My take on punishments

Nucleophilic atk··4 votes·667 views

You chat ban toxic players. Makes sense. I don't agree with rank banning, though. I think rank ban should be a punishment for players that troll in ranked games. Toxic? Chat ban. Troll ranked games? Ranked ban. Why are we mixing the two?

24 Comments

Jiberamu3 votes

i agree i never saw chatting as a problem ive played cs go cod you name it trash talk is great keeps games entertaining only problem is when someone is trying to lose the game. I still dont get why there is a punishment for something you yourself can fix (mute option)

Nucleophilic atk1 votes

Well yeah, I totally think they are waaaaay to sensitive with the chat punishments. That isn't my argument here, however. I am just saying it doesn't make sense to ban someone from playing ranked for just "toxic" language. You ban their chatting ability. It wouldn't make sense to chat ban someone that is nice but trolling ranked would it? No. So I don't get why they do the opposite. But yes, people should just mute if they have a problem.

Jiberamu1 votes

kinda like what they were talkin about on summoning insight ive seen so many what lyte would call (toxic) players be the best most hepful players in the games they play they just want to win, nobody gets banned in korea what for what people do in na because they know what competitveness is you play ranked you are playing to win and can/will have pressure on you maybe its why they have faker and we have 3/5 of the north american teams as europeans because nobody takes it seriously

arcinex1 votes

{quoted}

i agree i never saw chatting as a problem ive played cs go cod you name it trash talk is great keeps games entertaining only problem is when someone is trying to lose the game. I still dont get why there is a punishment for something you yourself can fix (mute option)

A million times this.

On another note, I recently finished playing a game where we had our adc afk the entire game and before the enemy team finally after forever ends the game we all say: "Welp.. time to go back to :gamename:"

Lmao.

arcinex2 votes

LMFAO I wish it was only a chat ban. I got first time warning being toxic with a TWO WEEK BAN. Tell me how this is fair guys. TWO WEEK ACCOUNT BAN FOR A WARNING. LMFAO.

phirestarter2 votes

That makes way too much sense.

disregardable2 votes

That's like asking "Why do people go to jail for stealing someone's credit card information? They only committed a paper crime, so they should only have a paper punishment (a fine)".

The goal of Riot's punishment system is to reform. When taking away chat isn't enough incentive for you to be less toxic, they give you another incentive.

Nucleophilic atk1 votes

False. It would be more comparable to taking away someone's driver license because they were caught stealing some gum.

ZeeDrakon1 votes

Because low elo players tend to lable people performing poorly as trolls.

Nucleophilic atk2 votes

Not in my experience, actually. People are generally good at determining actual trolls from people playing badly. It's actually a decently easy thing to notice.

ZeeDrakon1 votes

Ive experienced the exakt opposite. People look for reasons they lost other than themselves, and if they played poorly, teammates "feeding" is not enough. So they call trolls. Ive played on low elo accounts and there was not a single game where noone was called troll (and most likely reported as troll aswell) with only a few serious trolls

Nucleophilic atk1 votes

{quoted}

People look for reasons they lost other than themselves

I disagree with this statement in so many ways lol. People in this game take, "please don't chase the tank into the unwarded jungle" and reply "dude stop acting superior. you aren't good either. if you were good you would carry". I'm sorry, but I personally don't expect 1 single person to have a bigger effect on the game than 9 players, and most of the time the reason you lose is a team effort, not "look at your own play and see what you could have done better". You can easily look at your own play and see what you could improve, while still telling some asshat to stop 1v3 diving.

If you are 0-4 and continue to fight the fed lane enemy, you are trolling. You KNOW that fighting will result in death, so you are intentionally feeding. Like I said, it is easy to see someone that just faced a better opponent, but if you are shoving your lane with 0 vision against a fed enemy and then complaining that "i gotzed camped bruh lolz jus a gam nuub", you are trolling.

ZeeDrakon1 votes

You seem to highly underestimate the people that complain about elo hell, that actually think hey deserve plat/dia when in bronze/silver and that generally suffer fom dunning kruger effect

Nucleophilic atk1 votes

And you over estimate the amount of these players there are.

ZeeDrakon1 votes

How so? And how is that important in this context?

Nucleophilic atk1 votes

Are you kidding? How is that important in this context?

People are generally good at determining actual trolls from people playing badly

.

Ive experienced the exakt opposite You seem to highly underestimate the people that complain about elo hell,

.

And you over estimate the amount of these players there are

ZeeDrakon1 votes

Shit i didnt see the "these" sorry.

No i dont think i do. Pretty much everyone in my.friendlist that is lower than gold 3 thinks he deserves at least one league higher. Amd many people on the forums do so too

Nucleophilic atk1 votes

Well to be honest, it is probably because they don't understand the ranking system. The ranking system doesn't place you based on how good you are, it places you based on how much you can "carry" the game. Dumb in my opinion, but really the only way I can see it being done. You think I feel I deserve silver? Nope lol. Was gold last season. I even dou'd with my Plat 1 friend while I was gold. We wen't 3-0 before he reached diamond and we could no longer duo. But, I have been playing ADC lately, and just winning lane isn't effective because I can look at the score and see the enemy mid and top have a combined 15 kills at 10 mins. GG. Thinking you belong in a higher elo doesn't make you a dick. I know people consider me a dick because I say things like "please play safe since you have died 3 times". More often than not I get a "stop harassing me /all report toxic". That is the game that rito has evolved. Anyway...I digress...

ZeeDrakon1 votes

I agree, they dont understand the ranking system. And IMO thats like 80% of players in bronze and silver, and thats the vaaast majority of people playing ranked in general. And those would abuse what you suggested because they label everything as trolls... :/

bad arcade kitty1 votes

i agree, i don't play ranked why do i get ranked restricted? 2 games ranked restriction at first, 35 games ranked restriction then (also like 100 games chat restrictions summarily), 0 ranked games played, 0 games intentionally fed, a couple of games i lane trolled for 2-3 minutes running from lane to lane to confuse people what i wanted... all those restrictions are simply for speaking with people in the lobby. most of reports went when i was on a series of win streaks too

Jubbinaut1 votes

That's actually really strange. Ranked restrictions are supposed to only be issued for toxic behavior in Ranked games. So if you aren't playing Ranked, you shouldn't be receiving them.

Are you otherwise capable of playing Ranked (lvl 30/16 champs owned)? There is a known bug that shows up now and then that shows players looking at the Ranked queue that they're Restricted, when it's actually a different issue preventing them from queuing.

bad arcade kitty1 votes

{quoted}

Are you otherwise capable of playing Ranked (lvl 30/16 champs owned)? There is a known bug that shows up now and then that shows players looking at the Ranked queue that they're Restricted, when it's actually a different issue preventing them from queuing.

yeah, i can play them obviously no, it's an actual restriction with a counter which decreases after each normal draft win, a pop up window etc

Jubbinaut1 votes

That's really strange, and it's really not supposed to happen. If you haven't yet, you might submit a Support ticket asking how you received a Ranked Restriction with no Ranked games played.

Alternatively, you might hit up Lyte on Twitter (@RiotLyte) or Reddit (/u/RiotLyte). I'm sure he'd love to know there's something causing Ranked Restrictions for players who aren't playing Ranked - can't fix bugs if you don't really know they're happening. Or at least he might be able to offer more insight into it.

Jubbinaut1 votes

[{quoted}](name=Nucleophilic atk,realm=NA,application-id=cIfEodbz,discussion-id=566WFaFr,comment-id=,timestamp=2015-04-06T00:18:24.711+0000)

Toxic? Chat ban. Troll ranked games? Ranked ban. Why are we mixing the two?

Because Riot considers trolling to be a form of toxic behavior. They also consider verbal abuse/harassment/chat spam/offensive language/etc to be a form of toxic behavior.

There are only two forms of sanction available for non-verbal toxicity at the moment: Ranked Restrictions and Time Bans. As such, players who troll, grief, or are otherwise toxic without using chat are more likely to receive a Ranked Restriction quicker.

Meanwhile, chat restrictions are explicitly intended to address verbal toxicity. However, should chat restrictions prove ineffective, future sanctions can be escalated to Ranked restrictions or even Time Bans, depending on the severity or frequency. It's important that these tools remain available for use in appropriate situations - as incentives, they can both be very useful in encouraging reform.

More from [ARCHIVED] Miscellaneous

More by Nucleophilic atk