Our voices fall upon deaf ears.
Trying to explain why our champion deserved to stay in the game is an impossible task. Misconceptions, stigma, word vomit, hive mind, lack of empathy... there's plenty of things the general community and Riot can use to justify why Aatrox was 'bad' for the game despite barely playing him/seeing him.
Most turn a blind eye to the hypocrisy on the reasons why Aatrox was changed.
Too toxic for the game due to lifesteal and auto-attacking?
The same champion who got absolutely fucked by bramble vest, had only 1 mobility spell/hard cc spell and was a squishy champion who built primarily offensive without being a good cdr abuser? Yeah, he was obviously just a broken, brain-dead piece of shit. When you think about Tryndamere who has RNG crits to autowin lanes and an invuln ult or Yi who has untargettable abilities as well as insane sticking power/on hit abuse... I don't see how Aatrox compares to either one as a carry. As a duelist, he was often times a worse Jax because at least Jax could offload his damage insanely quick, had shorter c/ds, could abuse CDR, had 2 super strong defensive abilities (E and R) and didn't require nearly as much offensive resources as Aatrox.
If we're talking today's game, new Aatrox is much more of a terror in a teamfight and hence, remains a consistent problem in pro play whereas new generation duelists like reworked Irelia literally heal for 80-100HP off 4-5 minions, have an on-demand damage reduction ability, is hyper mobile and has a better teamfight ultimate. Oh yeah, and she's hybrid between auto attacker and ability caster who can abuse trinity force procs on her Q lol. Let's not forget to mention Conqueror which has literally taken champions who had never conceived of the idea of sustain and now have it in spades. Why does Katarina have sustain? Why does Sylas have sustain? Who fucking knows, it's not like they sacrifice anything for it. Old Aatrox had to toggle between healing or doing damage, not getting both at the same time.
He didn't hit his intended thematic mark?
Isn't that something that should be up to the mains to decide? Why should you take someone else's champion, rework it and then cater it towards an entirely different crowd. It's literally disgusting. But just because it only happened to us and not a more popular player base it's accepted. The fucking hypocrites. I'd love for Ahri to be reworked into a tanky support or Lux to be reworked into a bruiser. I'm sure that'd sit well for all these normie goons. Lux is pretty binary don't you think? All she does is throw boring skill shots and doesn't do anything remotely unique or interesting am I right? That definitely warrants a complete rework right? Of course not.
I don't give a rat's ass if he didn't fit his theme for all you outsiders, WE, THE DEDICATED AATROX PLAYERS TOOK PRIDE IN PLAYING HIM, BORING TO YOU OR NOT. Why the fuck does any of your opinions matter when most of you guys didn't try him or tried him once, threw him in the trash, memed about him being the worst champion in the game, flamed aatrox players for picking aatrox and only after how many years of being mediocre/bad when he finally picked up traction and we developed a new OP build for him, did you guys all come out to complain about how 'broken he was'. lol stfu.