Why was Xayah censored when Kled was not?

Zero Skill Tank··18 votes·9,191 views

What's the reason to cut bad language now? Is it because she's a grill? That's sexist.

Rito pls. This game is, after all, about 10 characters killing each other over and over for an hour or so.

Swain summons ravens who tear out living flesh out of his enemies and feed it to him, but Xayah can't have a fucking cigar?

30 Comments

Marshbouy15 votes

It fits his personality as a crazy war vet who forgets the norms of society (he's the only champion who swears while everyone else doesn't). Adding more people who swear would slowly detract from Kled. Not to mention it's bleeped, while Xayah was not bleeped. Bleeping Xayah is not an option because it wouldn't fit her as much because Kled is all about craziness and cartoonish comic relief, Xayah is not.

RiotReav315 votes

Kled was actually heavily censored, it's just that all the censored lines never made it to the PBE. He had much worse lines before.

The reason Xayah was censored is because of the specific word. Apparently "shit" has higher implications then the words Kled says, which is why "Shit" is bleeped out in Kled's VO. The word "shit" can cause our rating to go up which is something we aren't willing to risk.

We bleeped out that word on Kled because we thought it added comical effect to Kled. We could have bleeped it out with Xayah as well but we didn't feel that same comical effect would work for her personality.

ZER0 24 votes

My only question about this is, you guys knew about the rating problem before (which is why you censored Kled's) so why add the voice lines that had shit in them or add "shit" to any voice lines in the first place? Could've avoided a lot of confusion that way. If you never give people something, they'll never know it was removed, but if you give it to them and take it away, however minuscule, people will get upset. (Personally I'm neutral on the situation, just curious as to the answer.)

DrCyanide2 votes

Things get pushed to the PBE accidently from time to time, such as Urgot's WIP model, Alistar's internal testing version of a lock-free headbutt, or file names hinting at a new game mode/champion.

ZER0 22 votes

While this would make sense, I'm almost sure that's not what happened.

ModAcademy Kayn1 votes

Except it likely is, considering the chain of events. The VO lines that Kled never got, never made it on to PBE. The lines that Xayah got removed, did make it on to PBE. Both lines were removed regardless, so if both were meant to be removed regardless, it was most likely an accident that they made it onto PBE.

Dolasaur1 votes

It's a work efficiency tradeoff. Making everyone in your company sit through hours of geopoli training is something not many companies care to do. Involving a dedicated geopoli expert at every step of the way can be helpful, but tedious. So Riot seems to have just done what most people do: Get everything ready to go with a general idea of their ratings boards, and then let something slip because it wasn't a huge, obvious red flag (like rape/swastikas/Batman (well-known unowned IP)/etc.).

La Belle Sauvage1 votes

Thank you for the clarification, I wondered about the reason!

KataOnCrack1 votes

The community already swears a lot. I don't get why a champion couldn't do that.

I though, maybe you could put an option in the settings that mutes or censors all swear words from all champions(considering they have any).

Cute Poro1 votes

Because things players say aren't rated when it comes to games. That's why League's ESRB says: Other: Online Interactions Not Rated by the ESRB (Macintosh, Windows PC)

Niyumi1 votes

{quoted}

The word "shit" can cause our rating to go up which is something we aren't willing to risk.

Hey look, more money grubbing. But, you know, removing lines that add to the character of a champ because they might make parents less willing to let their kids play the game and grow up into whales is putting quality before money. Yepo.

Knight Sky1 votes

what a ball of positivity you are..

Sexy Jack Rabbit11 votes

Kled's line were censored for comedy purposes. It's funnier to hear the "BEEP" or the "SKWAAAAK" whenever he goes to swear.

Xayah was censored becasuse tbh it's not very fitting to her character and it's wholly unnecessary. I feel like people are making too big a deal of this. I had my doubt these lines were gonna last.

TyrekGoldenspear7 votes

Kled had his bleeped. Xayah didn't. Quite simple.

Sexism has nothing to do with it.

6Sfool5 votes

It's because she's a grill. We don't want her flaming everything, so they removed the charcoal.

ModAcademy Kayn4 votes

People keep saying this, but where is the source?

GreenLore3 votes

Uhm Xayahs isn't the one with the censor,Kled is. And its purely done because its funny.

Papa Andrei2 votes

They should just add the line back in, and have it be disabled with the profanity filter

OurLestrade1 votes

I vaguely remember Simpsons Hit & Run having crap in, and that was PEGI 7+

Keevalroy2 votes

"Oww my ass!"

OurLestrade1 votes

{quoted}

"Oww my ass!"

"MY OVARIES."

Darius Strada1 votes

But...she still says shit on the PBE...

Sckullzz1 votes

Kled gets censored. They bleep him out when he says "shit"

Only Play Darius1 votes

{quoted}

Swain summons ravens who tear out living flesh out of his enemies and feed it to him

I don't know why, but this never occurred to me. Until now.

Swain is a psychotic cannibalistic motherfucker.

Meep Man1 votes

I'm confused on the source of this finding. Who said they removed the quote?

medic titan1 votes

wait are they bleeping all of kled's cussing or just his quote when he says "shit?"

Ralanr1 votes

Except Kled is censored in game.

ZT Xperimentor1 votes

Given he's supposed to be an old war veteran, he's probably got the excuse of being senile.

KataOnCrack1 votes

The community already swears a lot. I don't get why a champion couldn't do that.

I though, maybe you could put an option in the settings that mutes or censors all swear words from all champions(considering they have any).

More from Story, Art, & Sound

More by Zero Skill Tank