New Hud and why I will not play until it is reverted FELLOW COUNTRY MEN LEND ME YOUR EAR!

Paintank·7/23/2015, 10:04:54 PM·12 votes·908 views

The new HUD in it's current form was always destined to fail. Conceptually, it was a poor design and add in the fact that the populace as a whole have an aversion to change and there was no chance.

Aversion to change aside though, this HUD would never work and the main reason for that is the area that it draws your eye to.

Yes, there are a lot of things that I don't enjoy about the hud - Color, size, lack of detail in the important areas - but the most important thing that they changed is the location of where they put things. With the old hud there was balance everywhere. It drew your eye to the center and allowed you to focus on what was happening. With the new hud, everything is focused to the bottom right of the screen. There is currently no reason to look on the left side of the screen unless you're checking an opponents stats and even then, it's generally more strategic to hit tab and just guess around where their stats are based off of items for fear of taking your eyes off of what's important for too long.

This is very important because it throws off every skill shot, and basically gives us a blind spot on the left hand side. In addition to that, the placement of the ally icons were not thought out very well. Placing them above the map is a bad idea because if you attempt to click on ally icon - as many shen players do - you run the risk of accidently clicking somewhere on the map by accident and screwing your self up bad.

So as my note to Riot, this was a poor concept that was conceptually bad and had no thought put into it. If you wanted to revamp the HUD you should have just given it a face lift and not changed where things were. There's an old adage that states "if it aint broke, don't fix it." and that applies to this scenario. It doesn't mean don't try and update it, but don't change the aspects of it that weren't in need of changing - primarily, location (side note: that idea to have all stats hidden normally was a stupid idea) . The best way to fix it is to roll back the new hud, and leave it out until you're able to create a patch that allows the user to pick which Hud - classic or new- that they would like to use.

Until then, this hud has made the game legitimately unplayable for me as my favorite champions are skill shot champions and with this hud throwing off my orientation so bad, there's no reason for me to play, all I would do is get frustrated. I'll be back when you decide to change things back to how they were.

I would ask that anyone who has a strong aversion to the hud and not change, to stop playing for this time being. Riot may be able to ignore comments, but a drop in sales immediately following the HUD update will force them to change.

6 Comments

Shiny Pidgey7/23/2015, 10:12:40 PM3 votes

They should just have the option to choose between huds. And copy dota with choosing an announcer. I don't like Gangplank talking.

Two Liter7/24/2015, 1:21:38 AM2 votes

The new hud made it impossible to play, Thanks rito....

Eleshakai7/23/2015, 10:18:04 PM1 votes

well you've voiced your feedback well. If it doesn't work, you're right. Quitting is the only option you have.

That's what I did when I disagreed with the direction their PB team was taking.

It didn't do much good in my case, but hopefully you have better luck. lol

Buttigieg 20207/23/2015, 10:37:37 PM1 votes

+1 for Julius Caesar.

LMTR147/24/2015, 2:35:54 PM1 votes

I actually quit. I was very committed to this game, playing over 3000 games in 2 years, but one game with the new epic failhud was enough. pretty much all decisions since the start of s5 were atrocious, but this is the end of the line.

hope very much they give the option to revert, but until then, I'm out of a multiplayer game to play :-(

also posted on my blog about this fiasco: http://supersanereviews.blogspot.co.at/2015/07/rip-league-of-legends.html

NICOLAS787/25/2015, 7:02:09 PM1 votes

SAME HERE

My wife and I stop playing for now

WHAT I LIKE OF NEW HUD :

mothing really

WHAT I DO NOT LIKE OF NEW HUD (A LOT OF STUFF) :

  • unlike they seems to THINK my experience is i click more and scroll more on -bottom_mid- than on - bottom_left... and that actually expose me more now to not see or not click, whereas the bottom left is empty ... i do not care too much but it looks silly... now if i add my 2 cents why not to put the top right stuff in top left then - if it s to clear the diagonal ... to me all corners can be filled with data that go together because of one bulk is too much to process old HUD was smart - allies left - map bottom right - time, ping, fps ... top right ... and so on. the important area to be free of panels is a CIRCLE around the center ...
  • missing ping buttons (to welcome new players...) i actually used it to avoid misclicking F...
  • spells current levels hard to see (gold box changed into a small dot ...)
  • can not see your own stats correctly they are not even displayed by default and NO BUTTON VISIBLE !? (need to know the keys ... values colors disappeared... keep going that kind of "improvements" guys !)
  • why to spotlight the range ??? i never ever cared before - you find out by shooting or being shot anyway...
  • i know to read but i do not know to read icons... and tiny font over the top... geniuses ! restore colors too.
  • useful values meaningful TOGETHER are not located at the same place (time / minions / kills / ...)
  • can not see the ping color - i don t have time to READ the small grey text ...- i used to see green or not ... (and of course no button ...)
  • one single area where too much is stacked making me have to dig in a bulk of values to find what i need (NOT SIMPLER NO), if you misclick ... too bad you clicked the map
  • old map was easier to read (my personal preference)
  • some fonts/colors are hard to read (ping, map area ...)
  • too many animations for things that you do not need vs no spotlight on what you actually need
  • announcer is irritating - i would like it as before instead - looks like a 5 y old game voice and comments
  • blue is not for mana anymore, it s for every single thing that happens in the game now to warn you of things you know or do not care, i thought i was out of mana a few times

ALLIES

  • portraits too small (cant see WHO IS IT if something is over it...)
  • can not click allies easily
  • can not really see allies health bars (soraka play ... too bad) neither click it easily
  • can not mute, or chat to all (actually unless you found the trick for it again...)

TAB section

  • why is there a sound for tab ??? i ncase i dont know i hit tab and i dont see it neither ???
  • can not read players names anymore (we can but after some tricks ... welcome again)
  • old tab window was easier to read for me before ... all one column - important being MY CHAMP being easy to SEE vs others - i could also see in one sight all kills for example (BOTH SIDE)
  • when i play with friends ... CAN NOT SEE THE NAMES !

UNFORTUNATELY it seems all this was DEVELOPED and pushed WITHOUT / AGAINST feedback for something that was not a problem to begin with... so if they are as proud as deaf ... they will not roll back... correct ? the one that made it first place wont roll it back if it means to admit an error he was warned about... and no BS : it is not hard to offer the old HUD as a choice nor it is too hard to have a customizeable UI but what do i know ... i m software engineer so THANKS guys for forcing me your improvements it might actually motivate me to change of game That also give a taste of the philosophy of the company in regards to the players feedback