Skip to content

Why does forum search feel like it was built by kids from a school project?

SnowFall··5 votes·1,361 views

For example I put two words in my search: "athene buff" What does it show me? Right, only things that were buffed, not a single mention of athene. It's just plain wrong, people.

10 Comments

yellowbricks2 votes

This whole forum feels like a grade school project. Oh look I click gameplay and balance and I'm in the role-playing forum for some retarded reason. And now I'm early to the party. And now I'm not authorized to downvote a post until I click it 5 more times.

Pro tip to riot, make sure your shitty replacement works before you force people to put up with your horrid beta.

the Anarchit3cht1 votes

Why does Snowfall not know how a search engine functions? Don't blame your mistakes on something else.

Daen4 votes

[{quoted}](name=the Anarchit3cht,realm=NA,application-id=bzRrPGQO,discussion-id=crHi3usg,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2014-12-12T17:37:34.203+0000) Why does Snowfall not know how a search engine functions? Don't blame your mistakes on something else.

It basically doesn't function unless you know the exact title of a thread or are willing to put in a long string of keywords. Search has really weird priorities, and I'll show some examples:

Search: "Cassiopeia Riot Stashu" Results: No threads created by Riot Stashu with Cassiopeia in the title were pulled to the first page.

Search: "Daen" Results: No threads I created or even posted on were pulled at all.

Search: "Tamat" Results: No threads created by Tamat were pulled to the first page, only 2 of the results had posts by him.


Yeah. Search is not working like other search engines, and it completely ignores basic sorting like searching by user.

the Anarchit3cht1 votes

You clearly don't understand how a search engine functions. For instance, I searched "athenes" and I got multiple threads about the athene changes.

Daen3 votes

[{quoted}](name=the Anarchit3cht,realm=NA,application-id=bzRrPGQO,discussion-id=crHi3usg,comment-id=000000000000,timestamp=2014-12-12T18:23:37.461+0000) You clearly don't understand how a search engine functions. For instance, I searched "athenes" and I got multiple threads about the athene changes.

That's not surprising, it's a simple linear search of "find word and display results". The question is, when you search "athenes" are you getting the most popular/important threads related to the search term? From what I can tell, it's in no particular order. Additionally, if you use the "Has Riot Comments" option, it removes the thread "@Riot, regarding Athene's Unholy Grail in 4.10" that has Riot comments. That makes zero sense.

LOL, actually. I just searched for "Athene's" and it pulled up completely different results from "Athenes". Not only that, when I also selected "Has Riot Comments" it completely ignored the search term I had put in and just pulled random threads.

The search engine here doesn't put words together properly, which is one of the big issues. Try putting Athenes Buff into the search bar; the results are, for the most part, talking about EITHER "athenes" OR "buff", it's not putting them together correctly.

Plus, it randomly returns a blank screen with no results. Good stuff.


I understand how a search engine functions perfectly. This one does not work properly, in any sense of the word.

the Anarchit3cht1 votes

It's working completely as intended and as any search engine would. It doesn't have all the features you might find desirable in a search engine but that's a different issue entirely--as are bugs such as returning a blank page.

Daen1 votes

[{quoted}](name=the Anarchit3cht,realm=NA,application-id=bzRrPGQO,discussion-id=crHi3usg,comment-id=00000000000000000000,timestamp=2014-12-13T04:26:56.119+0000) It's working completely as intended and as any search engine would. It doesn't have all the features you might find desirable in a search engine but that's a different issue entirely--as are bugs such as returning a blank page.

If it's working completely as intended, why are they fixing it?

It doesn't have all the features you might find desirable in a search engine

It literally doesn't function as a search engine in many circumstances. Successful search engines don't completely ignore search terms, that just isn't supposed to happen. Google is a far better tool for finding threads on this platform, and it's not even specifically limited to the Boards as the default functionality should be.

If adding an apostrophe completely changes the results and changing a filter setting results in the search completely ignoring the search term(s), that's not working as intended.

the Anarchit3cht1 votes

do me a favor. search athenes and then search athene's in google.

the Anarchit3cht1 votes

not to mention on top of that it has like 3 different sets of filters you can apply to narrow your results.

for instance, search simply cassiopeia and filter it to show threads with red posts. I saw multiple threads created by Stashu on the first page.

Dr Clueless PhD1 votes

AFAIK, it works like most other search engines. It'll show you top results based on your terms. If the top results don't have all of them, they're still top. If you want something that has ALL of your terms, you need to specify that.

More from Boards Feedback

More by SnowFall