Annie summon tibbers should be a projectile teddy bear monster that rips your fucking kidneys out.
On impact it should make a fiery deathball of fur and chaos.
I suggest we make her ultimate a projectile skillshot like corki phospherous bomb, nerf her basic abilities and then buff the living hell out of tibbers.
I'm talking about tibbers being a fucking monster with 150 / 250 / 350 armor and magic resist, 3000 / 4000 / 5000 health, and auto attacks that hit like udyr and bleed you out like darius. And he shouldn't be a lumbering zombie, he should be feral and vicious-- activating R again would cause him to dash into that direction, like a sejuani, and start ripping people apart. Annie should be able to heal Tibbers and infuse him with attack speed by casting a damage dealing spell on him, which gives her the ability to channel her ENTIRE kit into Tibbers and allows us to make peak Tibbers strength comparable to shyvanna.
In case you are wondering how something with the damage of shyvanna and tankiness of malphite and can heal as fast as mundo and enormous mobility could possibly be balanced, its quite simple-- Tibber's achilees heel is annie herself. If she dies, Tibbers goes away, so she has to play carefully with the bear and not get too greedy.
Lets not make annie just another cookie cutter burst mage. We have those already. Lets make her less about doing damage directly with her spells and more about being a tiny diabolical summoner, and make tibbers a monster.
's pet dragon mechanic to Annie?

can shit on Annie too?
would be terrifying and awesome at the same time
in a nut shell
"Oooh, look! A little girl alone in the woods!"