Look at it this way: the Immortal Journey skins are not aimed at western audiences.

Electro522··94 votes·5,827 views

First off, that is what riot is calling this new skin line: "Immortal Journey". Just figured I'd clear that up.

I'm going to copy and paste an interesting comment from Reddit from the user Warscythes;

"I would like to offer a bit of perspective on the skins here.

I am actually not surprised at all that Shen did not get the skin. From what I can understand, the audience for this skin line is for the Chinese players, since it is based on Xianxia. The characters in Xianxia, or at least most of them are agile characters with blades or almost sort of mystic character use chi to guide swords etc.

Which is why Shen is actually not a good fit. It would be akin for them to make a heavy armored cowboy skin.

_Many players on the Chinese forums have guessed Yi and Fiora to be chosen, while some debated Taliyah since you can change her stone throwing to swords instead. Irelia could also be a good fit but I think there is a rework for her coming. Janna while is not exactly a huge contender but the theme of which she represents is very prevalent in Xianxia so is not surprising at all. _ Basically is a cultural thing."

If you look at it this way, it actually makes perfect sense that these came out. Believe me, I'm just as surprised as any of you at these skins, especially with Yi. I was under the assumption that Riot stays away from a champ for at least 6 months before they start work on a new skin.....but this throws that right out the window.

However, do remember that Riot has been stepping up in production lately. This could actually mean that they are starting to pump out even more skins at a faster pace. I could be wrong, but if I'm right, it means 2018 is going to be PACKED with high quality skins.

Just a guess though.

47 Comments

Melledoneus54 votes

This is certainly something that makes me feel a bit better about Shen not getting the skin. Thanks for the information!

However, I'm still kinda irritated at how the teaser made the sword look more like Shen's spirit sword than the sword in Janna's skin. That was just plain nasty, even if it wasn't intentional.

Electro5224 votes

To be honest, I too thought it looked like Shen's sword, but you have to admit, the sword did look a little.......thin.

I'm not saying I wasn't expecting Shen, but there was something at the back of my mind saying "You sure?"

Anyway, glad this helps Mell.

[slayer-pantheon-thumbs]

Late For Tea24 votes

Sooooo, they could have done Cosmic Blade Shen & Eternal Sword Yi. 1,2,3 problem solved.

(Thanks for the information though. It does clear some things up why Yi was chosen)

50000000000000003 votes

Cosmic Shen's ultimate can look like a wormhole

Oleandervine21 votes

I think these skins look absolutely fantastic though. I'll definitely get my hands on the Fiora and Janna ones, they look phenomenal. I think it's nice to see Janna in a thematic that isn't just "magical wind waif with magic staff."

Electro5225 votes

I agree 100%. They truly are beautiful skins.

Just surprising.

TheMoralSupport1 votes

I think it's nice to see Janna in a thematic that isn't just "magical wind waif with magic staff."

Preach.

Frozen Diva9 votes

Well that Taliyah Skin would have been nice.

Sharjo4 votes

Hey if the reception's good they might make more Immortal Journey skins and Taliyah could be among them.

ModDaenrysTargaryen7 votes

Yes i thought the same thing, I was wondering when a skin set based on a totally different region would come, and it is this one. with worlds in china i think they decided to release skins to complement that.

RosaElia7 votes

Kinda sucks that we have to wait longer though for a new Shen skin. Would be cool if they gave Shen a legendary skin along with Zed and have and event that's something like Yasuo and Riven.

Salson7 votes

Which is why Shen is actually not a good fit. It would be akin for them to make a heavy armored cowboy skin.

I want it.

I'm gonna call it Project Graves.

warpenguin5556 votes

Taliyah throwing swords instead of stones? LOL WHY RITO WHY

Yordle Xayah4 votes

Wait... people are even complaining about this?

I just looked around for the skins and they look absolutely gorgeous and mostly distinct from other sets.

CytheGuy4 votes

Yeah people are complaining because Riot is giving non-meta champions skins (except Janna, they're mad because she's super easy and doesn't use a weapon to hit people, so a sword doesn't make sense in their eyes). People are mad because they came up with an idea they instantly accepted as fact. They are mad because Yi has gotten 2 skins this year (which I don't know why they're mad about that).

Chromatic Eagle3 votes

Speak for yourself I love this theme.

(I get what you're saying.)

Ebonmaw Dragon3 votes

WHERE IS MY HEAVY ARMORED COWBOY SHEN SKIN?

Lintu Puck3 votes

I know want a Red Dead Shen

Rathar Dashing2 votes

*Red Dead Redem-Shen

WinTheWarOnPants3 votes

Janna still doesn't make any sense. I'm only vaguely familiar with Xianxia(i stumbled across it while looking into Chinese mythology). The characters that have swords(even the pretty grillz) USE the swords(correct me if i'm wrong). Watching janna float shooting "stuff" from her "sword" that she's waves around like a (totally not)staff looks so freaking weird(or at least it does when you find out that it IS indeed a sword(which you won't even know until you recall)). Akali Irelia Katarina Taliyah Sona Syndra Xayah Riven Diana would have been better choice or another male champ. but whatever.

Beyond Legends1 votes

She suppose to be the sword barrier of legendary blade. It's not that uncomon in the genre and her kuudere personality fit the skin line.

WinTheWarOnPants1 votes

She suppose to be the sword barrier of legendary blade.

lul wut? i'm pretty skilled at the art of google, but couldn't find anything using an combination of "xainxai" and "sword barrier of legendary blade"

Beyond Legends4 votes

Google isn't everything lol and alot of these trope are in the form of chinese web novel so unleas you are a frequent reader of those type of novel you wouldn't know what I am talking about.

Also I was refering to jana personality on the second part.

GreenLore2 votes

Akali and Irelia are on the VGU list,the skin team will usually avoid giving them skins whenever possible.

Lintu Puck1 votes

ahem- "Called upon to protect her weapon, Sacred Sword Janna utilizes the blade’s powerful magic (and her enchanted koi fish) to protect all that need her. " The blade is a magic (i.e. SACRED) Blade, and based on the above description of the skin Janna channels and draws the magic of the blade to fight.

Terozu3 votes

Im srry but... The characters in Xianxia, or at least most of them are agile characters with blades or almost sort of mystic character use chi to guide swords etc That describes shen to a T. Not sure what these skins are, just noticed that and it makes no sense.

KuroCaliber9 votes

Shen's tanky though, he's a "hit me as much as you can kinda guy and I'll shrug it off while I whale on you." these characters are fragile, lithe and meant to avoid taking damage.

Terozu2 votes

Youve never built crit shen clearly.

Shinjusuke1 votes

Functionally yes, but shen dodges, dashes, teleports, is a literal ninja, and has a sword that magically floats around and is core to his kit.

Passing over Shen was for moar munz, and nothing else

KuroCaliber1 votes

Idk what being a ninja had to do with it. This line is Chinese not Japanese. Also most characters in XianXia games are high damage carries, or a weird sword protector type character which Janna portrays.

Shinjusuke1 votes

most of them are agile characters with blades

Sounds like a ninja fits that to me. Besides, the concept of ninjas, albeit not called "Shinobi" as that's a Japanese word, were equally existent in China.

ModAcademy Kayn2 votes

Taliyah since you can change her stone throwing to swords instead.

That sounds metal as fuck

xelaker1 votes

all cleared up. still grumpy.

AIIan1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Paleo Electro,realm=NA,application-id=6kFXY1kR,discussion-id=Eh8tWVkc,comment-id=,timestamp=2017-09-12T21:15:11.855+0000) Which is why Shen is actually not a good fit. It would be akin for them to make a heavy armored cowboy skin.

Anyone who thinks heavy armored cowboys are lame needs to consume more steampunk art.

GigaPube1 votes

how dare they not make a 420th futuristic exosuit skin line that i genuinely love every time despite this sarcastic comment

rtbf2256182411 votes

As far as i'm concerned, Janna fits any Eastern theme that has beautiful deities in them. It's a cheap shot regardless, essentially for something that's meant to be sword-themed.

The skin's pretty but damn that theme does not fit her. She doesn't use the sword and her attacks don't come out of it (which would also be dumb), they come out of her feet.

escape1 votes

OK as a Chinese player I think that the CN server is pretty upset about the skins. Basically Tencent marketed the skins as "仙侠" which should be magical sword art. The theme has been welcomed, but the skins don't really deliver it well, and thus dismissed as a hoax to get sales. Yi and Fiora doesn't really use Chinese swords, which are used in the magical sword art theme. Fiora is French and Yi is Japanese. Both of them doesn't hold or use the sword in the right way. And Janna doesn't use the sword at all...

I really appreciate the effort to make a Chinese themed skins and I will probably buy the Janna skin... but I can understand how it is both disappointing to both western and the CN server.

escape1 votes

I can also understand why Riot makes another Yi skin. The Cosmic Blade Yi skin is a limited edition skin that requires players to spend 2000RMB (~320USD) in a ward skin event (LUL) to get. If a 320USD skin for a champion can be a success there should be a lot of motivation for another skin for that champion... sort of like Ahri I guess.

Sulghunter1 votes

As a stupid westerner, with no knowledge at all of the mythology the skin line is based off of, is Janna supposed to be similar to the Lady of the Lake (the person from whom King Arthur got Excalibur)?

escape1 votes

So the mythology background is kind of like this: Assume that the world is flat, and there are a lot of people living on it. However, a very small portion of the population has the ability to communicate with chi or whatever invisible energy in the air, and make use of that energy by gathering those energy inside themselves. The commons may or may not know about the Xianxia world among them depending on individual author's setting. With the power and energy, people are supposed to learn to float/fly, travel fast, and live longer lives.

There was once a very popular Xianxia story (a game made by another company called XianJian), and the Chinese official teaser was referring Yi's skin to the protagonist -- poor boy growing up accidentally learning the power and goes on his way to find eternal life while revenging etc i didn't really read/play through the whole thing. And Janna's skin is supposed to refer to the main female character, being in love with protagonist as a girl growing up in a rich family.

big boi edri1 votes

Seems like there were other champs as a better fit, but either way I think the skins look pretty good.

Irelia Xayah Ekko Would've been pretty neat with these skins I'd think.

Lord Galvatron1 votes

I'd like a new Yorick skin aimed at any audience......

TimX24968B2 votes

have you seen the PBE lately?

apocoliptyc1 votes

does any1 have a link to where i can find these i cant seem to find one anywhere

Infernal Shen1 votes

Hey I loved reading your posts and with the current teaser incident with the New skins i was wondering if you could make a Part 3 to your Next Ultimate Skin post that you made a while back.

Electro5223 votes

Awwww......I have a fan! (joking)

But yeah, I was actually thinking of doing exactly that when this hype dies down a bit. Maybe later this week.

ChuShoe1 votes

I'm irritated that yi is getting another skin. For a champion that's more of a nuissance than anything else, I find the fact that he has so many skins irritating.

If anything, give the skin to akali. She has nothing but blood moon and headhunter.

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by Electro522