What would GP really lose if Parrrley was treated as ranged?

Anonagon··2 votes·507 views

Currently, Gangplank's Q, Parrrley, triggers on-hit effects as if it were a melee autoattack. Because of this, almost all GPs have taken to using the Bandit mastery, which gives 10 gold on hitting an enemy champion with a melee autoattack. A lot of people have said that this is a problem, as it makes GP incredibly hard to shut down and makes the choice of whether to use his Q for farm or for harass much less important.

This begs the question, aside from the Bandit mastery, what would Gangplank lose if Parrrley were changed to work like a ranged auto rather than a melee one? These are all the on-hit effects in the game that either are melee only or work differently for ranged and melee champions: item 3074 /item 3748 (melee only) item 3742 (does no damage and doesn't slow, still discharges momentum) item 3044 /item 3078 (half movement speed value for ranged) item 3022 (30% slow on ranged, rather than 40%)

Importantly, of these the only one Gangplank builds is Phage/Trinity Force, and the Phage passive isn't the major reason why he buys it. That means that if the Bandit mastery abuse is a problem, Riot can simply have GP's Q be classified as ranged rather than melee and the problem will be solved with minimal collateral damage. Of course, Gangplank is rather balanced after is last set of nerfs, though still strong in the right hands, so whether or not he actually needs nerfs is up for debate. But if he does need nerfs again sometime soon, changing Q to be classified as ranged would be a good move.

10 Comments

Ralanr1 votes

Do you want hurricane parleys?

Anonagon1 votes

It would be interesting, but sadly Runaan's is an on-attack effect, not an on-hit effect, so it wouldn't work.

specter4241 votes

Parrley applies on attack effects

Anonagon1 votes

I guess I should be more specific, because the line between on-hit and on-attack is really blurry when it comes to things like Parrrley - It doesn't apply for Ezreal's Q, so it wouldn't apply for GP's Q

Nagoh Shan1 votes

It would because parley is an AA replacer that would change his range type. It would work like Kayle E, not Ez Q.

Parley is an auto attack, and he would become ranged for it, so Hurricane would work.

Ralanr1 votes

Basically his pistol becomes a blunderbuss.

Edit: actually that's fucking awesome. Let's do that!

Astôlfo1 votes

Oe you could just make an exception that prevents Bandit from interacting with it instead?

Anonagon1 votes

special cases are bad for game health, they degenerate clarity it could also be argued that GP's Q applying melee effects on a ranged attack limits future item design space and makes his balance potentially volatile

Astôlfo1 votes

True enough.

MunchCrunchLunch1 votes

a lot

More from Gameplay

More by Anonagon