Boards›Concepts & Creations

[CWC] Civil War Contest Voting

showcase25·6/30/2018, 10:47:02 PM·10 votes·22,224 views

#Welcome

VOTING HAS ENDED!

This post is official place for voting for the first Civil War Contest [CWC]! Please see below for voting rules and conditions.

#Voting Rules

  1. Voting will only be counted on vote cast on this post.
  2. Voting will be considered cast by commenting.
  3. Comments need to include "I cast my vote for" or other unambiguous wording casting your vote.
  4. You may either vote for one the two options: Super Heros or Super Villains.
  5. Each comment will be responded with "Vote Counted!".
  6. Each person may have one and only one vote.
  7. All votes will be listed below in the Vote Tally section.
  8. The team with the most votes win.

#Entrants

| Super Heroes | 　 | Super Villains | |- | Spider-Man, the Webslinger by Showcase25 | 　 | Black Ace by Psychoaryama | | Master Oogway, the Grand Master of Kung Fu by Norksmeine | 　 | Drakath, The Champion of Chaos by Drakath2002 | | Steve Rodgers, Captain America by MajínBuu | 　 | Dormammu, the Cosmic Reaver by nasu010 | | Sakuya Izayoi, the Scarlet Devil's Maid by LuaDotExe | 　 | Darth Vader, The Imperial Conqueror by Infinite Irelia | | Ladybug, the Lucky Charm by Vanic998 | 　 | Ainz Ooal Gown, the Overlord by xUnRavelx |

#Timeline

06/30/2018 - Entry period closes, Voting begins. 07/07/2018 - Results announced, discussion on future contest begins.

#Voting Tally

| Super Heroes: 2 | 　 | Super Villains: 4 | |- | Vanic998 | 　 | nasu010 | | Norksmeine | 　 | Psychoaryama | | - | 　 | Tamur | | - | 　 | LuaDotExe | | - | 　 | - |

#Final Tally

| Super Heroes | 　 | Super Villains | |- | 2 | 　 | 4 | | 　 | 　 | 　 |

###Super Villains Win!

Thanks everyone!

44 Comments

LuaDotExe7/6/2018, 6:02:48 PM2 votes

Well, considering I tried really hard to balance my potentially oppressive kit, only to see a potential 2.5 to 3.5 second disable on a basic ability?

Villains win.

Gauging it off of "who would win" isn't really good, since you come into predicaments where you have a 3000 range whole-team teleport on a basic ability against what is potentially a literal shoe box for an ultimate.

Psychoaryama7/1/2018, 8:12:02 AM1 votes

The heroes have a surprisingly well-balanced team, but most of the villains just seem like they're near-perfect counters to the hero team. I have to vote for the villains on this one.

nasu0107/1/2018, 2:58:49 PM1 votes

Dormammu the cosmic reaver" Ha ha ha the time has come my champions rise, onwards to dominion. All shall bow before our might. Mortals, tremble!, The Dark side compels you.

I vote for the dark side

LuaDotExe7/1/2018, 4:06:52 PM1 votes

I thought I left a comment on this, but perhaps a Strawpoll would be better? Also, I'm not sure what the criteria upon which we're voting is. Is this like... kit design, matchups, or?

Psychoaryama7/1/2018, 4:58:22 PM1 votes

I do feel like there should be a separate system for voting which side overall had the best kit designs by LoL's standards, because the main reason I'm voting for super villains is just how OP the villain side seems. Drakath2002 stated on his Drakath concept that he knows just how OP his design is and he kept it that way to stay true to the Drakath character. Meanwhile Dormammu was just really hard to balance without losing some crucial aspect of the character, and while it's much more well-balanced now than it originally was, it's still just an issue of how powerful the character has to be in order to still be Dormammu. The same kinda goes for Darth Vader and Ainz, the creators did make the characters as balanced as I feel they could be, but they just have to be insanely powerful to stay true to the characters. The only thing that made Black Ace a bit easier to balance was that his character isn't as powerful as the others on the villain side, so naturally his LoL-ized kit wouldn't be quite as powerful, and even then he'd be quite the pain to have to deal with if he were added to LoL.

So just for the face-off, I just have to go with the villains, but if we were talking about the actual character designs, I feel like the heroes stayed more well-balanced. So maybe there should be two voting categories: in the first we decide which side we think would win, and the second is which side you think had the best overall kit designs, with balance being included as a factor.

Vanic9987/1/2018, 6:25:28 PM1 votes

I vote for heroes.

nasu0107/1/2018, 6:47:26 PM1 votes

Considering the fact that this is a contest should we create more hype to generate some traffic so more people can come to comment? Or at least make the page name more dramatic CWC Heros Vs Villans, The Battle Has Began

Tamur7/3/2018, 9:57:52 PM1 votes

After going though and reading both the posts and various sources from net. I cast my vote for the Villains

Psychoaryama7/4/2018, 2:35:17 AM1 votes

Just checking, why does it say there are 3 votes for Super Heroes when the only person you have listed who voted for Super Heroes is Vanic?

Norksmeine7/6/2018, 10:52:19 AM1 votes

[deleted]

nasu0107/7/2018, 1:45:25 PM1 votes

To be honest I thought it would be more like how well you could intigrate a marvel hero or Gillian into lol and make them balanced I was expecting to see interesting variations of lol'ized marvel characters thus the reason for my concept of Dormammu who is actually supposed to be named Demir . To avoid copy write.

xUnRavelx7/10/2018, 3:16:15 AM1 votes

Could we have a new contest ASAP. I have holidays for a week and i wish i could make new champion concepts. They are just so fun!!!

Norksmeine7/10/2018, 1:01:43 PM1 votes

omg villains leading

TheChainWarden217/12/2018, 6:58:49 PM1 votes

i vote for spiderman Elise

nasu0107/13/2018, 1:04:43 PM1 votes

Then let's do a game mode contest most likely to be created / easiest to implement, that's fun and original objective can be point based or unique ( survival of the fittest (like an areana mode, would love to have that)

And with that here's my entry

https://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/skin-champion-concepts/zLa5RArh-ozhirim-inspired-game-mode-water-line

EvilGrinNol7/13/2018, 8:32:32 PM1 votes

So, just so I understand, they created champions based off characters from other series and then we vote for the side that has the best ones?

nasu0107/16/2018, 1:12:55 AM1 votes

Hmmm is it just me or was this kind of anticlimactic? I feel like there should have been a judging post or maybe a fantasy battle commentary of how this battle would play out cuz if you notice the heroes have allot more synergy and look like they would make a more versatile team to fight against where as the Villans are more of a set of soloers exception of dormammu (who would still be able to sol) who has multiple ways of hindering enimes for teammates to followup I honestly can't remember the full kits for the other Villans but I know black ace has a grab which can be used with Dormammu's rift W, Ains has the goal of life which is a kill move that can be used when enemies are snared by fiends but as for the rest, am not sure.

I just think that this contest ended in a somewhat dissatisfying way where the voting wasn't even completed! 😕 I mean the contestants didn't even bother to vote for their own concepts .

Anyway if this is happening again I have some ideas on how we can make the next one . Also If you liked my concept of Dormammu I have a gallery where I post all my ideas feel free to check it out and leave a comment. https://boards.na.leagueoflegends.com/en/c/skin-champion-concepts/Eal50gAL-nasu-010-concepts-gallery

Stay frosty [vlad-salute]

Psychoaryama7/1/2018, 12:59:52 AM1 votes

Wow, it actually turned out as 5 v 5 XD

showcase257/16/2018, 12:11:53 PM1 votes

Hey everyone.

Apologies for my absence:

I've had a professional. familial, and personal health related incident and situations all within the past week right before voting ended, both positive and negative. It took me away from the boards, needing some time to clear things up and get me back together. But things are clear... at least for now.

Getting back to the contest:

I scanned the comments for any additional votes cast within the valid time frame, and see none to add. I will recheck the current tally and post the winning team above.

Regarding the future of the contest:

I already see good ideas and discussion regarding the future of the contest. I may be able to kick off future contest, but with the recent life changes, I may ask for a successor to this contest, and will share any knowledge and assist on start up.

Again, I thank you for your understanding and patience.