Can we get a new magic penetration item?

Ionian Vulpix··41 votes·2,180 views

With how easy it and health are to stack now, as well as the existence of Galio this pile of middle fingers to mages, it's even more difficult for mages to take out tanks. Can mages get something?

For comparison, there are 3 Magic penetration items in the game item 3151 item 3135 item 3020

While there are item 3147 item 3814 item 3036 item 3033 item 3071 item 3142

92 Comments

The Yetii Rider11 votes

The entire reason we got new MR items was because tanks were taking more magic damage than Riot wanted them to.

SpecterVonBaren20 votes

No, It's because there were only two MR choices for solo lane tanks and they only ever bought one of them, Spirit Visage.

Joxcab2 votes

To be fair, the other was so situational and bad it was barely even considerable a choice. But yeah I agree.

The Yetii Rider1 votes

{quoted}

No, It's because there were only two MR choices for solo lane tanks and they only ever bought one of them, Spirit Visage.

http://na.leagueoflegends.com/en/news/game-updates/patch/patch-79-notes

Source. Read Adaptive Helm. "Tanks are struggling to deal with sustained magic damage."

Voluug136 votes

And its useless for anything else.

Also ''sustained magic damage'' who??? Cass? Because aside cass there arent any mages with strong anti-tank magic damage. At least not strong enough to make AH ever, ever worth it.

The Yetii Rider1 votes

{quoted}

And its useless for anything else.

Also ''sustained magic damage'' who??? Cass? Because aside cass there arent any mages with strong anti-tank magic damage. At least not strong enough to make AH ever, ever worth it.

Sustained magic damage: Akali, Evelyn, Elise, Diana, Malzahar, Singed, Kayle, Teemo, Ekko

Fondling Gems1 votes

Throw Brand on top of that too, he is a huge tank shredder and his passive ticks over time meaning a lot of his damage is sustained.

Inting Pillow5 votes

Azir I'm surprised Azir who has as much sustained damage as an ADC has been forgotten

Divewing1 votes

Shurima's Lost Emperor

RainXBlade1 votes

In the near future, Riot will fix ruin his kit even further when they try to re-work him w/o removing his theme.

Variks the Loyal1 votes

There's also Syndra; Adaptive reduces the damage taken from her ultimate and repeated hits of her Q.

Bob the Toastr1 votes

TeemoRyze Rumble

Voluug132 votes

Ryze is trash outside LCS.

Teemo is a borderline troll pick that doesnt even build full magic damage anymore, Teemo AS/Hybrid is better.

I concede on Rumble. But that makes it 2.

RainXBlade1 votes

I don't recall Rumble being a spammy champion considering he's gated by his Heat silencing him. Then again, he's pretty obnoxious to fight when he's ahead and that good heat management allows him to spam his Q and E w/o any drawbacks.

Voluug131 votes

His play pattern (slow with harpoons -> flamethrower) makes AH kind of a good pick.

Problem is AH does very little against the rest of his team, specially since AP means AD top/jg.

OP Garen Support1 votes

Tanks are melting to ADC's not to mages. If riot cared about tanks melting they would have nor overnerfed the armor items. There was a lack of magic resist option so they created some.

GayFluffyUnicorn2 votes

So true. I don't even build mr on any champ at all. Even on kled where i pretty much build full tank the health from the armor items and titanic was more than enough to not even get tickled by the mage.

SteelMankind11 votes

Void Staff >>>> LW upgrades. Also, magic pen available on boots is much easier to itemize than a low gold-efficiency lethality tem

Morgan le Fey2 votes

Yeah. What most people don't realize about the two is that LW items only bypass bonus armor. Any base resists stay at their full values. Basically, armor from runes, masteries, items, and abilities is reduced (to hurt tanks - ADCs are designed to be the designated tank-killers), but built-in armor is untouched. Since flat applies before percent and, IIRC, flat applies to bonus armor first, this also means that flat lethality is less useful. If you take off 10 armor with lethality, and you have Last Whisper, you would've already ignored 4 of that 10 armor you removed. It's not taking it out of bases - you're making a %change to a smaller number.

Magic pen has the same issue with redundancy to some extent, but Void Staff bypasses bonus and base MR. That means the overall pool you're reducing is larger, and the percentage of the pool that you're taking off with flat pen is relatively smaller while still being the same in terms of actual value. Now, the numbers on Void Staff are a little smaller from a pure percentage standpoint, so LW's upgrades (just going to call them both Last Whisper from now on for simplicity's sake) are in theory better vs. tanks that build lots of bonus armor, but Void Staff helps against everyone rather than just resist-builders.

As a metaphor, imagine you're dealing with Kled, and you magic/armor penetration is %max health damage. Void staff would be like fighting Kled normally. It counts the combined health bar - both of Skarl's and Kled's together - as Kled's maximum health, meaning it does much more damage thanks to the much higher maximum health. Meanwhile, Last Whisper doesn't care - it only scales off of Skarl's HP, and ignores Kled's altogether. That said, it's bigger numbers, so when Skarl builds a lot of health, Last Whisper is better - thus, ADCs kill tanks well. However, when Skarl doesn't build much health, or, worse, when it's just Kled alone and he never even has Skarl (aka vs squishies), it's pretty much useless. It does nothing against Kled himself. Void Staff, despite its smaller numbers, does take Kled's HP into account when figuring out how much %max health damage to do. Thus, mages kill squishies really well.

LankPants2 votes

Really? As a tank player I can tell you that in almost all cases I don't give a fuck about Voidstaff. A mage with Voidstaff still isn't ever going to burst me down, I'd have to misplay massively to get killed by them. LW is a completely different animal. If an ADC or even someone like Riven gets one it feels like all of my bulk is completely fucking worthless.

SteelMankind3 votes

When it comes to mages, burst and artillery are pretty shit at killing tanks, and probably aren't even targeting you specifically, so any damage you do take from then is just random AOE/blocked skillshots.

Battle Mages on the other hand, will destroy tanks with their item 3135 item 3151 item 3116 . That's the entire reason for the existence of item 3194 - before that item, battle mages would tear through 1 MR item tanks like nothing

LordOfTheLeague1 votes

Most people don't make a difference between let's say Leblanc who is a burst mage that is totally not made to deal with tanks and Cassiopeia or Azir that have the dps to kill them almost as fast as a marksmen.

invisiblecat17 votes

Not to mention the desired stat of item 3020 and item 3151 , which cost 1100 gold, and 3100 gold respectively can be completely canceled out by the 450 gold item 1033 , while still giving 10 MR

ThePikol1 votes

Boots and Mask gives 15 magic pen, so 30 for both. Mantle gives 25 MR, so they aren't completely canceled, but I totally agree. 4200 gold shouldn't be negated by 450g item

BLACK REALM GOD1 votes

item 1057 720

invisiblecat11 votes

I was talking about how separately, once you get sorcerer shoes, the enemy can immediately just but Null-Magic Mantle, and save money

Ralanr6 votes

Mages are kinda meant to suck against tanks. You should be asking for more flat pen because now ADCs have MR (which was the reason imo why there were so few MR pen items).

LegendmakerGX1 votes

I don't think so I feel like mage are the thing that does most damage on tank reason being most of the time Top/ADC/Jungler and some times support are AD which tank would always build Armour to counter the 3 AD while ignoring 1 AP person which is mages. Just me opinion tho.

Ralanr2 votes

... Mages are burst. Tanks counter burst. That's why mages are not massive threats to tanks.

An Undead brat6 votes

AurelionSol Azir Cassiopeia Heimerdinger Karthus Malzahar Rumble Ryze Swain Vladimir Ziggs Zyra and I left out many DPS mages because they actually have burst, too.

Ralanr3 votes

And usually dps mages can hurt tanks well since resistances are better against burst than dps.

An Undead brat1 votes

Well that's not true either now since item 3194 exist, this item simply removes a champion, Idk why noone builds it, it's actually busted and was not necessary.

Voluug133 votes

Because teams dont have more that 1 champions its useful against, so its a worthless pick thanks to its extreme niche power.

Visage will always be better because its more generalistic and STILL helps against sustained damage.

Salron6 votes

Champions naturally gain far more base Armor than MR, it's only logical that we have more armor pen in the game Lethality as a flat stat is also weaker than magic pen due to it's scaling nature

Withitem 3020 and item 3136 you already penetrate 30/30 of range champions' lvl 1 MR Factor in Magic pen Marks and the Precision mastery and you have 43 flat total pen, which cuts through the majority of magic resist a ranged champion will have at level 18

Voluug133 votes

Errr, everyone gets natural scaling MR since the patch that also added AH.

SirTeemoMushroom5 votes

void stuff has 35% magic penetration though .. while you need 3 ad items for 30% of lethality . plus item 3033 item 3036 are armor penetration items not lethality which is kinda different thing

DJMason883 votes

Lethality works very differently from magic pen though

Chibi Zephyr3 votes

For the upteenth time, penetration is stronger v. targets with low resistances. For targets stacking resistances you're far better off focusing someone else. Voidstaffs %pen can still be moderately useful and torment's %hp burn will usually be helpful against resistance stacking champions too, since they normally build HP as well. Despite that, the penetration is much stronger v. those who do not have MR.

Violet Fields1 votes

And for the fact that they nerfed Precision just because it had too much lethality on it, riot didn't even think of the magic penetration being removed aswell.

GayFluffyUnicorn1 votes

Same as riot fucked DFT. When it was introduced i had so much fun taking it on a champ like ahri because the poking playstyle fit me into certain matchups or when they had too many tanky champs. Instead DFT gets a higher AD scaling and gets nerfed in the AP scaling as well because it is too stronk on jhin. topkek. It was essentially one or two mages "abusing" it. Brand and malz. That's it. Instead of nerfing them make the entire keystone trash for everyone.

SpecterVonBaren1 votes

Remove 5 flat pen from Sorcerer Shoes and Haunting Guise, adjust their prices accordingly and make a new AP item with 10 flat magic pen.

Bwuceleeroy1 votes

ummmm item 3091 item 3001

ThePikol2 votes

item 3091 is not good for Mages, nor is Mask.

Bwuceleeroy1 votes

says who?

ThePikol2 votes

Idk, everyone? Have you seen Ahri Annie Cassiopeia Karthus Lux Malzahar Syndra Velkoz buy any of these?

BLACK REALM GOD1 votes

yes. karthus and malzahar especially. then there's the fact that lux can yoink 5 magic resist every time she basic attacks to pop her illumination.

OP Garen Support1 votes

I main Malzahar and I never bought those troll items. This is a Malzahar build : item 3157 item 3089 item 3165 item 3020 item 3116 item 3151

Tell me where you see these items: item 3091 item 3001

BLACK REALM GOD1 votes

{quoted}

I main Malzahar and I never bought those troll items. This is a Malzahar build : item 3157 item 3089 item 3165 item 3020 item 3116 item 3151

Tell me where you see these items: item 3091 item 3001

as in 1 of many.

this is also a malzahar build

item 3001 item 3091 item 3071 item 3065 item 3812 item 3033

not saying it's a good build, but it is a build.

item 3091 item 3115 item 3006 item 3142 item 3087 item 3116 is another one.

OP Garen Support1 votes

Hey ultimate bravery challange item builds dont count :P

OP Garen Support1 votes

wtf :D Have you seen any mage building those? I main mages since season 4 from silver to platinum and never seen anyone building item 3091 on mages. I seen that item used like 5 times over the years on auto attack based champion like old Warwick and maybe Kayle .

This is a tipical mage build : item 3157 item 3089 item 3165 item 3020 item 3116 item 3135

More from Gameplay

More by Ionian Vulpix