[{quoted}](name=Abyssal Armor,realm=EUW,application-id=3ErqAdtq,discussion-id=uIqeApch,comment-id=000b,timestamp=2015-12-10T18:54:38.385+0000)
Okay, im really curious. As what do you see Mordekaiser? Whenever i come to Mordekaiser threads, i get the impression that his fanbase like him because of his "Heavy Metal" (like in music theme instead of his armor) theme. Do you seem him more as such instead of a Undead Warlord like Overlord, Sauron or the Lich King?
This might sound slight offensive, but i actually do care about Mordekaiser and never actually saw him as the "Heavy Metal (Music)" Knight. More like a Fallen Knight with a giant mace. There is almost always the word "Heavy Metal" in a Mordekaiser thread, which lefts me kinda alienated because im not into it at all. It's really strange, so i thought i might contribute to the conversation.
To begin with, Mordekaiser is flawed, which is no secret. His kit and gameplay identitiy are a gigantic mess which reminds me of the old Sion. This is the first thing that has to be visualized before oneself, before talking about possible solution. Mordekaiser can only be improved and fixed if parts of him gets sacrificed and replaced with better and new elements. He can't be improved if he doesn't sacrifice some parts of him that makes him what he is. Just like Poppy, Trundle, Sion and more did. They had a dedicated fanbase but they got changed somewhat drastically from their former self, for the better!
Riot actually talked about making mordekaiser from AP to ad once, long ago, before obviously dumping that idea. I initially expected that they work on making Mordekaiser AD and finding a way to make him work that way. Think about it, he is a giant guy, with a giant mace, why doesn't he deal any physical damage outside of his basic attacks? It would open him up to new abilities and ways how to improve and fix his dilemma. Being AP restricts him, from the items he can use and the balancing that is possible. Why not allow him to be reinvented to an hard hitting AD Juggernaut? Perhaps then, he can finally secure his place in the Top Lane. Yes i know, AP Mordekaiser Mid was fun, but didn't make much sense either, it was either extreme feast or famine. The Iron Revenant will only be restored if his fanbase allows him to change ! Because change is what he needs, how can Riot fix him if his fanbase doesn't allow him to change and be open about new things? Don't get me wrong here, the dedication you and the other Mordekaiser mains have for him is very VERY admirable. Even getting his title to change and giving feedback and possible solutions on a regular basis.
AP Mordekaiser should die and be reborn as a AD Juggernaut with old improved and new abilities that truly suits the Iron Revenant.
Change passion for the old Mordekaiser to full commitment to improve and re-enhance the ancient Warlord. Let him experience the Phoenix Effect , so that he might find his true identitiy and place in the League of Legends!
One last thing, i think the Juggernaut update on Mordekaiser is a big fail expect for his Q, so i dont want him to get butchered, i really think this is a necessary step, otherwise Riot will be too scared or hesitate to change mordekaiser. Do we really want Mordekaiser to become the second Skarner ? No, you guys obviously deserve better, but have to change aswell instead of desperately trying to preserve all of Mordekaiser abilities and making them "slightly" better.
This is what i think about this whole situation.
His Q is the very reason why he got trashed statwise. Because of that is why he got butchered and his movement speed crippled. I'm up for changes, the thing is these changes weren't for the better and instead finished ruining the champion. He was given a nuke in exchange of every single tool in order to allow him to apply it himself, therefore, forcing him into a duo lane. Again, I'm up for changes but the thing is when your champion gets totally changed to serve another role outside yours then being up for changes is just irrelevant from that moment on. That is why I'm personally angry at them. For taking the champion from me and serving him to another different playerbase that only use him for the cheap stuff, but now that he's been "balanced" and all the artificial advantage shits the designers implemented on him are gone then nobody plays him for real. No mains, no Freelo Express riders alike, no one.
I played mostly main top lane Mordekaiser, and he was pretty damn good up there, granted, in the right hands.
I like Ranged Morde more than this version and if it were for me I would gladly sacrifice his Mace for the identity back.
You have very valid points, but the very reason we are pissed is because this rework was a total failure and alienated us from the champion we love. So these changes made us angry, and the "Change" mentality is irrelevant to us Morde players because these changes just took the champion away from us.