All of your ideas are terrible. Your concepts, from items to champions to skins, are absolute trash.

Onimarus··70 votes·4,206 views

But don't let that dissuade you from trying to create something unique. Don't create new ideas for others, but instead do it as a form of entertainment to yourself. If you finish up that deep, complex champion with the perfect backstory and stats, and even go so far as to do simulated battles with current champions in League, then more power to you. Just do it for fun, though.

Because the chance of your character/skin/item being implemented in League so astronomically low, you'll have a better chance of winning the lottery. Now, please return to your daily dark and brooding champion creation (with a tragic past!). They probably miss you, even if they'll never admit to it.

54 Comments

Blaquenwhyte13 votes

Well, I would've phrased the title a bit differently (I understand it was supposed to be an attention-getter, and boy does it succeed), but the intent of what you're saying is something I totally agree with.

Lately, there's been an outcry on this Board about contests and the like, or begging for Riot to pay more attention to the concepts here, and frankly, I just don't understand it. Is it cool to get a Riot response on your concept, or to get noticed for what people believe to be a well constructed concept? Sure it is; there's nothing wrong with enjoying positive feedback... but seeking it is a different deal. If your concept was made because "Riot should add it" or because "people will think it's cool," then I think you're designing for all the wrong reasons.

You should create for creation's sake. Do it for fun. When an idea comes to your head and you want to build upon it and mold it into a concept... well, in the words of Shia LaBeouf, just do it. What people will think of it is another hurdle entirely; you can use responses and criticism to improve your concept and any ones you may make in the future, but don't start making concepts out of some misguided, self-aggrandizing attempt at approval or appreciation.

Now, that's not to say there isn't a distinction to make between good and bad concepts; some are more deserving than others to be noticed, but that's something the community upvoting system can handle. I would venture to say that the best concepts on these Boards (at least in terms of popularity) are from those who understand the one-in-a-million odds that their concepts will be noticed or added to the game, but they do it anyway. Despite the miniscule, borderline non-existent chance that their effort will achieve some form of representation in the game itself, they do it anyway. Why? Because they enjoy doing it. And that's all that should ever matter.

chipi991 votes

I miss Riots contests though. I liked seeing other peoples things and have wanted to enter one (sometimes it wasnt just art). But seems liked they stopped even though they have more money now.

BuzzinTate1 votes

A contest would be a really cool thing.

Riot would grab the top 25 upvoted posts on the creations forum they can find and filter out non-champion concepts.

They would then take the top 5 concepts of that month.

users would vote for their favorite concept each month.

Then at the end of the year a final vote is made on the 12 champions voted for best concept.

When a final champion concept is put forth it is considered highly by riot

Riot would make certain accusations about how the champion would fit in or not lore wise and gamplay style wise

If we can have a solid argument on the forums about why it deserves to be in then Riot agrees to make it.

simple

Dis The Chris12 votes

One champion was born from the Concept Creation, the Armored Bear - better known as Volibear now. So take that for aspiring + a legion of players who likes the concept enough for Riot to notice.

Mettaton EX12 votes

Also, Angus (AKA Braum)

chipi991 votes

Also Quinn.

kile1476 votes

Project: Leona was a community concept awhile back

The Soulforged2 votes

Barn, the sentient barn.

I Miss Cannon8 votes

Just recently Order of the Lotus Irelia, a community concept, was made. Arcade Riven as well. So no you're wrong.

AMYS GRAVE4 votes

astronautilus was also a community creation.

Zedex5 votes

Battle Bunny Riven was also a fan creation.

Leadpaintchips1 votes

Now comes the question of how many of these skin ideas and champion ideas were put up on the boards?

I'm not saying don't do it, but don't do it expecting that Riot will even consider it, because more than likely, they won't.

I Miss Cannon1 votes

Yeah of course they won't even consider Battle Bunny Urgot and Star Guardian Garen. But well thought out concepts with good art do at least receive a reds response most of the time.

Leadpaintchips1 votes

Rereading it, I don't think I was clear with the message that I wanted to portray.

Out of all of the ideas that have been put out here, how many have they actually used? There have been some that are chuckle worthy, some that were fantastic, some cringe worthy, and some that were just meh. There have been a LOT though, and almost all of them were not considered. Rioters love good concepts just as much as we do, but our ideas (for various reasons) have less than a snowball's chance on actually seeing it in game. I see it along the lines of actually getting hired at Riot, it MIGHT happen, but probably not for the vast majority of us.

I'm not saying don't, because your idea might be the next Battle Bunny, or the next Voli, but the chances are slim.

BuzzinTate1 votes

how many good ideas.

there are a lot of poorly constructed ideas on the boards.

Leadpaintchips1 votes

Even out of the well put together one's, what percentage of these actually make it into the game? Less than 1%? How about the one's that are good ideas, but the creator didn't put it together well?

Again, don't not do it, but don't get your hopes up that they'll take it.

Guyy Fieri1 votes

Skins are probably easier to do this with as they actually change the gameplay

DeynaTaggerung2 votes

He didn't say impossible, he said very low odds.

The Soulforged2 votes

void fizz

Puynsi4 votes

At least they try, if Riot didn't hated community so much there would be a lot more content.

Onimarus24 votes

If Riot implemented one idea out of every one hundred (from these forums), the game would be unplayable. It isn't that they hate the community, but instead they just don't trust it.

and it's completely understandable.

Zedex3 votes

They tried to trust the community when they asked what they wanted with Skarner and Darius.

They came out of the PBE broken as hell, lol.

Leadpaintchips1 votes

Those were balancing issues, which was something that they should've looked into more.

Troll for Trump1 votes

Yes, and garen got rightfully buffed. They ignored the community on morde and see how that turned out.

Mistress Madoka1 votes

CertainlyT in a nutshell

Paero1 votes

{quoted}

If Riot implemented one idea out of every one hundred (from these forums), the game would be unplayable. It isn't that they hate the community, but instead they just don't trust it.

and it's completely understandable.

Exiled Morgana was created based off a players custom skin mod, so no it wouldn't be unplayable

NegusInParis3 votes

I'm pretty sure that they sometimes use content from other people's champion ideas (atleast we can hope)

ZT Xperimentor1 votes

Aram was a community idea.

Daedalus8714 votes

Agreed.

80% of what goes up on boards is circlejerk/memes. 90% of what is left is pure garbage and people should feel bad just for having those thoughts.

Mama Soraka4 votes

I'm commander Shepard and this is my favorite thread on the Citadel.

[slayer-pantheon-thumbs]

Hello I am Bird1 votes

Rammus Ok

VanBracken3 votes

Some people have the urge to create and communicate. I don't think there are a lot of people here who come with ideas and are all RITO PLZ Y U NO about it. They just like to share their thoughts and have fun with it.

ModCaptainMårvelous3 votes

I don't think anyone made these things for purpose of implementation into league and, while a lot are definitely not great, calling them outright trash is knda shitty you know.

Also players have influenced the game. Hell, Mordekaiser's title was a community suggestion and that was like three patches ago.

Paero2 votes

Terrible? You obviously havent seen my hammus the rammus concept http://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/skin-champion-concepts/BxMiEqdW-hammus-the-rammus

Mistress Madoka2 votes

There have been 1 or 2 REALLY GOOD Champ designs I've seen in the past year and the rest were basically "It's like Yasuo but on a horse" or something.

I prefer looking at skin Ideas over champ concepts regardless. Those are always more likely to happen than Champ concepts.

For example, skins that are inspired by Community Creations

Swashbuckler Katarina Battle Regalia Poppy Surprise Party Fiddle Dunkmaster Darius Primetime Draven Gravelord Azir

Champions that are inspired by Community Creations: Braum (Based on the Concept of Angus the manly support)

ThePartyLeader1 votes

You had me at hello.

Spacesuit Spiff1 votes

This just goes for creative stuff in general, until youre doing it for a living. Much more fun once you admit to yourself that youre nowhere near competent at it.

Fowus1 votes

plz don't encourage r e g o n a s

Ravenstiker1 votes

I think you forgot the JUST DO IT part

Ryvaku1 votes

Unprepared Garen! Come on. You know that skin is gonna be a gold mine if they made it.

Teslablade1 votes

Also, Riot maintains that they DON'T accept champion concepts or art. They don't want a lawsuit.

BuzzinTate1 votes

they could try contacting the user and asking permission to use the concept and implement it into a new champion all together

Not Sungben1 votes

If anyone is mad.. Just click this to make everything OK. http://make-everything-ok.com/

Rammus

Krizalid1 votes

This topic is like a knife into the hearts of creative newcomers, lol. Good thing I've accepted the truth long time ago.

Old Man Teeto1 votes

raises a drink to fun

ModAcademy Kayn1 votes

It's called trash can, not trash can't.

Fnz1 votes

This comment was the definition of an emotional roller coaster, from the infuriating title, to the touching body paragraph 5/7

regonas1 votes

[deleted]

Vorazun2 votes

Can you not just get over the fact that your concepts just aren't very good? At least I try and put some effort to put out a decent concept, and it gets appreciated by the community because of the time and effort I put into it.

Also. Stop harassing me.

More from Concepts & Creations

More by Onimarus