"Thought Experiment" post, what if melee and ranged items were separated?

Arya Riven·2/8/2017, 6:30:42 PM·25 votes·1,824 views

I always thought it was weird seeing Caitlyn buying swords and MF buying axes. I realize this would take a lot of work and would mean losing some classic memes/references to specific items. But what if they just had separate items?

Like, what if Melee's had Infinity Edge but Ranged champions had Infinity Bow(dumb name), which is essentially the same but balanced around ranged champions using it?

We have something similar with item 3085 and item 3074 but it is not 100% what I mean.

So for example. There could be: Blade of the Ruined King, for melees. And Ranged champions instead get Gun of Kravos(random name is random), which is essentially the same thing but balanced around ranged champions using it.

This means item diversity would not be really hurt, but we could balance range and melee items separately.

45 Comments

WoonStruck2/8/2017, 7:42:02 PM7 votes

You could effectively get the same results from melee/ranged distinctions on stats.

Two items for each purpose could make sense, but only if Riot desired it for the sake of 'immersion', and they would have to automatically swap on dual-form champs and kayle/aatrox.

TyrekGoldenspear2/8/2017, 6:44:30 PM6 votes

We don't have to do this with all the items, only the problematic ones.

Mostly the Lethality items. Just make them melee only and make new ranged Lethality items.

Chalizard2/8/2017, 6:37:36 PM2 votes

And what with Elise, Jayce, Nidalee?

Covert Ops Gnar2/8/2017, 9:39:30 PM1 votes

Riot's goal is to allow anything to be done in the game.

Which means not limiting support items to just support

or AP just to mages

or AD just to ADCs

If I want to build black cleaver and frozen mallet on soraka i better be allowed to do it

Pacattack252/9/2017, 1:03:01 AM1 votes

Gnar would get TOTALLY ****ed...

Papa Andrei2/9/2017, 1:55:33 AM1 votes

Kravos, new pirate, debonair king?!?!?! rito ples confirm

GankedFromBehind2/9/2017, 12:56:22 PM1 votes

Then we'd need a lot more items

doiminat0r36002/10/2017, 8:00:27 PM1 votes

I wish people would stop thinking they're original by saying things with a different wording than a post from a week ago.

Leo10242/8/2017, 7:35:29 PM1 votes

Please yes, so i don't get another Malphite in my ranked who not only built a death cap but a hurricane after

Unlucky472/8/2017, 7:57:36 PM1 votes

Someone mentioned in a lethality post that they should make it so it has reduced effectiveness on ranged champion and I think that would be the better way to do all of those