRising14 votes

Rest In Peace, Beatrice. The bird is no longer the word...

Penta Penguin14 votes

I am honestly really put off by the Lucius Malfow look

Urgash13 votes

Can't wait for Riot reworking champions i don't Play. First Galio and now this... No Beatrice, no cane, no crow transformation, no laserbird and no dots anymore you could have named him Swoin and no one would have seen that it was based on Swain's design.

I guess the champion will be strong and people who didn't like Swain before will like him more that way. The graphics are nice, but that just isn't Swain.

Jeddy01711 votes
Oleandervine1 votes

I know, he can shiver me timbers anytime.

KuroCaliber3 votes

No wonder GP wanted to board his ship and plunder his booty.

Dan Squared11 votes

Things i liked: Kit looks interesting, maintains battlemage style Plenty of chances for skill expression with combo's (root, into passive pull, into eye?) ultimate is no longer just stat-check of whether you can out damage his healing Look is overall good and feels very Noxian, big plus on the coat-cape

things i wish were there Beatrice. While he does still have some raven ties with his soul collection effect, i still wish she was there. Full Raven transformation. Ult effect is fine...but part of the allure of Swain was going full monster-raven mode. hopefully his relationship with Beatrice is still present in the lore, and he still has her around, even if not in-game

things i dont like and NEED to go That hair...give the man a proper short haircut

Late For Tea10 votes

It's funny that they teased a potential upcoming Dragon Master Swain skin. What is the point when there are no more birds (and thus no dragons) =/

(Because tiny dragons carrying his soul fragments for him would totally be awesome /s)

JoeMG9 votes

7/10 Needs more birds.

I was really hoping they would expand on the raven theme - definitely disappointed by that.

Other than that, it's a big improvement over his old kit. I am concerned about his ult cooldown and mana costs, though.

Elipo9 votes

I never thought Lucius Malfoy would rock red

Knalxz8 votes

Anyone else feel like red isn't Swain's color? I feel like the people or person who made that choice really messed up.

YuGiHo9 votes

im gonna miss the green and purple effects since most mages dont cast in those colors but red is to color of noxus so i guess swain can join the other 20 mages and fighters that cast in red

Blood Magicks7 votes

Quick question, Riot, did you give him long hair specifically to troll me?

RiotBioluminescence18 votes

[{quoted}](name=Blood Magicks,realm=EUW,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=MFKKJvoA,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2018-01-23T18:10:02.127+0000)

Quick question, Riot, did you give him long hair specifically to troll me?

Highs and lows.

SEKAI7 votes

{quoted}

Highs and lows.

Hey, Riot, great job on Swain rework. It looks cool.

But can he also get his bird-head (during ulti) back as well? That will be even cooler.

Thanks.

Inphernal4 votes

Where is the bird, Lebowski? Bunny says you're good for it.

Blood Magicks4 votes

lows

please do NOT touch my man in a bad way

Líthillya2 votes

{quoted}

Highs and lows.

Is Beatrice at least still part of his lore, now that you cut her from his kit? Also, why was that choice made, and why was his profile changed to be something entirely different? Swain was crippled, he needed a cane to walk, or at least that's what he made people think. Who knows what the truth really was. That was part of what made him an interesting character, he'd succeeded in a nation where strength is -everything-, despite his physical disadvantages. Removing those removes what made Swain, Swain. I mean, I like that he's still the leader, and that you at least still make allusions to him being a great strategist, but his appearance is just entirely different. In all honesty, if I didn't know who he was, I'd have said he was a reworked Vladimir.

I've no idea who worked on the update, but can we get some context? Please? I'm trying to keep things constructive, but it's a bit difficult when we have nothing to weigh these massives changes again.

RiotBioluminescence6 votes

{quoted}

Is Beatrice at least still part of his lore, now that you cut her from his kit? Also, why was that choice made, and why was his profile changed to be something entirely different? Swain was crippled, he needed a cane to walk, or at least that's what he made people think. Who knows what the truth really was. That was part of what made him an interesting character, he'd succeeded in a nation where strength is -everything-, despite his physical disadvantages. Removing those removes what made Swain, Swain. I mean, I like that he's still the leader, and that you at least still make allusions to him being a great strategist, but his appearance is just entirely different. In all honesty, if I didn't know who he was, I'd have said he was a reworked Vladimir.

I've no idea who worked on the update, but can we get some context? Please? I'm trying to keep things constructive, but it's a bit difficult when we have nothing to weigh these massives changes again.

I'm sorry - I'm not on the Swain team (I don't work directly on League at all) and I feel stupid for turning up in a Swain thread when I can't speak to these questions. :(

I responded to Blood Magicks because they specifically had wondered if Swain was going to have long hair, and I knew, from seeing the splash art internally, that he would have long hair. Generally I'll hear about the lore side of things, but I have no connection to the kit or graphics side of things.

I do know that the team read the Boards (and Reddit, and other places) and will be going through all the feedback and questions. Unfortunately, asking me is like asking the janitor why the patch isn't live yet. I'm really sorry.

Inphernal7 votes

Where is his limp??????

Nylisa7 votes

The kit itself looks interesting i like almost everything about this rework BUT... his face! and Beatrice????!

The thing i liked about Swain before, he looked cunning , mysterious , at same time you wouldnt suspect him to be a mastermind of a great nation.

but now you can see a bad guy face on him from 10 miles away!

That Tyrant spash though :O damn!

Nefas6 votes

Kit looks interesting but I’m really not a fan of the visuals. It doesn’t look like Swain - it looks like Vladimir’s lost brother.

Amoc4 votes

I like the new look and lore, but I'm not really sold on the kit. I like the interaction with his passive and his E, but Q seems like a pretty boring/generic short range wave-clear and his W looks like it will be very situational. No problem with his R - that's neat. To me it looks like he's going to have a difficult laning phase, but I'm a potato so what do I know?

Whyte Lyon7 votes

What do you mean "I like the new lore", Swain hasn't had it released yet.

Catastrop3 votes

Ugh why did they make him red? It's incredibly minor, I know, but a green colour scheme was a really great aesthetic fit for him. Kind of disappointed to see it gone.

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by Electro522