I love Shyvana's new splash art, your splash art team did another good job.
As for vayne's new splash... it's well done, but the colors are weird. It looks like you were going for 3d art that needs those cheap bi-colored glasses.
I actually have the opposite opinion.
Shyvana's stance in the splash just seems wrong for her. She never walks like that in game, she always has a wide stance. Wide stances grant stability and power because you're well balanced - but her seductive walk doesn't suit her personality or do her playstyle.
As for Vayne's it seems more like to me that it's supposed to look like a panel from a comic. Vayne's character takes a lot of inspiration from Batman and the stark contrasts of that picture just kind of emulate the aesthetic a "dark" graphic novel. And her outfit is black, blue and red so it's not like they added any colors for that type of 3D effect - that's just what she is!
There are things to like about it, but I hate it. It looks... off. It's like it doesn't know whether it wants to be sexy or menacing -it doesn't pull off both.
You want sexy? http://fc05.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2013/153/9/7/ice_drake_shyvana_portrait_riotzeronis_by_zeronis-d67lbpp.jpg
You want menacing? http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-j2cLf9tTdi0/T7IIZZiXA6I/AAAAAAAAClU/1-jcTXNaueE/s1600/darkflame_shyvana2.jpg
You want both? http://fc04.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2012/197/7/c/7c0b8c5240f298160067a2a82818c5cd-d57e46f.jpg
Shyvana is an extreme character. Her splashes should always capture something. The old splash captured power. Ironscale captures heart. Boneclaw captures predatory nature. Darkflame captures fury. Ice Drake captures remorselessness. This new skin doesn't say anything other than "Hey, I'm a skin in pretty new lines and colors!" This is why I hate most of the Chinese artworks (I do like some though.) The art is all skill and technique with no heart nor care. :(
I'm normally not a fan of getting to see Shyvana's hair on display, because I think not being able to see it gives her a more inhuman appearance. However, I will happily make the trade of getting to see her hair in exchange for her skin taking on a drastically scalier looking texture. In fact, I'm actually kind of sad now. For ages I've been dreading the idea of Shyvana getting a VU, fearing that she'd become more human looking if she did. Now, seeing this art, I'm disappointed that she's NOT getting a VU, because I would KILL to get that level of detail onto her in-game. Everything about that piece of art is absolutely gorgeous and amazingly badass and I want it so bad.
My opinion on Shyvana's new splash: I hate it.
I like the current Shyvana splash, and its biggest problems are problems that would need a VU to solve: she doesn't look particularly tanky in human form, and she needs more clothes. The new one looks more generic and too human, and I don't like the art style. It's also a rather static pose, like her current splash. A better splash would involve her doing something. (Casting her E? Melee killing something? Perhaps a little lore, protecting Jarvan IV from a dragon?)
