S3 is here and i'm super excited to see whose getting it. Please tell me who you think would make a good Star Guardian.
The Best (Opinion):
(so perfect, they're practically guarenteed a spot.)
(Don't you gimmie that look! SG needs a top laner!)
Honorable Mentions:
Good. But they have too many skins already.
(This would be sooo cute.)
(already given skins this year.)
Daedric Etwahl4 votesStar Guardian 
pleeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaase
Oleandervine3 votesTaric is not on your list, so I immediately disapprove.
ModWulf Helhammer3 votesTaliyah definitely. She’s up for a permanent second skin, and Star Guardian just goes right up her alley.
Neeko I’d say is also a given. She needs a skin before her Snowdown skin goes Legacy, and Star Guardian fits perfectly.
hazerddex3 votes obviously
also they already have a top laner star gardian 
[sg-poppy]
ChaosReyn3 votesI love how many passive-aggressive downvotes there are for literally no reason though. I get that people take their skins seriously, and SG even more so...but jeez people, have some respect for opinions. >.>
MasterLico2 votesi 100 percent agree except sivir she has enough good skins already with pizza delivery poolparty and blood moon
Oleandervine2 votesi 100 percent agree except sivir she has enough good skins already with pizza delivery poolparty and blood moon
Ehhhhh. That's not really the case though. Outside of Pizza Delivery and the New Blood Moon, Sivir's only other skin that actually modifies all of her particles is Snowstorm. The rest just change how Q and W looks (to match her blade), without changing her E or R at all. So that's 3 skins in her entire catalog that actually have the full spread for Sivir, and it's pretty shameful. She definitely could use a Star Guardian skin, IMO, because it'd be fun in the way that it could mimic Sailor Moon's Moon Tiara boomerang ability.
MasterLico2 votesEhhhhh. That's not really the case though. Outside of Pizza Delivery and the New Blood Moon, Sivir's only other skin that actually modifies all of her particles is Snowstorm. The rest just change how Q and W looks (to match her blade), without changing her E or R at all. So that's 3 skins in her entire catalog that actually have the full spread for Sivir, and it's pretty shameful. She definitely could use a Star Guardian skin, IMO, because it'd be fun in the way that it could mimic Sailor Moon's Moon Tiara boomerang ability.
oh sry im not really a sivir main those skins just popped up when i was thinking of sivir skins :D
you get the point tho
Oleandervine1 votesoh sry im not really a sivir main those skins just popped up when i was thinking of sivir skins :D
you get the point tho
I guess I do, but Sivir doesn't have a pool party skin. I think of the older champions who could use more skins, Sivir is one.
MasterLico1 votesI guess I do, but Sivir doesn't have a pool party skin. I think of the older champions who could use more skins, Sivir is one.
oh f me im mistaking poolparty caitlin for snow day sivir im so sry*[sg-miss-fortune]*
MankeyMadness1 votessivir poolparty
Can you post this skins splash? Sivir is a personal favorite among ADCs but ive never heard of this skin.
Also PP for these lovely marksmen when? 
ChaosReyn1 votesSivir doesn't have a Pool Party skin...but I think I remember seeing her idly in the background of one of the other pool party splashes.
One of the earlier ones...that or it was someone else with dark hair, and im just blind af. >.>
DoktorKaiser2 votes
Caretaker Jack1 votesThat should seriously be an April fools skin.
Butterwood2 votes
The stars, the trees - he guards everyone!
ZevBenjamin2 votesStar Guardian 
Caretaker Jack1 votestoo old imo, but I do feel like it's cute.
ChaosReyn2 votesSlew of "STAR GUARDIAN URGOT!!!" Incoming...but to be serious for a moment:
Top has a SG skin (Poppy) but it definitely needs more. I however will expressly say though: Screw Riven. Not a single Riven player I've ever seen in game is worthy of getting such a skin - they're all mad toxic, even if they're winning...and besides that, her character doesn't really fit the guardian code, and her animations would be hard to translate into a good SG skin anyway. I would personally say 
would be a decent top SG skin. Yes, I am aware the VAST majority of Star Guardians are females and Ez was supposed to be an exception...but Shen could be more like Tuxedo Mask in this case, being that one random guy that shows up out of nowhere, probably saving someone, landing like 3-5 autos in the entire fight, and declaring his absolute victory before disappearing into the night. No hate against Shen: top lane is "The Island" and Shen loves to splitpush, so as far as teamfights go, I imagine this just fits his usual playstyle of going it alone and only popping in to help his team occasionally.
I am 200% down with Taliyah. The only reason I am saying no to Star Guardian Zoe is that she's Targonian, and basically already a Star Guardian, in her own way. However...First Star Zoe would be something to see, if you want to push the subject further, as she would make the most sense - A Star Guardian born of the stars. But that'll never happen, because the community hates on her too much over her kit. >.>
needs to be a thing, straight up. One of the oldest champions in the game, with an ultimate that literally screams "I protecc" should be at least an honorable mention.
is another candidate I'm looking at...she already has a pet (all the star guardians seem to) and Riot describes her as the "firefighter" of LoL - flying around the map at mach 6 to help her team wherever she can. Plus, it'd be a very viable jungle option.
Caretaker Jack1 votesShen just doesn't have that appeal to me, but I guess it's possible.... In some respects, I do think Kayle and Quinn would be okay.
Personally, Zoe being cosmic shouldn't stop her from being a star guardian. She really does fit the theme and I think it would be a shame to let that stop her from joining the crew.
PinkPowerCoin2 votesMy top picks would be 
Caretaker Jack1 votesAnnie is a cute option that I completely overlooked..
Chembaron Yamada2 votesMy preferred picks would be:
It would even be a full team. Caitlyn bot, Orianna mid, Quinn top, Taliyah jungle, and Sona support.
And yes, Caitlyn might have alot of skins, but that doesn't stop other champs to get more, so why should it stop her. She could be the intelligent and calculating member of the team, the strategist.
Orianna would be great because she could fulfill an interesting trope in my eyes. Kuudere, she might seem emotionless to strangers, but she actually cares alot about her friends. Maybe she got hurt on a mission and the first star was able to save her by giving her a magical, artificial body.
Quinn and Valor as magical girl and her familiar would fit too perfect to not give her a skin here.
Taliyah needs another skin, since the only one she got was because of worlds. I imagine her as himedere, acting like a princess (her sleeves would fit an outfit based on that).
And Sona fits the Star Guardians pretty well and was the only one coming to my mind for a support. ^^
Rathar Dashing2 votesDream team for me is
ZaneShadow2 votes
This would be a pretty amazing team in my opinion. Rakan Xaya would be amazing, and Oriana fits that weird but somehow universally present “robot girl” trope.
I also really like taliya because there are no SG junglers
My honorary mentions:
Caretaker Jack2 votesWhen you describe Orianna that way, it makes me want to see her as a Star Guardian too..
Winterkill2 votesI would love to see Karma, Zyra, Neeko, Xeyah and Rakhan.
wolvius2 votes[{quoted}](name=Caretaker Jack,realm=NA,application-id=A8FQeEA8,discussion-id=h2IvBAtM,comment-id=,timestamp=2019-02-12T17:02:48.772+0000)
https://d.facdn.net/art/galrock/1517775579/1517775579.galrock_star_guardian_ornn.jpg Your prayers have been answered.
Caretaker Jack1 votesrofl. literally made my day
ORB1TS1 votesConfirmed New Star Guardian skins are Xayah, Rakan, Taliyah, LeBlanc and Neeko.
Caretaker Jack1 voteshow do you know? I'm fuckin hyped for xayah and rakan tbh... Leblanc and Neeko feel out of place though. Neeko is too new and it doesn't fit her too well while LeBlanc is just too badass for the brand. I'd prefer to see her in almost any other space theme skin line.
ChaosReyn1 votesAre they really confirmed?
I would've thought LB would end up with a Dark Star skin, personally (damn Black Rose Illusionist...) but then again, Syndra ended up on the roster, so I cant be surprised.
Caretaker Jack1 votesSyndra was surprising, wasn't she? Hahaha. I gotta agree with you here.
General Matty2 votes[{quoted}](name=Caretaker Jack,realm=NA,application-id=A8FQeEA8,discussion-id=h2IvBAtM,comment-id=00060000,timestamp=2019-02-14T09:22:49.832+0000)
how do you know? I'm fuckin hyped for xayah and rakan tbh... Leblanc and Neeko feel out of place though. Neeko is too new and it doesn't fit her too well while LeBlanc is just too badass for the brand. I'd prefer to see her in almost any other space theme skin line.
Leblanc seems more like she would fit the dark star line, and Xayah and Rakan seem pretty cool for the line though.
Chembaron Yamada2 votesThese are not confirmed at all, it was a fake leak.
Rathar Dashing1 votesThose aren't even the champs from the big fake leak, which had Nunu and Tristana and Zoe as a good/evil star guardian. Only thing it got right that I can remember so far was that Tahm and Sej were getting new years skins, which was a pretty easy prediction given year of the pig.
Chembaron Yamada1 votesHuh, you are right. How did he come up that these are confirmed then?
Another fake leak I don't know about yet? XD
Rathar Dashing1 votesI can't even find the old leak anywhere. Haven't seen anything about a new one.
Linna Excel1 votesTop:
Jungle: 
Mid: (make her legendary so she can be human)
ADC:
Support:
Chembaron Yamada2 votesOrianna doesn't even need to be human in that skin line. Robot girls are a trope in anime and they could quite easily explain her. They are fighting dangerous creatures, maybe Orianna got almost killed in a fight and the first star was able to prevent that by granting her a new, magical, artificial body.
Kindred as a Star Guardian would be a bit out of place for me, tho.
Rathar Dashing2 votesYou could even give Orianna the Astro Boy treatment, very similar to her own current lore.
Linna Excel1 votesI'm thinking Kindred would work in that the star guardians seem to have an animal friend and she's got one built into her kit.
Chembaron Yamada2 votesAlright, that's the reason I support Star Guardian picks like as well.
But the reason why Kindred is a bit awkward for me is not because of that.... it's lamb....
All Star Guardians have been clearly humanoid to this point.
While these champions are not entirely human, they resemble humans still alot and the most important part for me: facial expression.
All these champions you see clearly human faces on, they feel more relatable because of that for me.
These would fall in the same category. Not human, but enough so I could imagine them as magical girls (or boy in case of Rakan).
But Kindred is different.... We don't see lambs face because of the mask and this mask is an iconic feature of the champion, they will probably always wear a mask in every of their skins. So no facial expression here. Adding to that the animalistic body, lamb does stray too much for me. I can't see lamb as a magical girl. Lamb falls for me in the same category like Twitch, he is humanoid too, but strays too much to be considered for such a skin line.
I probably can't explain it well... let's say it that way; Champions like Nami and Ahri for me are humans with animal features. Stuff like Twitch and Kindred tend for me to be seen as animals with human features. Don't know if this makes sense, but that's how I see it. :/
Rathar Dashing2 votesTristana's not a star guardian.
Chembaron Yamada1 votesUps, that was a mistake, she actually belongs in the "isn't, but possible candidate" category. ^^ Gonna fix that, thanks for pointing that out.
Rathar Dashing1 votesNo problem.
Caretaker Jack1 votesI agree... Like, come on people! Haven't yall ever played Persona???
Chembaron Yamada2 votesHell yeah, exactly.
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b4/36/b4/b436b4b80a3599fd4988ec5d2aa517b6.jpg An Orianna skin referencing her would be so perfect. [sg-jinx]
Caretaker Jack1 votesRight?? I'm drooling at the thought! And she could really use a good quality skin...
General Matty1 votesObviously we need Nunu and Taric.
Rathar Dashing1 votesNunu yes, Taric not so much.
